Poverty in Mexico

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article

 
Jump to: navigation, search
Poverty Headcount Ratio (2010)[1]
Poverty TrendWorld Bank
Live with less than $1.25 a day0.7% (0.8 million)
Live with less than $2.00 a day4.5% (5.1 million)
Live with less than $2.50 a day8.8% (10.9 million)
Live with less than $4.00 a day23.7% (26.9 million)
Live with less than $5.00 a day33.2% (37.6 million)
Map of world poverty by country, showing percentage of population living on less than $1.25 per day. Based on 2009 UN Human Development Report.

Poverty in Mexico is measured under parameters such as nutrition, clean water, shelter, education, health care, social security, quality and basic services in the household, income and social cohesion as defined by social development laws in the country.[2] It is divided in two categories: Moderate poverty and Extreme poverty.

While less than 2% of Mexico's population lives below the international poverty line set by the World Bank, as of 2013 Mexico's government estimates that 33% of Mexico's population lives on moderate poverty and 9% lives on extreme poverty,[3] which leds to a 42% of Mexico's total population living below the national poverty line.[4] The huge gap might be explained due the government adopting the multidimensional poverty method as a way to measure poverty, so, a person who might have an income higher than the "international poverty line" or "well being income line" set by the Mexican government might fall on the "moderate poverty" category if has one or more deficiencies related to social rights such as education (didn't completed studies), nutrition (either malnutrition or obesity) or living standards (going from elemental ones such as water or electricity to secondary domestic assets such as refrigerator, etc.). Extreme poverty is defined by the Mexican government as persons who have deficiencies in both areas: social rights and an income lower than the "well being income line" [5] Additional figures from SEDESOL (Mexico's Social Development Agencie) estimates that 6% (7.4 millions of people) live in extreme poverty and also suffer from food insecurity [6]

Mexico's positive potential and the result of millions in poverty is always a topic of discussion among opinion-makers.[7][8] Some economists have speculated that in four more decades of continuous economic growth, despite common trends in Mexico such as emigration and violence, Mexico will be among the five biggest economies in the world, along with China, the United States, Japan, and India.[9]

In recent times, extensive changes in government economic policy[10] and attempts at reducing government interference through privatization of several sectors,[11] for better[12] or worse,[13] has allowed Mexico to historically remain the biggest economy in Latin America,[14] until 2005 when it became the second-largest;[15] and a so-called "trillion dollar club" member.[16] Despite theses changes, Mexico continues to suffer great social inequality and lack of opportunities.[17] The current administration has made an approach at reducing poverty in the country, to provide more opportunities to its citizens such as jobs,[18] education and the installation of universal healthcare.[19][20]

Background[edit]

Mexico's unequal development between the richer urban zones and the considerably poorer rural zones have been attributed to the fast economic growth that took place during the so-called Mexican miracle, the period on which Mexican economy did a transition from an agriculture based to an industry based one, which led many people to relocate in the cities. Even though investments were pouring into urban infrastructure, the government generally couldn't accommodate the rapid influx of people, which led to the development of slums in the outskirts of many cities in Mexico. The constant governmental corruption is another factor to which poverty is frequently attributed.[21] Only in recent years, after various economic setbacks, Mexico has recovered to a level where the middle class, once virtually nonexistent, is beginning to flourish.[22][23]

Social stratification is still greatly present in Mexico can be traced back to the country's origin. In the Colonial Period, before its independence, the upper class was composed of those who owned the land and the lower class was made of those who worked the land. After the Mexican Revolution, the government ceded an estimated 50 percent of the land to the general population, covering a small portion of the gap between the wealthy and the poor.[24] Land ownership continued to be main source of wealth for Mexicans and has dictated the hierarchy of wealth distribution amongst the population. After the country entered its economic industrial transformation, industrialists, businessmen, and politicians have controlled the direction of wealth in Mexico and have remained among the wealthy.[25]

The average individual gross annual income in Mexico in 2002 was US$6,879.37 (2010 dollars).[26] 12.3 percent of the Mexican labor force earns the daily minimum wage or MX$1,343.28 per month (approx. US$111.94 November 2010 exchange rates).[27] 20.5 of the labor force earns twice the minimum wage and 21.4 percent earns up to three times the daily minimum wage while 18.6 earn no more than five daily minimum wages.[27] Only 11.8 percent of the working population earn wages equal or above MX$6,716.40 (US$559.70) per month.[27] According to Jaime Saavedra, World Bank Poverty Manager for Latin America, Mexico has made considerable strides in poverty reduction since the late 1990s, with performance above the Latin American average. Saavedra explained that: “Between 2000 and 2004, extreme poverty fell almost seven percentage points, which can be explained by development in rural areas, where extreme poverty fell from 42.4 per cent to 27.9 per cent. The urban poverty rate, however, got stuck at 11.3 per cent."[28]

Government involvements[edit]

