Never Let Me Go (2010 film)

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article

Never Let Me Go
Neverletmegoposterquad.jpg
UK theatrical release poster
Directed byMark Romanek
Produced by
Screenplay byAlex Garland
Based onNever Let Me Go 
by Kazuo Ishiguro
Starring
Narrated byCarey Mulligan
Music byRachel Portman[1]
CinematographyAdam Kimmel
Edited byBarney Pilling
Production
company
Distributed byFox Searchlight Pictures
Release dates
  • 3 September 2010 (2010-09-03) (Telluride Film Festival)
  • 15 September 2010 (2010-09-15) (U.S.)
  • 11 February 2011 (2011-02-11) (U.K.)
Running time103 minutes
CountryUnited Kingdom
United States
LanguageEnglish
Budget$15 million
Box office$9,455,232
 
Jump to: navigation, search
Never Let Me Go
Neverletmegoposterquad.jpg
UK theatrical release poster
Directed byMark Romanek
Produced by
Screenplay byAlex Garland
Based onNever Let Me Go 
by Kazuo Ishiguro
Starring
Narrated byCarey Mulligan
Music byRachel Portman[1]
CinematographyAdam Kimmel
Edited byBarney Pilling
Production
company
Distributed byFox Searchlight Pictures
Release dates
  • 3 September 2010 (2010-09-03) (Telluride Film Festival)
  • 15 September 2010 (2010-09-15) (U.S.)
  • 11 February 2011 (2011-02-11) (U.K.)
Running time103 minutes
CountryUnited Kingdom
United States
LanguageEnglish
Budget$15 million
Box office$9,455,232

Never Let Me Go is a 2010 British dystopian science fiction drama film based on Kazuo Ishiguro's 2005 novel of the same name. The film was directed by Mark Romanek from a screenplay by Alex Garland. Never Let Me Go is set in an alternate history and centres on Kathy, Ruth and Tommy portrayed by Carey Mulligan, Keira Knightley and Andrew Garfield respectively, who become entangled in a love triangle. Principal photography began in April 2009 and lasted several weeks. The movie was filmed at various locations, including Andrew Melville Hall. Never Let Me Go was produced by DNA Films and Film4 on a $15 million budget.

The film was directed by Mark Romanek from a screenplay by Alex Garland. Never Let Me Go is set in an alternate history and centres on Kathy, Ruth and Tommy portrayed by Carey Mulligan, Keira Knightley and Andrew Garfield respectively, who become entangled in a love triangle. Principal photography began in April 2009 and lasted several weeks. The movie was filmed at various locations, including Andrew Melville Hall. Never Let Me Go was produced by DNA Films and Film4 on a $15 million budget.

Prior to the book's publication, Garland had approached the film's producers—Andrew Macdonald and Andrew Reich—about a possible film, and wrote a 96-page script. The producers initially had trouble finding an actress to play Kathy. Mulligan was cast in the role after Peter Rice, the head of the company financing the film, recommended her by text message while watching her performance in An Education. Mulligan, a fan of the book, enthusiastically accepted the role, as it had long been a wish of hers to have the opportunity to play the part. The film's message and themes were the factors that attracted Garfield to become a part of the film.

Never Let Me Go premiered at the 37th annual Telluride Film Festival in September 2010, where the audience positively responded to its message. The film was also screened at festivals including the 2010 Toronto International Film Festival, and the 54th London Film Festival which it opened. The film was distributed by Fox Searchlight Pictures to cinemas in the United States on 15 September 2010, where it was given a limited release. It opened on 14 January 2011 in the United Kingdom. In the United States, Never Let Me Go opened at four theatres, grossing over $111,000 during its first weekend, eventually growing to $2.5 million. The movie got off to a better start in its first weekend in the UK, earning £625,000 and taking ninth place at the box office.

Never Let Me Go earned $9.4 million at the box office and an additional $1.8 million in DVD sales revenue. Never Let Me Go was met with generally positive reviews from film critics, with most reviewers praising the cast's overall performances. It was placed on several critics' top ten lists for the year.

Plot[edit]

On-screen captions explain that a medical breakthrough in 1952 has permitted the human lifespan to be extended beyond 100 years. This cuts to a young man (Andrew Garfield) lying on an operating table and smiling at a woman observing from the other side of the glass window. The woman is 28-year-old Kathy H (Carey Mulligan), the narrator. She reminisces about her childhood at a boarding school called Hailsham, as well as her adult life after leaving the school. The first act of the film depicts the young Kathy (Izzy Meikle-Small), along with her friends Tommy (Charlie Rowe) and Ruth (Ella Purnell), spending their childhood at Hailsham in the late 1970s. The school is strange; students are encouraged to create artwork instead of learning science and mathematics normal for school children. Their best work gets into "the Gallery" run by a mysterious woman known only as Madame. One day, a new teacher, Miss Lucy (Sally Hawkins) quietly informs the students of their nature: they exist only as organ donors for transplants, and will die - or, rather, "complete" - in their early adulthood. She is shortly afterward sacked by the headmistress for telling this to the students. As time passes, Kathy and Tommy develop feelings for one another, but Tommy falls into a relationship with Ruth.

