From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article
Roger Howarth as Todd Manning
|One Life to Live character|
|First appearance||December 1992|
|Last appearance||August 5, 2013|
|Created by||Michael Malone|
|Book appearances||Patrick's Notebook|
Trevor St. John as Todd Manning
Roger Howarth as Todd Manning
|One Life to Live character|
|First appearance||December 1992|
|Last appearance||August 5, 2013|
|Created by||Michael Malone|
|Book appearances||Patrick's Notebook|
Trevor St. John as Todd Manning
Thomas Todd Manning is a fictional character originated on the American daytime drama One Life to Live (OLTL). Created by writer Michael Malone, the role was originated in 1992 by actor Roger Howarth. Todd was a college student and fellow fraternity brother to Kevin Buchanan, Zach Rosen, and Powell Lord. Todd was originally intended to be a short-lived role, but Howarth's portrayal was popular with the audience, and he was showcased more regularly on the show. He became part of a ground-breaking storyline, the gang rape of Marty Saybrooke. The story's main players—Howarth, Susan Haskell (Marty), and Hillary B. Smith (Todd's lawyer Nora Hanen)—won Emmys in 1994, as did Malone and his writing team. Howarth left the role in 2003; the role was recast by Trevor St. John, physically altered by plastic surgery. In 2011, Howarth returned to OLTL; it was disclosed that he had been taken hostage and that St. John's version of the character was really Todd's twin brother Victor Lord, Jr., conditioned to assume Todd's place.
Todd was initially a short-term villain, but his popularity inspired the writers to forgo killing him or permanently sending him to prison, like most soap operas had done with rapists in the past. They layered Todd, having him exhibit a conscience and compassion. While keeping aspects of his personality dark or otherwise violent, they took steps to redeem him and make him an integral part of OLTL's canvas, despite Howarth's objections to a redemption storyline. The writers used literary techniques for the redemptive arc, borrowing from nineteenth-century melodrama and Gothic traditions, and great literature such as Frankenstein. Todd was revealed to be the product of an affair between his father, Victor Lord, and his mother, Irene Manning, which provided him with ties to other major characters, including his sisters, Tina and Victoria Lord. An important aspect of the character became his appearance, most notably the scar on his right cheek, which served to remind Todd of his past misdeeds against Marty. The scar later became synonymous with him. Music and the use of humor were key to the development of Todd, especially when Howarth portrayed him. Although Todd formed many relationships during his tenure on OLTL (including with his wives, Blair Cramer and Téa Delgado), and fathered children, a defining characteristic of his personality was his resistance to close relationships and sexual intimacy.
The drive to redeem Todd eventually drew Howarth, who always saw Todd as a villain, to eventually leave the show for a year; he was uncomfortable with the redemption storyline and with many fans' positive reactions to Todd. Recasting Todd years later with St. John was generally considered successful by viewers and critics. St. John, instead of imitating Howarth's portrayal, brought his own spin to the character. After OLTL's cancellation in 2012, Howarth brought Todd to General Hospital (GH), but returned, along with St. John as Victor, Jr., to the online version of OLTL in 2013, which was cancelled after one year.
Todd has been the subject of numerous soap opera articles, feminist studies, and inspired the creation of a doll in his likeness. He has remained a popular and controversial figure since his creation, and is considered one of soap opera's breakout characters.
Todd Manning, created by Michael Malone and originated by Roger Howarth in December 1992, was a young college student attending Llanview University who played defensive back for the university's football team and was fraternity brother to Kevin Buchanan, Zach Rosen and Powell Lord. Todd was originally intended to be a short-lived role, but Howarth's portrayal of the character inspired notable fan reaction, which prompted the creators to layer Todd's personality and showcase him regularly within the series. Malone said fleshing out the villain reminded him of what he loved about soap operas. "The story-telling is a genuine collaboration, not just among writers but by the actors", he said. Malone felt he could not take full credit for the development of the character from Marty Saybrooke's gang rapist to what the character later became, and also noted Howarth's impact:
In the creation of Todd Manning, no one played a larger role than the remarkably talented Josh Griffith, first associate head writer, then co-head writer, during my stay at One Life. Josh loved, lived and breathed Todd and fought passionately for his position on the show. Second, Todd never would have evolved from "first frat boy" to the major cast member he became without the powerful talent of Roger Howarth. Because of Roger's ability to convey the complexity of Todd (the hurt as well as anger, the insecurity as well as bluster, the brains, yearning, manipulativeness, sexiness, tenderness, nastiness) we were able to explore both the deeply dark side of this character (the effort to destroy Marty to cover the rape, the attempted revenge on his lawyer Nora, the attack on Luna) and at the same time slowly uncover his growing struggle (usually a failed struggle) towards some kind of redemption. Romantic leads have often begun their careers playing villains (Valentino, Clark Gable, Humphrey Bogart among them). These characters appeal because they make women feel both the thrill of the "bad" and the lure of the hidden "good": they can lead the man to change through love. "I'll save him!" Fans loved Todd from the beginning because he always had that appeal.
Malone originally scripted Todd as a serial rapist. It was disclosed during the 1993 rape storyline, when the character instigated the gang rape of fellow student Marty Saybrooke (Susan Haskell), that he raped another character, Carol Swift, a year or two before raping Marty, and there were hints that he raped other young women before Carol. The character is at first presented as 18 years old, but over the years, his age has been changed based upon the occasional rapid aging of his children.
Howarth called Todd, the product of an affair between Victor Lord and Irene Manning, "privileged and very rich". Malone gave the character the last name "Manning" without knowing the name of Victor's mistress, an oversight that allowed the writers to later reveal Todd as Tina and Victoria Lord's brother. Malone stated that making Todd heir to the Lord fortune gave the writers "huge story" that helped Howarth's character evolve from a short-term role to a major cast member, which Malone attributed to Howarth's "powerful talent". In December 1994, Todd discovered, in the midst of a storyline in which con man David Vickers tried to claim the Lord fortune and "corrupt" Tina Lord, that he was adopted. Peter Manning, who Todd thought was his father, died and Todd received letters written by his adoptive mother disclosing that he was the Lord heir, and worth almost $30 million. Developing Todd not only as Victoria's unwanted sibling, whom she was horrified to discover was her blood, but as "her professional rival" who used "a splashy tabloid newspaper to wipe out her venerable Banner" appealed to Malone.
Executive producer Susan Bedsow Horgan, when speaking of Todd's psychological motivations, reported that Peter Manning degraded him verbally and abused his mother, whom Todd loved but who abandoned and disappointed him, leaving Todd with wounds that influenced his later behavior. Author Gerry Waggett stated that Peter Manning had physically abused Todd his entire life.
In late 1993, in order to make Todd look more menacing, he was given a "nasty-looking" scar to his right cheek by Marty's friend, Luna Moody, when she hit him in his face with a crowbar while preventing his second physical attack on Marty. The camera would often close in and emphasize Todd's scar, which later became synonymous with the character.