Social development began to take place in the form of written policy in the early 1900s.[29] The Mexican Constitution, approved in 1917, outlined the basic social protections citizens are entitled to, including the right to property, education, health care, and employment; and it establishes the federal government responsible for the execution and enforcement of these protections.[30]

Map of Mexican states indicating HDI (2004)
   0.80 and higher
   0.750–0.799
   0.70–0.749

The global economic crisis of the late 1920s and forward slowed down any possibility of social development in the country.[31] Between the 1920s and the 1940s the illiteracy levels range between 61.5 to 58 percent, due this the government focused on establishing social protection institutions. By the late 1950s, 59 percent of the population knew how to read and write. In the 2000s only 9.5 percent of the population older than 15 years was illiterated.[29] By the 1960s, individual involvement of some states to increase social development, along with the country's economic growth, as well as employment opportunities and greater income, and the migration of people from the rural states to the urban areas, helped reduced poverty nationwide.[29] The 1970s and 1980s saw the transformation of government and economic policies. The government gave way to flexible foreign trade, deregulation and privatization of several sectors. After the economic crisis of the 1990s, Mexico recovered to become an emerging economic power; however, the amount of poor nationwide has remained constant even with the country's overall growth.[32][33]

Regional variation[edit]

Historically, southern states like Chiapas, Oaxaca, and Guerrero have remained segregated from the rest of the country.[34] Their implementation of infrastructure, social development, education, and economic growth has been poorly accounted for. These states hold the highest levels of illiterates, unemployment, lack of basic services such as running water and sanitation, overall urban infrastructure, and government establishment.[35] As citizens of the least fortunate states have noticed growth and improvements in others states, many have simply left seeking better opportunities.[36]

Causes of poverty[edit]

The reasons for poverty in Mexico are complex and widely extensive.[37] There is a consensual agreement that a combination of uneven distribution of wealth and resources sponsored by economic and political agendas to favor the rich and powerful is a major contributor to the millions left behind.[38][39]

Individual condition[edit]

Many families on extreme poverty in Mexico live in makeshift houses as the one seen here.

In the economic sense, access to insufficient monetary means to afford goods and services becomes the immediate reason to be poor. Because a person's personal income dictates what he or she can afford and what he or she will remain deprived of, the first common cause of poverty is the individual condition.[40] This means, a person's individual circumstances and possibilities create their opportunity for access to goods and services. This condition is triggered by a person's income, education, training or work experience, social network, age, health, and other socio-economic factors:

As population has grown, the number of students enrolled in schools throughout the country has grown tremendously since the 1950s.[41] At the same time, government efforts to accommodate the growing student population, improving the quality of instruction and promoting prevalent school attendance has not been enough and therefore education has not remained among priorities for families who must struggle with poverty.[42][43] 700,000 students grades 1-9 dropped out of school in 2009 in all of Mexico.[44] 7.9 percent (almost 9 million) of the population is illiterate.[44] 73% of Mexican households have at least one member without education or education below the 7th grade.[44] 40 percent of people in the states of Chiapas, Veracruz, Hidalgo, Oaxaca and Guerrero have education below the 7th grade.[45]

Getting an education does not immediately translate to landing better paying jobs or overcoming underemployment in Mexico: According to data compiled by the Civic Observatory for Education, fewer than 20% of recent graduates manage to find an appropriate position during their first round of job-hunting. Although the country has made great strides in education and professional training, the absence of a serious employment policy means that economic expansion is sacrificed so that higher prices can be avoided. That exerts a negative impact on the labor market in both the short and medium term, and on new professionals most of all.[46] Situations like this have cause the standard of living among the urban middle class to deteriorate and as a consequence brings on emigration from this sector to other countries, mainly the United States and Canada.[47]

Mexico does not promote equal opportunity employment despite established laws forbidding most socially-recognized forms of discrimination.[48] The government doesn't become sufficiently involved to promote opportunities to all citizens; including reducing discrimination against middle-age and elder citizens. Over a million of the unemployed face age discrimination and 55% of all unemployed face some form of discrimination when seeking employment.[49] There are virtually no opportunities for individuals with special requirements such as the disabled.[50] As job seekers become older, it is harder for them to get employed as employers tend to seek candidates within the "younger than 35 range". Social security (IMSS) is insufficient and there is a huge gap in proportion to the entire population (50% covered), the work force (30% covered), and the retired (33% covered).[51] There is no unemployment insurance in Mexico.[52]

Insufficient infrastructure[edit]

Mexico is a country where investment on infrastructure has remained as unequally distributed as income, specially in rural areas and in the southern states.[53] Because many people establish in rural areas, without government permission, and without paying property taxes, the government does not make significant efforts to invest in overall infrastructure of the entire country, yet it has started to do so until the 1990s.[54] Communities often face a combination of unpaved roads, lack of electricity and potable water, improper sanitation, poorly maintained schools, vandalism and crime, and lack of social development programs.[55][56] The government did not begin to focus on improving and modernizing the federal highway system up until two decades ago when it was composed of two-lane roads; often deathtraps and the scenarios of head-on collisions between truckers and families on vacation.[57] City and state governments often face challenges providing citizens who live on informal commerce with the basic services of urbanized life.[58] To worsen the problem the housing laws often vary greatly from one state to another, with the state of Hidalgo having no housing laws at all.[59] Because of this, higher income communities will invest in the development of their own communities while lower income communities might be deprived of the basics such as running water and drainage in various cases.