In the second act of the film, the three friends, now 18, are rehoused in cottages on a farm. They are permitted to leave the grounds on day trips, but are still resigned to their eventual fate. At the farm, they meet former pupils of other schools. Two of these students see a woman in a nearby town whom they believe to be a "possible" for Ruth - the person she was cloned from. Ruth is ecstatic at the prospect, but when she, Kathy, Tommy, and the other students travel to the coast to re-examine the woman, it turns out there is very little resemblance. Ruth, bitter and disillusioned, rages that all donors are "modelled on trash", meaning that they are cloned from the people lowest in society, such as prostitutes and criminals.

From the others, Kathy and her friends hear rumors of the possibility of "deferral" – a temporary reprieve from organ donation for donors who are in love and can somehow prove it. Tommy becomes convinced that the Gallery at Hailsham was intended to look into their souls and that artwork sent to the Gallery will be able to verify true love. The relationship between Tommy and Ruth becomes sexual, putting a strain on Kathy's friendships with the two. Kathy, feeling the need to distance herself, leaves the cottages to become a "carer" – a clone who is given a temporary reprieve from donation to do the job of supporting and comforting donors. Tommy and Ruth break up shortly before Kathy leaves.

In the third and final act of the film, ten years later, Kathy is working as a carer and has not seen Ruth or Tommy since the cottages. While working as a carer, Kathy happens to meet Ruth again, who is frail after two donations. They find Tommy, who is also weakened, and the three of them drive to the sea at Ruth's request. There, Ruth asks for their forgiveness for keeping them apart. She admits she has always known that Kathy and Tommy were meant to be together; Ruth was with Tommy because she was jealous of his closeness to Kathy and afraid to be "left alone". She claims she has found a means to put things right: she has found Madame's address and believes it is she who gives out the deferrals to couples in love. Though reluctant at first, Kathy eventually agrees to give it a try. Shortly afterward, Ruth dies on the operating table during her third donation.

Kathy and Tommy finally begin a relationship, though Tommy is weak from his donations. Tommy explains to Kathy that he has been creating art as an adult in the hope that it will convince Madame to give them a deferral. He and Kathy drive to visit Madame, who lives with the headmistress of Hailsham. The two teachers sympathetically tell them that there have never been any such deferrals. They also explain that the purpose of the Gallery was not to look into their souls, but to determine if they had souls at all. Hailsham had been, in fact, the last remaining place to consider the ethical implications of the donor programme. After Kathy and Tommy have left, Tommy requests Kathy to stop the car to let him out and breaks down in an explosion of rage and frustration. Kathy consoles him and the two cry in each other's arms. The movie returns to the first shot: Tommy is being anaesthetised on the operating table for what would be his last organ donation, while looking and smiling at Kathy who is standing on the other side of the glass window.

The film ends with Kathy still living, but knowing that her organ donations will begin in one month.

Cast[edit]

Themes[edit]

Director Mark Romanek has said that, as in the novel, everyone has to uncover their relationship to our own mortality; we have two options: either go against it, or try to figure out a way around it like the character Tommy does.[2] Romanek hoped the audience of Never Let Me Go would be reminded of what is important: love, behaviour, and friendships. He recalled an email a person had written to him: "'I saw your film and it made me cry and I haven’t reacted to a film emotionally like that in years. And I called my father, cause I realized I hadn’t spoken to him in 3 weeks and I told him how much I love him and how much I appreciated what a good father he's been.'"[2]

Andrew Garfield believes the story of Never Let Me Go is about humans, and exploring "what it is to have a soul, and how you prove what a soul is"; he says he enjoys the way the film is a "call to arms" about the positives of life.[3] He adds that its message could hopefully remind people that they have a choice when they arise in the morning whether to pursue their own choice of activities for the day, or to do what they should do or are obliged to do.[3] Keira Knightley feels that the film's story is alarming, but has said that the film is "more about humanity's ability to look the other way". "You know in fact that if your morals can go out the window if you think you can survive in a certain way, whatever your morals may be".[4]

Production[edit]

Development[edit]