According to casting director Howard Meltzer, "Todd wears the scar like a badge. It's a warning to others: Don't mess with me". Meltzer felt Howarth underplayed Todd; Todd did not have to rant to incite fear. Meltzer went to say about Howarth's performance: "He gets a lot more from the raising of an eyebrow than raising the volume of his voice. Most of Todd’s performance is reacting to the environment around him, and thanks to Howarth’s expressiveness, viewers can see the wheels turning". The scar also served as a reminder to Todd of his past villainy against Marty. It was applied by glue, with a little makeup to make it look more authentic, and usually took 10 minutes to apply.
Todd's hair was also integral to the character. It was described as "enigmatic, with an air of innate authority". The hair was said to demonstrate Todd's lack of pretense and to convey an "I don’t care" attitude. Todd's "overhanging brow" seemed threatening, but instead concealed "the "intense, vulnerable eyes underneath", features that contrasted well with the character's "pouty, sensual mouth". The features, which conferred "a charming, boyish quality", could sometimes convey that Todd was less dangerous than he actually was. According to photographer Robert Milazzo, Howarth's hair softened Todd's character, and added, "You don’t expect that intensity because of it," he said, and felt that it made Todd more intriguing. Milazzo also stated that the combination of Todd's soft hair and intensity made Todd "a very complex character to look at".
In November 2008, when St. John portrayed the character, Todd was given a new scar by John McBain during a physical altercation in which John beats Todd with a gun. The scar symbolized Todd's "second rape of Marty" and history with her, and was considered "a poetic nod" to Todd's history. The scar was significantly smaller than the original but placed in the same spot; it was gone by January 2009. St. John stated, "I know. It's too bad. I honestly have no idea why they wouldn't keep that reminder on Todd's face. It might be an economical thing. You know it costs to apply that kind of makeup each day."
The most important aspect of Todd's appearance for St. John was his character's hair. His preference was that Todd's hair was a little shorter; he told Soap Opera Weekly (SOW) that he thought that Todd's hair was too "shaggy", which was not his personal style, and that he hoped the writers and producers would let him trim off a bit. When he first got the role, St. John's hair resembled Howarth's shorter shoulder-length haircut, which was initially worn from 2000 to 2003, and St. John was told by the writers and producers not to change his hair until further notice. St. John "made the creative choice [to let himself] go because [Todd's] not really right in the old noggin'", and gained weight for the role.
One Life to Live's producers stated that most of the show's music was custom written, suitable for the situation and what the characters in the scene might actually play. For Todd, his volatile nature was represented with powerfully dark theme music, which producers and fans called the "Todd theme". The music consisted of ominous low chords and signaled that Todd was about to commit a vicious, dangerous, or threatening act. The theme was especially evident in Howarth's portrayal, but it continued during St. John's early portrayal as well.
Composer David Nichtern, who created Todd's theme music, said he loved the character and enjoyed implementing the different versions of the Todd theme. While describing the music that marked Todd's prominent 1996 "return from the dead", Nichtern addressed the broader aspect of his composition for the character:
All of Todd's music has had a certain "vibe" to it, especially since the character is so well-drawn. It also has seemed particularly well-suited to my guitar style, so I've enjoyed "becoming" Todd musically. The key is always to represent his dark side, but with the possibility of redemption and power behind the whole thing. That's what makes him such an interesting character. Todd's cues are always custom-made so to speak, so there is energy and attention going toward getting the exact flavor of what the current story-line is saying about his journey.
Three primary musical themes were played throughout Todd's evolution. The original Todd theme, from 1993 to 1996, encompassed Todd's rape of Marty and his early misdeeds. The second theme was heard throughout 1998 and 2000, and the third theme was first heard in 2001. The 1993 rape sequence was scored almost entirely with popular rock songs. The lead-up to the rape, during the fraternity party, included hard-edged songs playing at low volume in the background, which intensified "the underlying tense, aggressive atmosphere", and was described as "chilling". When Todd reached his turning point and decided to rape Marty, the volume of the song being played ("Head Like a Hole") was increased, which made the lyrics clear: "I'd rather die/Than give you control." This use of background music allowed Todd's motivation for the rape to significantly register with viewers.
There have been additional musical themes for Todd; for example, the "minous chords", which played as he stalked Nora Gannon in 1993 for mishandling his trial and sending him to prison. During his romance with Rebecca Lewis in 1994, a sweeping romantic theme with tragic undertones, which was "sometimes interspersed" with the former ominous music, were heard. His rescue of Marty and two children and the Todd and Téa romance have their own themes. In mid-1994, when Todd rescued Marty and two children from a car crash, "his change of heart was reflected by a change in music". His dominant theme then becomes "a tuneful, forward moving piece". This theme is used regularly throughout Todd's 1994 redemption storyline and later when he becomes the Lord heir in 1995. According to Nichtern, the music for Todd and Teá, which he composed with his friend keyboardist Kevin Bents, was "as close as we get to Todd 'romantic' music", with "the possibility of a little sensuality and romance".
In August 1996, for the Todd "returns from the dead" storyline following several months of absence, an "on-edge, demented sound", which signifies that Todd has "once again undergone a psychological change, this time for the worse", is introduced. This theme accompanied Todd's emotional breakdown and revenge scheme after discovering his wife, Blair Cramer, having sex with Patrick Thornhart.
At the time of Todd's introduction to OLTL, he was a competitive athlete. His fraternity was the most important part of his life, and he was "under intense pressure from the male figures in his life". Howarth felt that the key to understanding the character was his concern about his status and how others perceived him. Howarth thought that Todd mistreated people because it made him feel better about himself and that he did not want to appear vulnerable, so his defense mechanisms "spun out of control". Trevor St. John, Todd's second portrayer, described the character as "kind of both good and bad. He’s got his good side with his kids, and yet he is conniving and vicious and all those negative things".
During an April 1994 Soap Opera Update interview, Howarth said that the only thing that he admired about Todd was his clothing style. His interviewer, who called Todd's fashion sense "grunge, Salvation Army like 'rags', and Howarth described it as "all Ralph Lauren" and "[d]ouble R.L. 80 dollar pants and a 400-and-something-dollar jacket". Howarth, in the same interview, expressed his discomfort with the character's popularity, stating that he found it disturbing people could romantically desire a character he considered unhealthy. "I don't get it," he said. "I don't want to insult anybody, but I don't know why he's attractive". When the interviewer concluded Howarth's good looks may have contributed to the character's magnetism, Howarth said, "I know what the convention of a good-looking person is, and I know that for some reason skinny white guys are big now. I guess you could blame it on that".