The concentration of poverty and distribution of wealth and opportunities is clearly visible from a geographic perspective.[60] The northern region of the country offers higher development while the southern states are the most impoverished. This is clearly the result of states equipped with better infrastructure that others. The states of Chiapas, Oaxaca, and Guerrero are among the least developed in the country. These states hold the highest numbers of indigenous population. As a result, 75 percent of the indigenous population lives on moderate poverty line and 39 percent of these under extreme poverty.[61]

Map of Mexican states indicating levels of overall poverty (2005)
   62.4-75.7
   35.8-41.9
   9.2-22.5

Unemployment[edit]

Unemployment in Mexico has been continuous.[17][46] In 2009, the unemployment rate was estimated at 5.5 percent (over 2.5 million).[62] Although that figure is far below the unemployment indexes in the rest of Latin America, the European Union, the United States and much of Asia, Mexico faces a serious problem generating jobs.[63] In spite of splendid macroeconomic indicators that currently exist: continuing low levels of inflation and stability in the nation’s currency exchange rate; a sufficient number of formal jobs- at least one million every year to keep up with the growing population- have not been created in over ten years.[64] With the abundance of natural resources in the country- as well as its petroleum wealth, these benefits don't seem to reach many of the people of Mexico who lack job opportunities and the means to raise their standards of living out of poverty and marginalization.[65]

In order to improve present day employment opportunities in Mexico, existing laws and regulations must be replaced for efficient instruments with greater legal certainty; encourage private investment; increase the collection of taxes; stimulate the productivity of businesses and the training of workers; and create more and better jobs.[66]

Differences in national income equality around the world as measured by the national Gini coefficient. A higher number means a higher income inequality

Mexico's wealth is unevenly distributed among its people where 10 percent of nation's wealthiest have 42.2 percent of all income and 10 percent of the nation's poorest have 1.3 of the remaining income.[67] Carlos Slim, the richest man in Mexico and in the world has a personal fortune equal to 4 to 6 percent of the country's GDP.[68][69] In spite of efforts by government officials during the past three administrations; transition to globalization,[70] the NAFTA agreement;[71] Mexico has been unable to create efficient public policies in order to compensate for the distortion of its market and the poor distribution of national income.[72]

The absence of basic agreements among Mexico’s main political parties for more than ten years has caused a serious backwardness in needed legislation in a number of areas.[73] The current economic framework needs adjustment on virtually all levels including business development opportunities, fair competition, tax collection and tax law; commerce, trade and finance regulations.[74]

The Mexican economy does not support unprivileged businesses, considering its current standards regarding monopolies, both in the public and private sectors.[75] By law, there are public monopolies: government-owned companies controlling oil and gas, electricity, water, etc.[76] Private sector monopolies and duopolies are found in the media, television, telecommunications, and raw materials.[77] For this reason, clear principles of competitiveness that offer incentives to private investment, both national and foreign, are needed in order for jobs to be created.[78]

Government and politics[edit]

Mexico's rampant poverty, lagged social development and general public welfare is strongly tied to its politics.[79] Historically, the political system of Mexico has not favored the general population, mainly because it focused to become and be a single-party system of government, largely dubbed "institutionalized" where those in charge had a one-voice, unquestionable plan of action mainly focused to favor the few elite while ignoring the welfare of the rest of population. From the 1800s to the end of the 20th century, as presidential administration came and went, the forms of government has been described as authoritarian, semi-democracy, centralized government, untouchable presidencies, mass-controlling, corporatist and elite-controlled.[80] As each administration took turn, some changes have occurred, sometimes as to contribute to the welfare of the least fortunate but, overall, the political framework behind the economic and social structure of the country continues to be the greatest contributor to inequality.[81]

While the NAFTA agreement proved effective in increasing Mexico's economic performance, foreign trade policies have been heavily criticized by activists such as Michael Moore (in Awful Truth) as not doing enough to promote social advancement and reducing poverty.[81] To remain competitive in the international market, Mexico has had to offer low wages to its workers while allowing high returns and generous concessions to international corporations.[82] The words "palancas" and "favores" are part of Mexican economic culture where high-ranking policy makers and private entrepreneurs are accused of promoting their own bottom line while ignoring the necessaries of the working class.[83]

Current recessionary trends in the United States have an even greater impact on Mexico because of the great economic dependence on the northern neighbor. After crude oil export sales, remittances sent home by Mexicans working in the United States are Mexico’s second largest source of foreign income.[84][85]

Administration after administration, economic policies and social development programs have been targeted at decreasing poverty and increasing development in the country. Even with the best of intentions, friction between the "special interests" of decision-makers and the general public welfare, makes it difficult for clear goals in the benefit of the public to be accomplished.[86]