Alex Garland, a long-time friend of Ishiguro, asked the author for the rights to the novel before he had finished reading it.[5] Before the novel was published in 2005, Garland had already written a script for a possible film. He gave the screenplay to two producers, Andrew Macdonald and Allon Reich, and development started at that moment. "We are delighted to be shooting this special project, which Alex Garland first brought to us before the book's publication in 2005."[6] The script for the film was 96 pages long, done in chapters.[7] Director Mark Romanek was originally attached to The Wolfman, but when he was dropped from that production for an unknown reason, he accepted the offer to work on Never Let Me Go.[8] The movie was made into a dystopian drama.[9] Romanek was glad to get the opportunity to shoot this film: "From the moment I finished [reading] the novel, it became my dream to film it. Ishiguro's conception is so daring, so eerie and beautiful. Alex Garland's adaptation is sensitive and precise. The cast is perfect, the crew superb."[6] The Seattle Times observed that the project was "something of a departure" for the novelist, noting that it merges Ishiguro's signature "elegant prose with a decidedly science-fiction theme".[10]

Garland, who has explored science fiction themes in some of his previous work, was a sounding board for ideas for the novel and an early reader of the book. Ishiguro stated that, despite Garland's screenwriting skills and previous experience with film, they did not discuss the idea of a film until after the novel was complete.[10] "I try not to think about things like that when writing a novel—in fact, quite the reverse", he stated. He said that he attempts to "go for something... very interior, following thoughts and memories, something that I think is difficult to do on the screen, which is essentially a third-person medium."[10] Thus he was surprised when Garland, after reading a complete version of the book, said he would like to try to adapt it. Ishiguro recalled that Garland wrote a draft very quickly and immediately asked of his opinion of it "as a first go".[10] Ishiguro was very satisfied with Garland's screenplay—which was changed very little from its initial draft to the filmed version—and with the final film. When asked to compare the experience with that of The Remains of the Day, he acknowledged that both were more hands-on with this film.[10] Romanek said that he did not make Never Let Me Go a science fiction film; rather he was presenting a love story with fictional science context mixed in. He described the film as telling a "love story where the science fiction is this subtle patina on the story." The filmmaker explained that had they done the film with "science fiction-y things", it would have been more openly, with props such as futuristic structures and devices.[2]

Casting[edit]

Carey Mulligan plays the narrator, Kathy, an introverted, observant character who projects both innocence and knowingness, and who over the course of the story develops from a passionate, optimistic child to a wise and accepting young woman.[11] Prior to her casting, Mulligan had already read the novel a few times, considering it to be a favourite of hers.[12][13] She recalled that from when she first read the book three years ago she had wanted to play Kathy.[7] The young actress said that she could not "bear the idea of anyone else" portraying Kathy, although she acknowledged that she thought other people would be able to do a better performance.[13] She was certain that someone would make a film adaptation of the novel and had hoped that they would wait until she would be old enough to play the character. Romanek told The Los Angeles Times that he originally was having difficultly finding the right actress to play Kathy; a tight filming deadline loomed prior to Mulligan's casting.[11] Peter Rice, the head of Fox Searchlight (the company financing the film) was watching An Education at the Sundance Film Festival in January. He wrote Romanek a four-word text message: "Hire the genius Mulligan."[11] When later asked why the message was so abrupt, he explained that he was still in the middle of viewing the film. Rice exhibited what was described as a "rare foresight" in greenlighting a film with an almost unknown lead actress. "He just knew that she was it", said Romanek.[11]

Romanek (far left), Ishiguro (front), Purnell, Meikle-Small, Mulligan, Knightley, and Garfield at a screening of Never Let Me Go at the BFI London Film Festival

Andrew Garfield was given the role of Tommy, a well-meaning, rather dim young person who struggles to find a place in an environment which values imagination and creativity above all. He said of his character, "There's a sense of anxiety that runs through these kids, especially Tommy, because he's so sensory and feeling and animalistic, that's my perspective of him."[13] Garfield was attracted to the film based on the existential questions the story expresses.[13] He called the experience of being a part of Never Let Me Go a "dream to come true".[14] Garfield enjoys an opportunity to let loose with his roles. He said the scenes in which his character—unable to contain his frustration—erupts with a wail, was "intense" for him. "I think those screams are inside all of us, I just got a chance to let mine out".[3] Before shooting the film, he had read the screenplay and the book.[14] In March 2009 Daily Variety reported that Knightley was signed to the project.[15] Knightley admitted that she only agreed to appear in Never Let Me Go because co-star and friend Mulligan had asked her to.[16] She portrays Ruth, a zealous, ambitious character who behaves manipulatively out of inner insecurity. When asked what she did and did not have in common with her character, Knightley said she was unable to relate to Ruth's situation of being involved in a love triangle.[4]