For several years on the series, a defining characteristic of Todd's personality was his resistance to close relationships and sexual intimacy, which were due to his mistreatment by others (especially his adoptive father) and his horrific past misdeeds, including his rape of Marty and dysfunctional aspects of his relationship with Blair. Todd was bitter after surviving a near-death experience and being presumed dead in 1995, although when he returned in 1996, he emotionally "shut down" after catching Blair having sex with Patrick. The writers made Todd's fear of intimacy into a prominent obstacle for his relationship with Téa Delgado, whom he married after offering her $5 million in order to ensure his custody of his daughter Starr. Todd's difficulties are manifested in his nightmares, which give him insomnia and are designed as a look into his soul and personality; Téa attempts to help him by encouraging him to open up to her about them, which he eventually does. At one point, Téa attempts to seduce Todd by stripping down naked in front of him and pleading with him to make love to her, but he rejects her, explaining that he no longer trusts himself to be intimate in that way; he subsequently throws her out into the middle of a snowstorm.
Todd is portrayed by the show's writers to always remain one step ahead of his enemies, consistently out-smarting police, family, and anyone else he targets, often using weapons. In one storyline, he takes fourteen of his friends and family hostage, using fake dynamite because he knew it would incite fear in his victims. He then fakes dissociative identity disorder in order to avoid a prison sentence, something that devastated his sister Victoria, who had actually suffered from the disorder. When Todd, as portrayed by Trevor St. John, fights for the custody of his son Sam in 2006, he is motivated by anger that he has been lied to and revenge more than by a desire to recover his child.
When asked to compare his personality with that of the character he portrayed, Howarth said, "I think when it comes to creating a character for a soap opera they have to go with an archetype, one that's recognizable." Writer Jennifer Hayward felt the same, stating that like 19th century melodrama and serials, soap operas draw on powerful archetypes. Writer Dianne L. Brooks states that the storyline conforms to many of the same conventions of how rape has been presented in soap operas. According to Hayward, the OLTL writers "had a terrific time camping up Todd as the embodiment of evil". She said that the writers who created Todd's first major storyline, the gang rape of Marty Saybrooke and its aftermath, treated rape like most soaps had done in the past, by using archetypes such as the fight between good and evil and the contrast between the weak and strong. Author Gerry Waggett said, "The close-ups of the rapists' faces during the assault, distorted to capture Marty's scared and drunken perspective, rank among the show's most graphic images". An attempt was made to dramatize the rape, and to present it differently than the typical voyeuristic perspective, and were designed to disturb the audience. Waggett added: "Marty's subsequent quest to bring her rapists to justice dominated the show" throughout the summer of 1993.
Up to this point, soap operas used rape and its related archetypes to, like their nineteenth-century melodrama counterparts, "critique power relationships, especially the oppression of the poor by the rich and of women by men". Hayward believes that the storyline was initially flawed because two of the rapists, Todd and Zach, were demonized, which oversimplified rape and "failed to capture the complex power relations underlying...violence towards women". The perpetrators were "simply evil or out control", so they and their mindsets they represented could be rejected. The three characters represented three archetypes of the rapist: "the evil instigator" (Todd); "the good resister" (Powell), and "the mediator between these polarized figures" (Zach), but also represented a departure from how rape was treated in soaps. Brooks called the rapists "a complicated alternative to the standard soap opera rapist", because they had a different relationship with their victim than in previous rape narratives and because they were multiple. Todd, whom Brooks called the "evil 'other'", was the leader and most villainous of the group and had a previous physical relationship with Marty. Hayward states, "What becomes especially clear is that for these characters the act of rape is not about sex, about women, or even about Marty. It is about what takes place...between men". Howarth considered Todd's rationale for raping Marty as a complex matter. "Todd was in love with Marty," he said. It upset Todd that she did not reciprocate his feelings and rejected him, and when he failed an exam, he became frustrated and instead of accepting the responsibility for it, he blamed her for his problems.
Like serials throughout history, soap operas use the unstable identity as a literary device, which is evidenced by the genre's use of mistaken identities, evil twins, and characters that suffer from multiple personality disorder and whom come back from the dead. Identity is used in the rape storyline as well. Before the rape, Todd was crude yet still human, but afterwards, he became a dehumanized embodiment of rage, demonstrated by Todd's bizarre and dangerous behavior after his conviction. Powell Lord, whose name is full of the same kind of symbolism Dickens used when choosing his characters' names and who initially urges his friends to let Marty go yet ultimately gives into peer pressure, is a "relative 'good'" character as compared to Todd's "'absolute evil' identity". In Hayward's opinion, "The show also departs from the rape paradigm not only by insisting on the essential 'goodness' of Powell Lord...but even more startlingly by redeeming the evil Todd". Initially, "the increasingly guilt-ridden" Powell is the only rapist who has a conscience. He attempts to convince Todd and Zach to confess their crime, and comes close to confessing to his lawyer. Hayward calls Powell, like Todd, "redeemed", but unlike Todd, was so guilt-ridden that he committed suicide, was forgiven by Marty, and received a much lighter jail sentence than Zach or Todd.
Initially, Todd was written as "unequivocally bad: sullen, remorseless, charmless". As Todd's popularity grew with the audience, mostly due to Howarth's abilities to portray Todd as more than a one-dimensional rapist, Malone and executive producer Susan Bedsow Horgan chose the controversial option of redeeming Todd rather than killing him off or permanently sending him to prison, which is what soap operas had usually done with irredeemable rapists in the past. According to Hayward, the writers began to "redeem" Todd, or change him so that he could be incorporated into the show, in the spring of 1994, a year after the rape. Hayward states that it required "a whole arsenal of symbolic weaponry", something that had never happened in soap operas before. Malone was intrigued by crafting the story in this way, and saw it as the spiritual journey of a man who wanted forgiveness for his past misdeeds.
Malone stated that Todd believes that he does not deserve forgiveness, which contributes to him embracing his worst qualities, something Malone felt worked better due to Howarth's acting choices, which prevented Todd from acquiring redemption easily. Malone felt the most important part of Todd's redemption was to have him re-confront Marty in order to better deal with the fact he initiated her rape. In addition to having Todd risk his freedom from prison and save Marty from a car crash, he donates his own blood to Marty to ensure she survives. A year later, Todd risks his life to save Patrick, Marty's lover, from death; this act leads to Todd's presumed death. Despite having the character yearn to be thought of as a decent human being, the writers felt his good deeds should never make him feel any less horrible for having raped Marty. Initially, Howarth disagreed, and did not consider the storylines to be redemptive. "[Todd's] not being redeemed at all," he said. "Todd, as I see it, is looking for a way to overcome this rage so he can live in society again. From now on, his menace will be on the surface, not exploding. It's more interesting if his violence is on the surface and that he play against it. That's where the subtlety is."