Cancun is an example of where the government have failed to promote general welfare and unequal distribution of wealth. While known for its crispy white beaches, fancy hotels of international renown, and spring break; Cancun shows a notorious economical inequality between the touristic urban zones, and its more rural outskirts, where in various cases, the poorest neighborhoods lack one or more basic services.[87][88]

The lack of political transparency in Mexico has led to bureaucratic corruption, market inefficiencies, and income inequalities.[89][90][91] The ability to exercise civil rights has been increasingly displaced by the control of official authorities, including access to vital information that can capture the misappropriation and mis-allocation of funds, and public participation in state and municipal-level decision-making.[92] This opens up a channel for corruption. Evidence of this can be derived from the Corruption Perception Index 2010: Mexico received a low score of 3.1, on a scale of 0 to 10 (lower scores represent higher levels of corruption).[93] The result is a diffusion of corruption, from the state to the municipal level, and even right down to local security.[94][95]

While it can be difficult to quantify the costs of corruption with pinpoint accuracy, a report from the UN estimates that the cost is about 15 percent of Mexico’s GNP, and 9 percent of its GDP.[96][97] Such higher costs have adversely affected the growth of the economy, for instance deterring foreign investments due to uncertainty and risk. A study by Pricewaterhouse Coopers reveals that Mexico had lost $8.5 billion in foreign direct investments in 1999 due to corruption.[98] Business companies admit to spend as much as 10 percent of their revenue in bureaucratic bribes.[97] 39 percent is spent on bribing high-ranking policy makers and 61 percent on lower-ranking bureaucratic-administrative office holders.[99] At least 30 percent of all public spending ends up in the pockets of the corrupt.[99]

Even the domestic impact of corruption is no less severe, incurring additional expenses on firms and households. A family on average pays 109.50 pesos as bribes to authorities; households have also reported paying up to 6.9 percent of their income as bribes. In total, the cost of corruption in terms of GDP was estimated to be about $550bn in 2000.[100]

The situation is still problematic in spite of recent initiatives by the state to become more transparent to the public.[101] Over the years, there has been an effort by the government to reduce opacity, but even so, these initiatives often do not realize their full potential. In June 2003, under Vincente Fox’s presidency, the implementation of the Federal Law of Transparency and Access to Public Government Information (IFAI) offered civic organizations and members of the public to acquire previously undisclosed information. This reform has led to the exposure of previous under-the-radar activities, such as the government’s misappropriation of 200 million pesos that was intended to combat AIDS.[102] And yet, censorship is still prevalent: in 2008, changes were proposed to increase the subjugation of IFAI’s decisions to state control, so that the distribution of information would become more centralized.[103] A number of vertical subversions were also carried out at the time, including the merging of offices that handled information requests with less important agencies.[104] This violated the earlier progressive changes to the constitution, including Article 6, so that transparency was threatened.

Opacity is therefore a major player as a determinant of inequality, especially in effecting the welfare of lower-class households.[105] When resources are misallocated and official funds pocketed by illegitimate parties, the true quality of public services such as healthcare tend to be lower than expected;[106] similarly, the secrecy of the government’s budget allocation prevents public scrutiny, so it is difficult to establish financial accountability.[107] As well, from a broader perspective, vital infrastructure from projects, especially those aimed at facilitating social mobility, will also have to deal with the potential impediments caused by the overpricing effect and unnecessary risks of corruption, thereby reducing the accessibility of infrastructure for the poor, especially in rural areas where such infrastructure is less established than in urban areas.[108]

Reducing poverty[edit]

Poverty aid organizations and social development groups have remained active in Mexico. Despite foreign and national aid programs in the country, the overall level of poverty in the country prevails.[109]

Government approach[edit]

Transparency Collective[edit]

The Transparency Collective, or El Colectivo por la Transparencia in Spanish, is a non-governmental collective organization that advocates transparency in Mexico. It was first formed by six civil society organizations in 2002 to demand for greater transparency from state agencies, and the right to access information. Currently, it consists of eleven civil society groups with the common goal of strengthening democracy and raising accountability and the transparency of the state.[112] The Transparency Collective offers an avenue for locals to seek help in obtaining the right to information by offering manuals and online tutorials teaching the locals how to file a request for information. It also discusses topics like human rights, the legislature and government budgets so that locals will be more informed and aware of their rights.[113] For example, Fundar, an NGO which specializes in government budget analysis, runs workshops to educate the public on disseminating information released by government agencies.[114]

The Transparency Collective has also been working with IFAI (Federal Institute of Access to Information). The civil society was productively engaged in the reform of the constitution. For example, CIDE, an academic focusing on public policy, worked at state level helping states comply with the reform. Fundar also focused on evaluating government responses to information requests, the appeals process and on training groups to analyze information released by the government.[115]

