Pasty tax

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article

 
Jump to: navigation, search
Cornish pasty – cut

Pasty tax was a popular phrase used by the British press to describe a proposal made by the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Conservative MP George Osborne, in the 2012 United Kingdom budget to simplify the tax treatment of “hot takeaway food” so that Value Added Tax (VAT) would be charged at 20% in all cases. The change would hit sales of hot snacks such as sausage rolls and Cornish pasties sold on the premises where they were baked.

The issue became a political controversy, described by at least one newspaper [1] as a political scandal, dubbed Pastygate in March 2012.

Background[edit]

Under long-standing VAT legislation, sale of most food bought to eat or cook at home is zero-rated for VAT (no tax is charged). By contrast, meals bought and consumed in a restaurant, and hot take-away food or drink, are charged at the standard 20% tax rate. (In addition, items such as chocolate products, juice, soft and alcoholic drinks are always standard-rated.)

At the boundary between these two classes, there was a history of legal challenges around food which is baked for sale, and is sold while still hot. If this could be claimed to be hot only incidentally, it could be zero-rated, as for example freshly baked bread but also pies, pasties etc. Revenue and Customs (HMRC) guidance[2] stated:

4.4 What about freshly cooked products?

If you sell freshly cooked products for consumption while they are still hot they are standard-rated, see paragraph 4.5.

Some of these products are, however, not sold with such an intention. They may only be hot/warm as they are in the process of cooling down. Examples include pies, pasties, sausage rolls and similar savoury products, cooked chickens or joints of meat, bread products and croissants. The liability will depend, therefore, on how you prepare and sell them.

If they are sold specifically for consumption whilst still hot (as a result of being freshly prepared, baked, cooked, reheated or kept warm), they will be standard-rated. See also paragraph 4.5

If they are sold warm simply because they happen to be freshly baked, are in the process of cooling down and are not intended to be eaten while hot; or cold or chilled at the time of purchase, they can be zero-rated.

4.5 What do we mean by ‘specifically sold for consumption whilst still hot’?

You sell food specifically for consumption whilst still hot if you either:

  • have an established hot take-away trade and are selling the food as a part of that trade
  • advertise it as either hot take-away food or in any other way which indicates that it is meant to be eaten while still hot
  • sell it accompanied by napkins, forks, etc to enable it to be eaten before it cools

In the March budget papers, the Government published a paper[3] which claimed:

The borderline between hot takeaway food (standard-rated) and cold takeaway food (zero-rated) has for a number of years been the subject of litigation with some retailers arguing that the purpose of heating their food products is to improve their appearance or to comply with health and safety regulations, rather than to enable them to be consumed hot. This litigation has been decided on the facts of each individual case.

The document proposed to

apply VAT at the standard rate to all food which is at a temperature above the ambient air temperature at the time that it is provided to the customer, with the exception of freshly baked bread. This will clarify the rules in this area and ensure that all hot takeaway food is taxed consistently.

"Don't Tax My Pasty"[edit]

In response to the ensuing row, a number of campaigns were begun in order to try to prevent the tax rise on the cornish pasty. These ranged from The Sun '​s "Who VAT all the pies" campaign to an on-line petition set up by the Cornish Pasty Association entitled "Don't Tax My Pasty".[4] The issue was also taken up on Facebook and Twitter.[5]

"Out of touch" claim[edit]

A Labour Member of Parliament (John Mann MP) asked the Chancellor of the Exchequer, Conservative MP George Osborne, about when he last ate a Cornish pasty. Osborne answered that he had no idea when he had last eaten one. This answer has been used to show how out of touch with ordinary people the Conservative party had become. The Prime Minister David Cameron later said that he had recently eaten a Cornish pasty at Leeds railway station "and that it was very good". However, The Sun newspaper then reported[6] that there was no place to buy Cornish pasties at Leeds railway station at the time David Cameron claimed to have eaten one there.

The issue, which at first appeared to be unimportant, was then taken up by several other newspapers and political commentators. They pointed out that the Conservatives seemed not to know that the pasty was a basic food eaten by many ordinary people in the country. The VAT rise on the pasty would affect both these customers and the pasty industry itself. These newspapers and commentators made fun of David Cameron's attempt to show himself as a regular pasty eater[7] (i.e. as one of the people) and George Osborne's inability to remember when he had last eaten a pasty.[8]

References[edit]