Hayward stated that the writers turned Todd from a realistic soap opera character into "the villain appropriated from nineteenth-century melodrama and Gothic traditions". After Todd was sent to prison for Marty's rape, he vowed he would escape, and did so by drugging himself and by forcing himself to wake up from a coma, which allowed him to escape from a speeding ambulance. He returned to Llanview to stalk Nora, the lawyer who threw his court case, who had gone temporarily blind. He tried to rape Marty for the third time, killed Marty's boyfriend Suede, kidnapped the evangelist Rebecca Lewis, and was shot by the police, but survived. The writers also began to deepen his character by emphasizing his tenderness towards Rebecca and showing flashbacks of the abuse he experienced from his father, which Hayward states does not "historicize the problem but simply removes the cause of violence one step". Laurie Stone of the Village Voice, however, stated that Howarth's performance steered Todd away from cartoon villainy, "heightening the character's wildness as a dodge from sentimentality and high-mindedness". Instead of killing Todd off as other soaps had done to other unrepentant rapists, OLTL chose, as Stone put it, "to renovate the genre: maintaining Todd as a rapist, while enlarging his human dimension". Stone went on to state, speaking of how the writers kept Todd on the OLTL canvas:
Characters as dangerous as Todd go up in flames on soaps. You can see little coffins on their eyelids, leaving only one question: how will the fiend get whacked? Todd was this close to being offed, but Howarth made that choice laughable. Rampaging through fictional Llanview, he injected ambiguity into the bluntest dialogue, his sneers averting cynicism to reveal depression and humor. He transformed Todd into a soul-wrenched Lucifer, his rage ripped from abuse and bathed in vengeful glee, his sexiness rising off his instinct for survival and his outlaw impulse to disrupt. Even the ragged scar he acquired on one cheek only heightened his animal appeal. No soap would jettison such gold and electricity--a figure simultaneously furious, ironic, melancholy, and horny.
The writers used strong imagery to redeem Todd. Malone, who had been a novelist and was known for his "Dickensian" plots on OLTL, was clearly influenced by nineteenth-century literature. Malone told Stone that he compared Rebecca's decision to marry Powell instead of Todd with Cathy's decision to marry Edgar Linton instead of Heathcliff in Wuthering Heights. According to Stone, Todd is a classical character−"a soap character of unprecedented psychological complexity, a being whose feelings are intrinsically mixed and mostly unresolvable". He is an angry character, whose impulses that made him a rapist remain, even after he understands them, and even after he becomes capable of love.
In Hayward's view, Malone and his team of writers used four techniques drawn from the conventions of Victorian sentimental fiction to redeem Todd: his unhappy childhood with an aloof but caring mother and abusive father; sending Todd to church to confess his past sins and present impulses; his love for Rebecca, "an innocent and highly religious virgin"; and his friendship with two children, Sarah and C.J. Hayward calls Rebecca, with her "open-mouthed passivity" and "pre-Raphaelite curls", "almost a caricature of Dicken's more sentimental and less felicitous heroines". Hayward believes that many of Todd's scenes with Rebecca are heavily iconic, with symbolic representations of the Virgin Mary and other Freudian images of Todd's own feminization, but "seems to encourage both female and male fantasies about the power of a 'good woman' to save a man from his own violent impulses".
Hayward compares Todd's friendship with Sarah and C.J. with scenes in Frankenstein, in which the monster interacts with village children. Mary Shelley's monster watches two children playing, and similarly, Todd rescues Sarah and C.J.'s cousin, Jessica Buchanan, which leads to meeting the children. Like Shelley's monster, Todd observes the family's happy moments from afar, and wishes to be part of their lives. He uses his time alone to make toys for the children. Once they accidentally discover him, he manipulates them into keeping his whereabouts a secret by telling them he is "a genie on the run from an evil master". Hayward says, "The stories he tells them function as clear metaphors for his feelings about his father". Stone adds Todd's counseling sessions in prison to the writer's attempts to redeem Todd, and both she and Hayward include one of the final techniques the writers used: Todd's rescue of Marty and one of the children he befriended after a car crash. Hayward, however, calls the writers' attempts to use powerful narrative and visual techniques to redeem Todd "dubious at best".
Writer Mary D. Dutta believed that OLTL, in order to "assuage the moral qualms associated with a sympathetic rapist", added "mitigating reasons for Todd's sexual abuse of Marty"; namely, that he was sexually abused at the age of 14 by his adoptive father Peter Manning. Dutta feels that the gang rape storyline invokes many of the rape myths that have appeared in literature since the 18th century, which includes "only bad girls get raped," "women ask for it," and "women 'cry rape' only when they've been jilted or have something to cover up". Dutta also includes the myth of the "reformed rake", or "the rapist redeemed by the woman who loves him, not uncommonly the same woman he raped". which "deny or reduce perceived injury, or ... blame the victims for their own victimization". Dutta states, "Todd's redemption begins with his rescue of Marty and two children from a car wreck and ends with the discovery that he is the rightful heir to a huge fortune".
Following Howarth's 1992 casting as Todd Manning, he occasionally vacated the role. His 2003 departure was his longest absence from OLTL; he did not return to the series until 2011. Todd was recast in 2003 with St. John, and Howarth joined As the World Turns as Paul Ryan until it was cancelled in 2010. Malone stated that because of Todd's appeal, which he credited to Howarth, "The network was therefore happy to have him return to Llanview whenever Roger would come back, and happy to have him move into story in major ways." In April 2011, after several months of speculation, OLTL confirmed Howarth's return, although it was unclear if he would portray Todd Manning. He stated, "I am looking forward to returning to One Life to Live". Valentini said, "We are thrilled to have Roger return to One Life to Live". It was eventually revealed that St. John's version of the character was really Victor Lord, Jr., Todd's twin brother, conditioned to believe that he was Todd and assume Todd's identity, while the real Todd (Howarth) was held hostage for eight years.
OLTL was cancelled in early 2012; Howarth brought Todd to General Hospital (GH), along with his co-stars Kristen Alderson as Starr and Michael Easton as John McBain. All three actors were forced to briefly leave GH when Prospect Park, the company that bought the rights to OLTL and aired an online version of the show in 2013, sued ABC for breach of contract. Prospect Park claimed that ABC sabotaged its efforts by killing off two characters, Starr's boyfriend Cole and her young daughter Hope. Both St. John and Howarth appeared on the online version as Victor and Todd, but the suit prevented ABC from continuing to feature Howarth, Alderson, and Easton as their original characters on GH; ABC's solution was to create new characters for the actors. The online version of OLTL was cancelled after one season.