Despite the organizational size of the Transparency Collective, collectivization has nonetheless been an important factor in its effectiveness. The collective call for greater transparency was one of the reasons for the comprehensive reform of Article 6 of the Mexican constitution in 2007, which heralded a new level of progression for Mexico's right-to-know movement.[116] The reforms guaranteed the public's rights to non-confidential information at all levels of the government. State transparency laws also had to be standardized around certain basic principles within a year, and states had to implement electronic information systems.[116]

However, in spite of this, there is still a considerable way to go to achieve full transparency. The 2008 constitutional amendments, and interference of the judiciary branch with the demanded disclosure of tax information, threatened the FOI laws that were previously established. Nevertheless, this movement has been met with fierce protests from civil society groups,[117][118] and the Collective continues to appeal to the government to allow for more civil participation.[119]

Demographics[edit]

GDP by State in US Dollars (2008)

World comparison[edit]

*The next comparisons are done between national poverty lines, meaning that each country has a different criteria to set its poverty line, for a comparison among countries under the same criteria see International poverty line

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Mexico - New Global Poverty Estimates". World Bank. 
  2. ^ Mexican Congress (2004-01-04). "Mexican Congress Bill, General Law of Social Development". Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  3. ^ "1.4 millones de mexicanos dejan la pobreza extrema entre 2010 y 2012". Animal político. 2013-07-29. Retrieved 2013-07-31. 
  4. ^ "Clases medias en México". INEGI. 2013-06-12. Retrieved 2013-07-19. 
  5. ^ "La medición oficial de la pobreza en México". EstePaís.com. 2011-03-01. Retrieved 2013-07-19. 
  6. ^ "Cruzada contra el hambre atenderá a 7.4 millones de pobres". Milenio. 2013-01-21. Retrieved 2013-07-19. 
  7. ^ Brenda Walker (2005). "Mexico is Rich". LimitsToGrowth. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  8. ^ George H. Wittman (2010-07-09). "Mexico Unmasked". The American Spectator. Retrieved 2010-07-09. 
  9. ^ TheCatalist (2010-03-17). "Mexico 2050: The World´s Fifth Largest Economy". Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  10. ^ IMF Survey (2010-03-16). "Mexico Recovering...". International Monetary Fund. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  11. ^ "Impact of Globalization: the Case of Mexico". HumanGlobalization.org. 2010-11. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  12. ^ Albert Chong and Florencio López de Silanes (2004-08). "Privatization in Mexico". Inter-American Development Bank. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  13. ^ Hernández Oliva, Rocío Citlalli (2001-07). Globalización y Privatización: El Sector Público en México, 1982-1999. Instituto Nacional de Administración Pública (INAP). Template:Listed invalid ISBN. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  14. ^ Tal Barak Harif and Jonathan J. Levin (2010-10-04). "Mexico Boom Leads Americas as Drug War Loses to NAFTA". Bloomberg BusinessWeek. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  15. ^ "Brazil now Latin America’s largest economy". MSNBC. Associated Press. 2005-09-30. Retrieved 2010-11-28. 
  16. ^ CIA World Fact Book (2010-01-15). "Mexico in the Trillion Dollar Class". Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  17. ^ a b Samuel Peña Guzman (2006-09-04). "Social Inequality in Mexico". Mexidata.info. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  18. ^ Secretary of Tourism (2008-07-02). "Promoting Tourism to tackle Poverty". Mexican Federal Government. Retrieved 2010-11-16. [dead link]
  19. ^ "Federal Government Poverty Fight Initiative". Notimex. 2009-12-28. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  20. ^ "Mexico achieves universal health coverage, enrolls 52.6 million people in less than a decade". Harvard School of Public Health. 2012-08-15. Retrieved 2013-09-16. 
  21. ^ "Politics, Poverty, and Corruption in 20th-Century Mexico". Documents for Small Business and Professionals. 2010-11-01. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  22. ^ Erika Wurst (2004-12-08). "Mexican Middle Class Rising". Walter Cronkite School of Journalism and Mass Communication-Arizona State University. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  23. ^ Dr. José Enrique Vallarta Rodríguez (2008-02-18). "Unemployment and Mexico’s Need to Create More Jobs". MexiData.info. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  24. ^ BookRags Student Essays (2006). "Causes for the Mexican Revolution". BookRags, Inc. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  25. ^ World Bank-World Development Indicators (2000). "Mexico-Poverty and Wealth". Encyclopedia of Nations. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  26. ^ Mexican National Income Survey and Household Expendetures (2008). "Mexico Average Salaries & Expenditures". World Salaries. Org. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  27. ^ a b c Notimex/El Universal (2008-02-03). "12% of Active Work Population earns Minimum Daily Wages". El Universal. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  28. ^ The World Bank (2005-08-27). "Mexico's Urban Poor Work Harder For Less". CityMayorsSociety. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  29. ^ a b c Liliam Flores O. Rodriguez (2009-10-07). "History of Social Development in Mexico, (in Spanish)". Mexican Congress-Chamber of Deputies. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  30. ^ Mexican Congress (1997-12-20). "Constitution of Mexico, Title 1: Chapter I, articles 3 and 4, Title VI: Article 123". Illinois State University. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  31. ^ Library of Congress Country Studies; CIA World Factbook (2004-11-10). "Mexico and the Great Depression". Photius Coutsoukis. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  32. ^ Carlos Cruz Pacheco (2010-10-11). "Poverty in Mexico: Same as in 1992, PRI". ArgonMexico.com. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  33. ^ El Mundo de Tehuacán (2010-10-17). "Imprisoned in Poverty". Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  34. ^ Exploring Mexico Editorial Group (2010). "The Poorest States of Mexico". Explorando México. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  35. ^ John P. Schmal (2004). "History of Mexico: Chiapas-Forever Indigenous". Houston Institute for Culture. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  36. ^ World Bank Group and Guanajuato's State Population Council (2003-11). "Migration and Poverty in Mexico's Southern States". Munich Personal RePEc Archive. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  37. ^ Carlos A. Benito (2000-05). "The Causes of Poverty in Latin America and the Caribbean: The Role of Political Institutions and Governance". Sonoma State University-Economics Department. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  38. ^ James Chyper (2002-02-01). "Poverty in Mexico". Red Eurolatinoamericana Celso Furtado. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  39. ^ Suzanne Bilello (1989). "The Economic Chaos In Mexico: A Primer". Alicia Patterson Foundation. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  40. ^ Hari Srinivas (2010-08-16). "Causes of Poverty". Global Development Research Center. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  41. ^ Kevin Rolwing (2006-06). "Education in Mexico". World Education Services. Retrieved 2010-11-21. 
  42. ^ "Mexico's Education System Ranks Last Among Members of OECD". SourceMex Economic News & Analysis on Mexico. 2004-09-22. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  43. ^ Aileen Garcia, Prof. Eugene Matusov (2006-04-28). "Life In Mexico:Focusing on Schools". University of Delaware-Publishing Web for Student’s Final Paper. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  44. ^ a b c Nurit Martínez (2010-01-18). "(Spanish)700 mil dejan la escuela por crisis". El Universal. Retrieved 2010-11-21. 
  45. ^ Mexican Editorial Organization (2008-10-07). "(Spanish)En el 73% de las familias en México hay rezago educativo". Tabasco Herald. Retrieved 2010-11-21. 
  46. ^ a b "Mexico Faces Up to Unemployment Growth". Wharton School at the University of Pennsylvania. 2005-09-21. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  47. ^ Prof. Héctor Ramón González Cuellar (Tijuana Technological Institute) (2010). "Social Conflict: Brains Escape...". ZETA Newspaper. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  48. ^ Basham, Ringe y Correa, S.C. (2005). "Age Discrimination Internationally-Mexico". Lewis Silkin, LLP. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  49. ^ Sara Arellano (2009-08-19). "(Spanish) Discriminación por edad se dispara en mercado laboral". El Universal Newspaper. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  50. ^ Lic. Gilberto Rincón Gallardo. "(Spanish)Disability in Mexico". Mexican Senate. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  51. ^ Pedro Moreno, Silvia Tamez and Claudia Ortiz (2002). "Social Security in Mexico". Solidarity Center and Autonomous Metropolitan University-Xochimilco (UAMX). Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  52. ^ Sara María Ochoa León (2005-06). "Unemployment Insurance in Mexico". Center of Social Studies and Public Opinion, Mexican Congress-Chamber of Deputies. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  53. ^ World Bank. "A Study of Rural Poverty in Mexico". Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  54. ^ Anna Wellenstein, Angélica Núñez, and Luis Andrés (2005). "Social Infrastructure". The World Bank. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  55. ^ Laura M. Norman, Jean Parcher, and Alven H. Lam (2004-12-12). "Monitoring Colonias Along the U.S.-Mexico Border". U.S. Geological Survey and Association of American Geographers. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  56. ^ "Violence and crime in Mexico at the crossroads of misgovernance, poverty and inequality". World Bank Group. 2009-04. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  57. ^ Engineer Arturo M. Monforte Ocampo (2008-11). "Conserving the Toll-Free Federal Highways". Engineering Academy, A.C. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  58. ^ Isabel Becerril (2010-10-27). "Badly Needed National Urban Development Policy". El Financiero. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  59. ^ Oyuki Sànchez (2010-10-12). "Urban and Housing Planning: Fundamental for Development". CentroUrbano.com. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  60. ^ Jesús Orozco Castellanos (2008-08-04). "Marginalization and Inequality in Mexico". Crisol Plural. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  61. ^ Blanca Valadez (2010-08-09). "In Extreme Poverty 39% of Indigenous in Mexico". Fundación Konrad-Adenauer-Stiftung México. Retrieved 2010-11-22. 