Malone credited Howarth's versatility with the reason he was cast as Todd, as well as why he became an important part of the show's cast, and one of the contributing factors for the character's subsequent complexity. During a February 2, 1993 interview with Soap Opera Digest (SOD), Howarth stated he was surprised he won the part. "I really don't know how I made it," he said. He met a One Life to Live casting director two years previously, while performing in a New York play, but when the role opened up, he "auditioned just like everybody else". Howarth said, "I made it to callbacks, and I got the part." He also stated, "I was happy to get the part of Todd, but it was the furthest thing from the fabric of my personality." In an interview later that year, with Soap Opera Weekly, he grimaced when reminded of what he had said, and said, "What a totally self-involved, pretentious thing to say." He clarified his previous statement, saying that although he seemed to be consistently cast as a "bad guy" and as a "Greek frat brother-type", both his upbringing and experiences in college were different than those of Todd and his other roles. For example, Howarth was not in a fraternity in college, and unlike Todd and his previous soap opera roles, Kent in Loving and Jory on Guiding Light, status was unimportant to him.
Although Howarth was familiar with campus fraternity life while attending George Washington University, he did not base Todd or his other roles on anyone he knew. When asked about his roles, he was unable to explain why he was cast in them, but said that he enjoyed them. He stated, "I would never want to come in now and play a nice guy for three months. That would be dreadfully boring. This suits me fine. It's just as easy to pretend I'm a bad guy as it is to pretend I'm a good guy". For Howarth, playing a rapist was like playing any other role because "I know it's all make-believe". Howarth was perplexed by the need for writers to redeem villains. "Todd's a pretty interesting character just the way he is", he said in late 1994. "There's no need to fix it if it's not broken. I don't know where the whole notion of redeeming characters comes from. People used to say to me, 'I hope you get redeemed so you can stay on the show.' Well, Todd hasn't been redeemed, and he's still on the show." Howarth continued, "I don't love the character I play. If I met Todd on the street, I wouldn't say 'Hi' to him, but I do love playing this character".
During Howarth's portrayal, the show's writers presented Todd's personality as a combination of dark humor, uncouth behavior, and the essence of a tortured soul. Todd would often deliver one-liners that ranged from humorous to sadistic. In 1997 and 1998, he was given comedic partners similar to the set-up in comedy teams, in which the "funny guy" usually has a "straight man" who either sets up the joke or simply does not understand it. Todd's first partner was Charlie Briggs, portrayed by actor Robert J. Hogan. Hogan was first seen as Briggs in 1995, working for the rival publication The Banner before Todd "[steals] him away" to work at his newspaper. Hogan said, "Briggs had been on the show for 17 years, but they never showed him." Scenes between Todd and Briggs typically involved Todd issuing "some bizarre order" to Briggs, or Todd asking Briggs a "way-out question" that was often "way out of line". During these scenes, Briggs would often respond with a stupefied look on his face. Though Briggs appeared lost at some of Todd's comments, Todd was sometimes unable to realize that the joke was about him. Hogan felt Briggs was "more than a match" for Todd. "You look at a kid yelling at you," he said, "and you can't take him seriously".
Another of Todd's comedic pairings is his friendship with a parrot he names Moose. Todd is closer to Moose than he is to most humans. He tells the bird his private thoughts and secrets, which causes conflict and antagonism between Moose and his wife at the time, Téa. Actress Florencia Lozano, Téa's portrayer, clarified: "My character...has a very adversarial relationship with the bird...It's sort of jealous of me, I'm jealous of the bird. We're both trying to get close to Todd". The bird, portrayed by two South American blue and gold macaws named Flash and Lucky, had developed an "impressive résumé" by the time they appeared on OLTL. They were trained by Ed Richman, who had worked with the birds for fifteen years in TV shows such as Magnum, P.I. and Jake and the Fatman. Richman stated that Howarth caught on "real quick" regarding his interaction with Flash and Lucky and said that he was the best actor he had worked with in the industry. The parrots were used for different purposes: for intimidating scenes where it looked like Moose "was going to kill somebody", Richman used Flash, and Lucky was used for the "loving, very caring, physically close" portrayal of Moose. Like other actors, the parrots were able to connect, in character, with their fellow castmembers and achieve comedic timing with them. Voice actor Ron Gallop was hired to deliver Moose's lines, which was crafted to help demonstrate Todd's train of thought and signified their close bond, consisted of funny or insulting remarks aimed at anyone causing problems for Todd.
Howarth's departure from the series motivated OLTL's writers and producers to do what many considered impossible: recast Todd. During Michael Malone's second stint as head writer of OLTL, he had to decide if Todd would remain. Malone later reported that the producers could not allow Todd to permanently leave the show's canvas, so they chose to recast the role. They offered the role to Michael Easton, who had played the vampire Caleb Morley on the cancelled soap opera Port Charles, but he turned it down because he did not want to be affiliated with a role played by another established actor. Malone later said that St. John's audition was "extraordinary", and that although a committee was involved in the recast, everyone agreed "he was Todd". Malone felt that they had made a risky decision, but St. John made it work and that he had made the character his own. Initially, St. John, in his first role in daytime television, was introduced as Walker Laurence, younger brother of Mitch Laurence (Roscoe Born).
Author Gerry Waggett stated that Walker was "reinvented as Todd with plastic surgery" after the show's viewers accepted St. John as a part of the cast. The soap press and fans speculated for several months that Todd had been recast with St. John. The soap website Soap Central.com stated that despite executive producer Frank Valentini neither confirming nor denying it, St. John's character exhibited "Todd-like" behavior. TV Guide confirmed the speculation and reported that St. John, when asked about it, stated, "That would be fascinating, though I don't see how it would work," and added, "Todd [had] a different voice and height, but this is a soap world and anything can happen."
St. John's version of the character had undergone plastic surgery after being severely beaten during a murder attempt on his life ordered by Mitch Laurence. While recovering in the hospital, Todd conducts research and learns Mitch has a brother named Walker (also portrayed by St. John), who goes by the name Flynn Laurence. Todd pays Flynn for information on Mitch, and has extensive plastic surgery in order to physically resemble Flynn and get revenge on (as well as protect his family from) Mitch. The writers revealed Walker's true identify slowly, allowing Walker to develop as a new character before hinting that he could be Todd.
St. John was unaware that Malone and the producers of OLTL were considering him as Todd, but had no strategy in his performance once he won the role. When speaking of the recast, St. John stated, "It's nice, because I had instant concrete relationships". He liked that he could consult old scripts and his fellow castmembers to gain information about his character, resources he did not have when playing Walker. He was able to use these resources to figure out his relationship to other characters, which helped him analyze how to play a scene. St. John stated that as an actor, he let the audience interpret the character, and believed in exploring and portraying the moment as it was written in the script. He said, "Todd is already written on the page, so it's my job to bring him to life in that moment".
St. John was instructed by the show's directors to watch about fifteen episodes of Howarth's performances of Todd because they wanted St. John to portray Todd like Howarth did. St. John reported that he watched two episodes, but never tried to mimic Howarth's style because he felt that it was limiting, uncreative, and destructive. He said, "I needed to get a sense of who Todd was first, and that has to happen organically." He did not care if Marlon Brando portrayed the role before him. St. John said that even actors who portray Hamlet do it differently, and added, "I don't care what the other guy did. That's his time". He felt that it was up to him to decide how to perform Todd, saying, "I know that sounds very arrogant and overconfident, but it would be no fun to try to mimic somebody."