  62. ^ The World FactBook (2010-11-09). "Mexico's Profile". CIA. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  63. ^ "Mexico Faces Up to Unemployment Growth". Universia. 2005-09-21. Retrieved 2013-010-17. 
  64. ^ Gustavo Merino (2008-05-07). "Social Policy and Job Creation in Mexico". Social Development Secretariat (SEDESOL). Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  65. ^ International Energy Statistics (2010-06). "Oil and Energy in Mexico". U.S. Energy Information Administration. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  66. ^ Dr. José Enrique Vallarta Rodríguez (2007-02-12). "...Needed Labor Reform in Mexico". MexiData.info. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  67. ^ a b United Nations (2010-03-27). "Gap between rich and poor in Latinamerica is largest in the world, says UN". MercoPress. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  68. ^ The Week (2010-03-16). "7 things to know about Carlos Slim Helu". Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  69. ^ Rodrigo Garcia-Verdú (2008-08-20). "(Spanish) Wealth of the Nation". Semanario de Economía y Finanzas. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  70. ^ Gordon H. Hanson (2004-10). "Globalization, Labor Income, and Poverty in Mexico". University of California, San Diego (UCSD)-National Bureau of Economic Research. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  71. ^ Gerardo Esquivel (2008-12). "The Dynamics of Income Inequality in Mexico since NAFTA". Harvard University-Center for International Development. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  72. ^ Alejandro Tuirán Gutiérrez (2005-12). "(Spanish) Inequality in Income Distribution in Mexico". National Population Council (CONAPO). Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  73. ^ Dr. José Enrique Vallarta Rodríguez (2007-03-26). "What Are The Most Serious Problems Mexico Faces?". MexiData.info. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  74. ^ Allan Wall (2007-05-21). "World Bank Diagnoses Mexican Economic Problems". WorldBankd-MexiData.info. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  75. ^ Elizabeth Malkin (2009-06-02). "Are Monopolies Holding Mexico Back?". The New York Times. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  76. ^ Allan Wall (2008-02-25). "Pemex, Mexico’s Oil & Gas Monopoly, Must be Modernized". MexiData.info. Retrieved 2010-11-24. [dead link]
  77. ^ Emir Olivares Alonso (2007-05-15). "(Spanish) To Grow Mexico Must Eliminate Powerful Monopolies". La Jornada. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  78. ^ "(Spanish) Bureaucracy- Parking Brake for Competitiveness in Mexico". EL Informador. Retrieved 2010-11-23. 
  79. ^ Murilo Kuschick Ramos (2002-02-01). "(Spanish) Government, Poverty, and Public Opinion". Autonomous Metropolitan University, Azcapotzalco (UAM). Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  80. ^ Mara Steffan (2007-10-22). "The Political Impact of NAFTA on the Mexican Transition to Democracy, 1988-2000". Bologna Center Journal of International Affairs-Johns Hopkins University. Retrieved 2010-11-21. [dead link]
  81. ^ a b Julia Hanna (2006-07-19). "Political Turmoil and Mexico's Economy". Harvard University-Business School. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  82. ^ Gordon H. Hanson; Ann Harrison (1999-01). "Trade liberalization and wage inequality in Mexico". New York State School of Industrial & Labor Relations. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  83. ^ Ricardo Bonilla Esparza (2006-11-29). "(Spanish) Corruption a Part of Mexican Culture". El Siglo de Durango. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  84. ^ Tracy Wilkinson (2009-06-02). "Remittances to Mexico down sharply". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  85. ^ "Mexico Sees Record Drop in Remittances". CBS News. Associated Press. 2010-01-27. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  86. ^ Sergey V. Mityakov (2010-06-10). Special Interests and Financial Liberalization: the Case of Mexico. Blackwell Publishing Ltd. doi:10.1111/j.1468-0343.2010.00368.x. 
  87. ^ Marc Cooper (2003-09-06). "The Real Cancun: Behind Globalization's Glitz". The Nation. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  88. ^ Ali Tonak and Tessa Brudevold-Iversen (2005-10-17). "The Real Cancun". Upside Down World. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  89. ^ Harry Kimball (2008-12-30). "Corruption in Mexico is Rampant and Pervasive". Newser. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  90. ^ Daniel C. Levy, Kathleen Bruhl, and Emilio Zebadúa (2001-09-24). "Mexico: The Struggle for Democratic Development". University of California Press. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  91. ^ Revenue Watch Institute. "Mexico: Transparency Snapshot". Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  92. ^ Rosy Laura Castellanos (2005). "(Spanish) Accountability, access to information and transparency in Mexico". Civic Alliance, AC. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  93. ^ Transparency International Latinoamerica y el Caribe (2010-10-26). "Corruption Perceptions Index 2010 Results". Transparency International. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  94. ^ Prof. Claudio Lomnitz (1995-11-27). "Understanding history of corruption in Mexico". University of Chicago-Chicago Chronicle. Retrieved 2010-11-24. 