Unlike how most actors are trained, St. John believed that it was not up to the performer to interpret the character, but that a character existed regardless of how an actor played him, which he realized was "an unusual way to approach acting". He also thought that playing Todd was fun and "never boring to watch" because Todd, although he was popular with the audience, was an unlikable character. St. John told Branco that when people asked him if Todd was capable of harming his loved ones, like his long-time love Blair or daughter Starr, St. John would say that Todd was capable of anything because to state otherwise meant that he was "limiting the character". He also stated, "Todd is a marvelous character to play because he could commit genocide, or find a cure for AIDS. He's full of possibilities—good and bad...See, as an actor that always gives you conflict to play—and that subtext enriches a performance".
Todd's impact is varied. The rape storyline inspired feminist studies, and in 1994, OLTL was awarded several Emmys in writing and acting, for all the principles involved. Michael Malone and Josh Griffith's team won an Emmy for writing, Susan Haskell won an Emmy for Best Supporting Actress, and Hillary B. Smith was awarded the Best Actress Emmy. Howarth won for Outstanding Younger Actor. In 1995, Howarth was nominated for an Outstanding Supporting Actor Emmy and Soap Opera Digest (SOD) named him Outstanding Leading Actor. SOD also named him Outstanding Villain in 1998. Todd has been called "one of the greatest characters of all-time" and Howarth's portrayal of Todd has been called "iconic". Howarth has also been called a "fan favorite, and one of the best actors in soaps". The Hollywood Reporter stated that even though Todd was a convicted rapist, he was the most popular character and Howarth was the most popular actor on OLTL. According to Waggett, the rape storyline propelled Todd "onto the list of OLTL's most despicable viilans". Waggett also stated that due to the storyline and to Howarth's talent, Todd "would become the show's next centerpiece villain and eventually the show's male lead". Howarth appeared on several interview shows following his first Emmy win in 1994, including the Phil Donahue Show in May, with six other male soap stars, and later that month, on Live! with Regis and Kathie Lee. Host Regis Philbin commented on the amount of fan mail Howarth had been receiving, and called him "a terrible villain, who's become a heartthrob to thousands of wildly adoring fans..."
At the height of the character's popularity, which was called "Todd-mania", Howarth was disturbed that so many women were attracted to Todd and that the show's writers had begun to redeem the character. In a September 1995 interview with The Hollywood Reporter, he admitted that he was troubled that "his villainous character became such a fan favorite". In October 1995, Howarth told SOD, "People have come up to me and said, 'My 7-year-old loves you.' What do I say to that? I'm not going to tell them, 'Don't let your 7-year-old watch TV.' But I have to say, it's disturbing". He gave credit to the show's writers for Todd's popularity, saying that the rapists' trial was well constructed and added, "I think, right now, we're just riding the wave of something that started last summer. Beyond that, I don't really know why people like Todd". Todd's "rampant" popularity intruded on Howarth's life. "It's really starting to frustrate me because I can't just go to work anymore," he said. He stopped doing press interviews after fans screamed "Rape me, Todd" at fan events. Howarth's coming-and-goings from time to time throughout the years, including his return in 2010, even though the role of Todd had been re-cast with St. John, were greeted with anticipation, excitement, and speculation from the fans. At one point in 2000, Howarth returned for a week, accompanied by significant fanfare, in order to assist with the departure of Florencia Lozano (Teá). During the ten years he was on the show, rumors of his departures were reported sometimes weekly by the soap press.
Soap Opera Magazine attributed the success of Todd as a character to Howarth's appearance and skill as an actor. In February 1998, the magazine stated, "Although the scar that traverses his face while he plays Llanview's dark prince isn't real, the menacing intensity Roger Howarth can so effortlessly convey with his eyes and furrowed brow are frighteningly authentic". Soap Opera Weekly called his presence "hypnotic" and stated that his eyes relayed his focus. The magazine added that Howarth "has given Todd such a deliciously frightening edge we hope he wreaks more havoc in Llanview..." Marla Hart of the Chicago Tribune stated, "...it has been an unexpected pleasure to watch actor Roger Howarth as a lost soul in search of spiritual redemption". Hart speculated that the darkness Howarth brought to the role made him interesting to watch and was responsible for his Emmy win in 1995.
St. John and the writers received praise for the recast, and for successfully re-integrating Todd into the show's canvas. Soap Opera Weekly stated, "They said it couldn't be done. One Life to Live's Todd (previously played by Roger Howarth) could not be recast. But with an appealing actor and the right pacing, One Life to Live may just have done it". The magazine stated that the writers revealed Todd's identity slowly, letting Walker develop as a character before dropping hints that he might be Todd. By the time he disclosed who he really was to his daughter Starr, the audience had already suspected the truth. Soap Opera Weekly called the scene between St. John and Kristen Alderson, who played Starr, "one of those great (and, these days, rare) must-see moments". Soap Opera Digest said that despite the recast, a difficult situation in and of itself, "St. John aptly distinguished between Walker, who's really Todd, as well as Flynn, who pretended to be Walker". The magazine stated that St. John revealed glimmers of Todd to the audience: "We could see Todd when Walker lowered his eyes while holding back from telling his sister, Viki; with fiancee Blair, Walker's gaze was always shifting, making sure nothing could clue her in to his secret". The article also credited St. John with maintaining "the [uniquely scheming] relationship of Todd and Starr" and for keeping their scenes touching and delightful.
On May 29, 2006, in what has been described as "one of the most memorable moments" for OLTL, and "breathtaking, nerve-racking, heart wrenching", St. John portrayed Todd being executed for a crime he did not commit. At the last moment, after the lethal injection has been administered, John McBain rushes in declaring Todd's innocence, with proof: the woman Todd is accused of killing (Margaret Cochran) is at his side, clearly still alive, and Todd is revived. During the execution episode, a montage a little over four minutes in length was shown while a song played in the background. The song was called "Forsaken" (or "Todd's Song") and written by Michal Towber especially for the show. The montage included reaction shots of those witnessing the execution, shots of Starr crying in the presence of a lynch mob outside the prison, and flashbacks of Todd's children and of Blair during both St. John and Howarth's tenures as Todd, with Howarth's face unseen. The scenes were called "unbearable", and viewer response was varied. Much of the audience was infuriated by Blair's unwillingness to believe that Todd was innocent. Many viewers thought that Todd's death was permanent; Soap Opera Digest speculated that it was due to limited Internet access or to a lack of interest in spoilers. Although both fans and St. John's co-workers felt that he deserved an Emmy nomination for his performance, he never received one, even though OLTL won a nomination for Outstanding Drama Series by submitting the episode. One soap website criticized St. John's Emmy snub, stating that it was incongruous that the show's Best Show nomination was due in large part to St. John's performance. Soap opera commentators Nelson Branco and Michael Fairman called St. John's execution performances the best on any daytime drama in the early 2000s. Towber, along with other composers for the show, was nominated for Outstanding Achievement in Music Direction and Composition for a Drama Series.
Although the gang rape storyline was well-received, it was also criticized. Jennifer Hayward, in her literary analysis of the rape and its similarity to nineteenth century melodrama, stated that in this storyline, the figure of the rapist was split into three personalities, which not only polarized "the gap between rapists and the raped but also the figure of the rapist himself". Hayward believed that the polarization was a departure from melodrama and from the standard treatment of rape in soaps. The writers accomplished this in two ways: by insisting on "the 'essential' goodness" of Powell Lord", which implied that peer pressure "could be an adequate (or even physiologically possible) excuse for rape"; and by, as Hayward put it, "startlingly...redeeming the evil Todd". Scholar Mary Buhl Dutta thought the storyline perpetuated the same myths about rape that had been in existence for centuries, especially how it used Marty, who fulfilled the stereotype of "the bad girl" who was the rape victim. Dutta stated, "Marty had once 'cried rape' when the Rev. Andrew Carpenter rebuffed her romantic overtures, falsely accusing him of sexually abusing a boy he was counseling". After she was actually raped, she falsely yet unintentionally accuses Kevin Buchanan, who was innocent. Marty, according to Dutta, "is a 'bad girl' because she had a one-night stand with Todd before the rape, bolstering his later claim she 'asked for it' in their second sexual encounter".
Critics have wondered why Todd is popular. Soap opera journalist Marlena De Lacroix, who admitted that she neither liked or understood Todd, expressed her inability to understand his popularity among so many fans, even during his many hiatuses from the show. She asked, "Why has the show devoted years of storyline time to him and all but made a hero out of a criminal?" Hayward, who admitted that her response to Todd's redemption was ambivalent. called the writers' attempt to redeem Todd controversial and stated that the role of Rebecca, the woman the writers paired Todd with during the redemption process, "seems to encourage both female and male fantasies about the power of a 'good woman' to save a man from his own violent impulses". In his book Behold the Man, Edisol Dotson suggested that viewers accepted Todd's redemption because he was physically attractive. Dotson stated, "Were Todd an ugly man, he would have never been forgiven, and female fans would not crowd the studio's backdoor shouting his name."
Hayward describes the thought processes of the writers involved in Todd's redemption, who included "an usually high number of male writers", an unusual situation because historically, most soap writers have been women. In a June 1994 interview with TV Guide, in an article about the trend during the early 1990s of redeemed rapists on soap operas, head writer Malone commented, "The bond between the woman and the violator is a great historical tradition in fiction and films...Rudolph Valentino, Humphrey Bogart, Kirk Douglas, and Clark Gable all began as totally irredeemable villains". Although he did not think that most women want to be raped or are drawn to violence, he said that viewers "are responding to the intensity of passion and an actor who lets you inside the torment. Some [women] believe they can be swept up in that passion and still turn it good. They think, 'With me, he'd be different'". The author of the article, Michael Logan, supported Malone's statements by stating, "Let's call a spade a spade. There is a large contingent of American female soap viewers who find something very attractive about rapists". Hayward reported that many female viewers were furious about being described in this way, and stated that their attraction towards Todd was due to the skill of the actor playing him.
Howarth said he had no desire to portray a redeemed Todd, and he subsequently left the series for a year. In the October 24, 1995 Soap Opera Digest issue, he stated:
In the beginning, the character of Todd was successful. I'll always be proud of this story, because it was the result of a real team effort. It was one of those spectacular times when the writer, producer, director, grips, engineers and actors were all on the same wavelength. Everybody was working toward a common goal. My task, at the time, was to show the humanity of someone who was basically inhuman. Todd wasn't one-dimensional, but he was definitely a serious psychopath. Todd was a serial rapist. He raped Carol Swift. Then, he raped Marty Saybrooke, and that rape was brutal, intense, violent and realistic. There were innuendos he had raped other women before. He stalked Nora, he stalked and tried to rape Luna. [Then-Executive Producer] Linda Gottlieb told me with reasonable certainty that [One Life to Live] would not try to redeem Todd. So, I didn't think the character would change. Then about a year ago, it became clear to me they were taking the character on a different path — they were redeeming him. In my mind, I'd been hired to play Todd Manning, a very realistic, serious psychopath. But now, the powers-that-be wanted me to play Todd Lord. And the story of Todd Lord is not realistic — it's a fairy tale. I thought, "It would be best for the show if I were to leave." That's when I tendered my resignation.
Howarth also stated that Todd and Marty suddenly bonding did not make sense and that he could not, in good conscience, support Todd's redemption by continuing to play him as Todd Lord, who had become a likable character. Since the rape was, as he called it, "so in-depth and so brutal", he viewed Todd and Marty doing something like having drinks with each other bizarre. Entertainment Weekly reported that One Life to Live agreed to let Howarth go on the condition he would not appear on another soap opera for twelve months. By contrast, at a fan gathering in 2008, St. John joked about Todd and Marty bonding that year, stating, "I'm all for gang rape." He later issued an apology for the comment: "I should know better than to ever try and make a joke about such a serious subject. I intended no disre[s]pect and apologize to anyone I offended."
In 2002, as part of ABC's push to sell merchandise from its soaps, the network began selling a doll in Todd's likeness on its website, but were thwarted by a backlash. It sold for $19.95 and according to the description on the site was "an all-cloth doll with brown felt hair and blue eyes. He is 20 inches standing. He wears a blue shirt and black pants".  The doll's face even included Todd's scar. Even though several years had passed since the gang rape and Todd had "since settled down", and had become a more sympathetic character, rape advocate groups thought that selling the doll glorified sexual assault, so ABC removed the doll from its online store. Pictures of the doll were pulled from the Internet and the doll was blocked from being available at eBay or any other online store.
The controversy began when the industry newsletter "The Jack Myers Report" harshly criticized ABC for selling the doll, and other news outlets reported the snafu. Bob Tedeschi of The New York Times stated, "In the charge toward e-commerce revenues, ABC learned a useful lesson last week: Don't try to sell cuddly rag dolls depicting homicidal rapists". Angela Shapiro, president of ABC, said, "I was insensitive and take total responsibility for it. I should have been sensitive to the history of the character and I wasn't". Another ABC executive stated, "We didn't exercise proper sensitivity to the history of the character of Todd. We have re-evaluated and decided not to sell the doll". A doll of Todd's daughter, Starr, remained in ABC stores.