  95. ^ BBC News (2010-08-30). "Mexico sacks 10% of police force in corruption probe". Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  96. ^ Jacques Hallak and Muriel Poisson (2007). "Corrupt schools, corrupt universities: What can be done?". International Institute for Educational Planning. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  97. ^ a b Julio Reyna Quiróz (2010-04-13). "(Spanish)The Cost of Corruption in Mexico...". World Economic Forum. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  98. ^ PBS.org (2002-09-05). "How Big is Mexico's Problem?". Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  99. ^ a b Ronén Waisser (2002-10-07). "(Spanish) Cost of Corruption in Mexico". Monterrey Technological-Center of Strategic Studies. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  100. ^ PBS.org (2002-09-05). "How Big is Mexico's Problem?". Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  101. ^ Rocio Moreno Lopez. "The Lack Of Transparency And Accountability Mechanisms For Mexico’s Oil Income". Economic Policy Mexico’s Rights-To –Reforms Civil Rights Perspective. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  102. ^ Lost in Transition: Bold Ambitions, Limited Results for Human Rights Under Fox. New York: Human Rights Watch. 2006. ISBN 1-56432-337-4. Retrieved 2011-03-11. 
  103. ^ FUNDAR.org (2010-05-28). "(Spanish) Press Release: The opacity is gaining ground in Mexico". Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  104. ^ Zachary Bookman (2008-04-22). "Shine a Light on Mexico". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  105. ^ Sanjeev Gupta, Hamid Davoodi, Rosa Alonso-Terme (1998-05). "Does Corruption Affect Income Inequality and Poverty?". International Monetary Fund. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  106. ^ George W. Grayson (2009-11-19). "Health care and illegal immigrants in America: why Mexico is the key". The Christian Science Monitor. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  107. ^ David Davia Estefan and Jorge Romero Leon. "Legislators in the Labyrinth: Discretion and Opacity in the Policy Debate over Mexico’s Budget". Economic Policy Mexico’s Rights-to-Know Reforms Civil Society Perspectives. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  108. ^ Transparency International. "Preventing Corruption on Construction Projects". Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  109. ^ Jorge Cisnero (2004=07-28). "(Spanish) Poverty in Mexico: an Evaluation of Conditions, Trends, and Government Strategy". World Bank. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  110. ^ Leigh Gantner (2007-11-08). "PROGRESA: An Integrated Approach to Poverty Alleviation in Mexico". Cornell University Library. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  111. ^ Warren Olney (2009-01-01). "Mexico's anti-poverty program, Oportunidades". Public Radio International. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  112. ^ "(Spanish) Strategic Planning for the Transparency Collective". El Colectiva por la Transparencia. 2007-02-08. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  113. ^ "(Spanish) Accountability, Access to Information and Transparency in Civil Society Organizations". El Colectiva por la Transparencia. 2005. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  114. ^ "The Mexico Freedom of Information Program". George Washington University. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  115. ^ Benjamin F. Bogado, Emilene Martinez-Morales, Bethany D. Noll, and Kyle Bell (December 2007). "The Federal Institute For Access to Information & A Culture of Transparency (A Followup Report)". University of Pennsylvania. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  116. ^ a b "Mexico's Constitutional Reform Guarantees the Right to Know". George Washington University. Retrieved 2011-03-10. 
  117. ^ "(Spanish) Transparency in Quaretaro". El Colectivo por la Transparencia. 2008-12-10. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  118. ^ "Denouncing Changes to Transparency and Access to Information in Queretaro". El Colectivo por la Transparencia. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  119. ^ "(Spanish) The Autonomy of IFAI in the Hands of the Supreme Court of Justice of the Nation". El Colectivo por la Transparencia. Retrieved 2011-03-10. [dead link]
  120. ^ Caribbean and Latin American Economic Commission (CEPAL) (2009-01-24). "(Spanish) Primary Education Would Reduce Hunger". Milenio. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  121. ^ CONEVAL (2009). "CONEVAL's 2009 Fact Sheet". U.S. Embassy in Mexico City. Retrieved 2010-11-16. 
  122. ^ a b United Nations Development Programme-Mexico (2010-10). "HDI in Mexico; pg. 41". United Nations Development Programme. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  123. ^ Agencia EFE (2009-07-19). "(Spanish)Mexico with more than 50 Million Poor". El Expectador. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  124. ^ Considering Mexico has the second biggest population in Latin America and 49-50+ million in poverty-- Brazil has over 57 million in poverty-- the result is Mexico with second highest number of poor in the Western Hemisphere.
  125. ^ CIA World FactBook (2010-11-09). "2010 GDP Comparison Chart". Retrieved 2010-11-25. 
  126. ^ Only China, India and Brazil have a higher amount of people in poverty than Mexico among nations with higher GDP than Mexico.
  127. ^ By analyzing nations' poverty rates and their populations: Mexico's 2010 estimate at 111,212,000 and 44.2 rate of poverty from 2009 CONEVAL's study.
  128. ^ By analyzing nations with greater population than Mexico and their poverty rates.
  129. ^ a b c United Nations Development Programme (2010-11-04). "2010 Human Development Index; pgs. 142-146". UNDP. Retrieved 2010-11-25. 

Further reading[edit]

External links[edit]