When Todd was recast with St. John after Howarth's departure, many fans felt that like the roles of Luke Spencer (Anthony Geary) on General Hospital and Erica Kane (Susan Lucci) on All My Children, Todd should be portrayed only by the actor who had originated the role. As Soap Opera Digest put it, "Few recasts caused more uproar". Soap Opera Digest also stated that while there were fans who "will only consider Howarth to be their beloved Todd", St. John won over many fans by putting a lighter spin on the character. In an earlier issue, Soap Opera Digest stated that they were "on board with St. John". Soap Opera Weekly agreed, commenting that St. John made the transition believable while adding new facets to the character. The magazine also stated that Todd's new appearance aided in his continuing redemption. Soap opera columnist Jill Berry expressed her approval for the recast, stating, "Trevor's Todd continues to impress me. He has given some sweetness to Todd that I find totally appealing".
In late 2006, St. John and Howarth simultaneously began contract negotiations with their respective shows, which caused rumors that St. John was leaving OLTL, leaving room for Howarth, who was with the soap opera As the World Turns at the time, to return as Todd. TV Guide sought to clear up the matter and questioned executive producer Frank Valentini, who stated that although he was not able to comment on contracts, the producers were "doing our best to make sure that we do right by the audience". In 2007, TV Guide received official confirmation Howarth would not be returning to the series. The magazine conducted a poll on its website, TV Guide.com, and found that 82 percent of the show's viewers wanted to see Howarth return. Daniel R. Coleridge of TV Guide.com, however, disagreed with the results, stating, "Perhaps I'm in the minority, but I absolutely adore Trevor St. John", whose portrayal of Todd he found "very cocky, arrogant and humorous in a sexy way".
In 2009, following the announcement that As the World Turns would be cancelled in 2010, rumors that Howarth would return to OLTL regained momentum. The rumors were further fueled by an August 2010 episode of OLTL, in which Howarth's picture was shown and a delirious Téa stated that the current Todd (St. John) was not Todd Manning. This caused fans "to race to their computers to figure out the meaning of the scene". Dan Kroll of the website Soap Opera Central.com speculated that the scene was "crafted merely to get fans talking, or was it a hint to viewers something big was coming down the pike?" Soap Opera Network, citing unnamed sources and pointing to the 2010 episode, reported on their website that they had "learned exclusively Howarth [would] indeed be returning" to the series in the near future. Soap Opera Digest columnist Carolyn Hinsey, however, dismissed the report, stating on her Facebook page, "Seriously, stop with the Howarth misinformation here please. He is not coming back to OLTL. Case closed." Although Howarth eventually returned as Todd in 2011, his return was initially accompanied with fan speculation regarding what role he would play, Todd Manning or a new character. Some fans were convinced that St. John's character was an impostor while others were not.
According to Nelson Branco of TV Guide, in March 2008, OLTL aired "some of the most explosive and ugliest scenes ever broadcast on daytime" television when Todd beat up teenager Cole Thornhart (his daughter's boyfriend and Marty's son), and slapped Starr and Cole's friends Markko Rivera and Langston Wilde. Todd barges in on Starr and Cole in bed together for the first time, jumping to the conclusion that Cole had raped her, "and [beats] the son of his rape victim relentlessly". At least one soap blogger was outraged, and wanted Todd to be punished.
In Branco's opinion, head writer Ron Carlivati wanted to use the storyline to return Todd to his dark roots by showing him as a monster again, stating, "Carlivati chose to do something unique, bold and risky with one of his marquee characters", demonstrating Todd's damaged character and calling into question his mental stability. Carlivati said that Todd was convinced that Starr's alleged rape was karmic payback, even when Starr insisted that she had not been raped. Branco postulated that Todd's conclusion and strong reaction to seeing the two in bed together was Todd's inability to separate sex from violence, stating, "Todd, in that instance, became unhinged, paranoid, and out-of-control". Todd was in denial, and even almost hit Starr twice when she challenged his beliefs. The scenes were praised as "riveting". Soap columnist Marlena De Lacroix, a self-described "Todd hater" who felt that the character was psychotic, expressed hope that they were "the beginning of a storyline that will delve into Todd's mind and enlighten viewers as to the complexities of a character who is mentally ill". De Lacroix worried that although the storyline had the potential to be memorable, it could be another way to build sympathy for Todd.
In 2007, head writer Carlivati decided to revisit the rape storyline. In December, Marty is shown to be thrown from a van during a crash. The van explodes, and she is presumed dead. In June 2008, Todd discovers her alive; she is afflicted with amnesia and had been crippled since the crash. He starts to nurse her back to health, lying to her about her identity and her importance to the people she loves. ABC promoted the storyline by airing ads that called it, "The story you thought you'd never see". Carlivati defended the storyline by assuring the audience, who was concerned about and resisted the storyline, that it would not have been written if Marty had not lost her memories. He stated that he was aware of how serious it was pairing the characters romantically, but did not feel like they were damaging Marty's character. Carlivati was committed to having the storyline progress slowly, and to using the actors' and characters' chemistry. According to Branco, the show's past writing teams had proposed creating a Marty and Todd love story, but it never happened, mostly because Haskell and Howarth had refused to participate. In Branco's opinion, the push toward the storyline was the reason Howarth eventually left OLTL for As the World Turns".
De Lacroix found the storyline "disgusting", stating that the storyline was exploitative, misogynous, insulting to the audience, and "the most phony, stupidly contrived story I have ever seen". She also felt that it was a severe misjustice to the original storyline. Fans who were opposed to the controversial storyline called it "the re-rape", and ABC aired PSAs (public service announcements) for their viewers. Lynn Parrish, a spokesperson for Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network (RAINN), which was not consulted by the show's writers, spoke out against the "re-rape" storyline. She told Branco, "There is nothing romantic about rape", and that "whoever writes a romance between a rapist and its victim under any circumstances clearly doesn’t understand rape nor violence—and probably shouldn't be writing about it".
Branco stated that Carlivati had changed the original storyline, which he called "the gold standard of rape stories", into a soap opera cliché. The storyline left him feeling betrayed, hurt, depressed, angry, insulted, and disgusted, and he said that he had wasted almost 20 years investing in and believing in the original rape storyline. At the "re-rape" storyline's conclusion, however, Branco stated that the payoff was worth the tense moments. "However obscene or depraved the riskiest storyline in recent memory was," he said, "the fallout has been shockingly riveting—thanks to the fact that head writer Ron Carlivati is playing all the psychological beats of Todd's self-serving and criminal actions". In addition, Branco gave credit to St. John. "Nominated for a 2009 Soap Opera Spirit Award as outstanding lead actor, St. John inarguably faced the most challenging assignment of any actor in 2008—in any genre", said Branco. "And yet, somehow, St. John made it work. In a lesser actor's hands, the storyline most certainly would have resulted in career suicide for all involved".