The three lead characters do not have last names because "they are not normal people".[17] Romanek believed that the three main characters act with intense dignity. He noted that they are not materialistic or looking for power, but just desire to acknowledge their love for each other and stay close in their friendship.[2] An example he mentioned was how Ruth tries to seek redemption by attempting to set right a big mistake she had made. What he found the most moving aspect of the film was the "graceful place of acceptance that Kathy comes to at the end".[2] Child actors Isobel Meikle-Small, Ella Purnell, and Charlie Rowe play the younger versions of Never Let Me Go '​s three lead actors.[18] Hawkins, who co-starred with Mulligan in An Education, had a supporting role as Miss Lucy, who is a teacher at an isolated English boarding school where the students slowly become aware of the fact that they are feared by people in the outside world.[19] Charlotte Rampling portrays Miss Emily, a schoolmaster who presides over the orphanage at Hailsham.[20] Richard was cast as an administrator, who is known as Madame. The character has been conducting an ongoing project that aims to analyse the students’ characters and psychologies, which has been compared to treating them as if they were subjects in an experiment.[21] Riseborough's casting in Never Let Me Go was announced in April 2009 by Screen Daily;[22] she had a small role in the film.[11]

Filming[edit]

Never Let Me Go was given a production budget of US$15 million.[23] Principal photography for the film started in April 2009 and lasted a few weeks. Production design was done by Mark Digby, and Adam Kimmel was assigned to cinematography. The commercial director was Duncan Reid, who works for Ingenious Media,[24] and the film was shot by crewmembers of the English company DNA Films.[25] On 8 May 2009, the production moved to Norfolk for filming. The beach at Holkham is also featured in the film. Knightley previously shot scenes at nearby Holkham Hall for her 2008 film The Duchess.[26] A location on Hill Road In Clevedon was used, and a shop was converted into a travel agency. They also filmed on the beach and the Victorian pier in Clevedon. The pier is featured on the film poster and the cover of the rereleased book. A large property on the Bexhill-on-Sea seafront was used on 12 and 13 May 2009 to act as the exterior for the residence of Madame, where Tommy and Kathy go to apply for a deferral.

Andrew Melville Hall in the University of St. Andrews was the setting for the Dover Recovery Centre.[25] Nearly thirty film extras, film producers, and location scouts had to wait several hours for the sun to set so they could film the scenes there.[25] The restaurant scene, which is featured in the trailer and in promotional screenshots, was shot in the Regent Restaurant and Coffee Lounge in Weston-super-Mare in April 2009.[27] Chiswick Town Hall, a dark building in London, was also used as a shooting location. The scenes where the Hailsham assemblies were held was filmed at a school in Snaresbrook, called Forest School, in May 2009.[4] Ham House, Richmond, was used for filming mostly exterior scenes at Hailsham School and a couple of interior scenes.

Romanek called working with child actors and "knowing that the first act of the film was going to have to be carried by 12-year-olds" almost certainly the most difficult challenge of making the film. He said that most of the rehearsal schedule was focused on helping to ensure that the first act would be good.[2] At rehearsals, the film-maker would have the younger actors observe the older actors practise the first-act scenes. This had a double purpose: the older actors would have a memory of having played those scenes, while the child actors would get a better idea of how a more skilled actor would play their part. Romanek would then mix and match the actors (for example, Mulligan would do a scene with the child playing the younger Tommy).[2] He also had them spend time together doing things like playing and talking. He took them to the school location and let them play games together so they could get a better idea of the layout of the place.[2]

According to Mulligan, a problem during the production was that her role required her to drive: at the time she did not know how to drive or have a driver's licence. She did a two-week intensive course to learn how to work a manual gear change so she could eventually film the driving scenes, but failed the driving test. "I’m really bad at it", she explained. "[I have] no hand and eye coordination."[28] The production team ultimately had to shoot the scene on a private road, where she was allowed to get behind the wheel.[28] The director had a hard time making Knightley look plain in the film. He tells in an interview: "It was difficult. She was eager and happy to do it because the role called for it. But even at her worst, Keira still looks astonishing".[29]

When accessing the very deep emotions called for by her character, Mulligan stated, "I really took my cue from the book". She noted that her role did not require her to have much to say, because Kathy was more of an observer throughout most of the film. She recalled that "every time I was in a scene where I wasn’t quite sure where I was going with it, I would go to the book and read through the lines because she's unreliable, in that much of the time she's not being truly honest with herself or the audience."[30] The young actress said that her friendship with Knightley made their scenes together easier because they would both perceive each other's comments as being helpful and would not feel "insulted or hurt".[30]

Music[edit]

Never Let Me Go '​s score was composed by British composer Rachel Portman. She worked on Never Let Me Go '​s music for four months.[31] Portman said that because of the film's sad themes, she wanted to "put some hope" and humanity into the music. It was important to her that there be a "real emotional heartbeat in the midst of this story." Believing that a "huge sweeping score" would not have fit Never Let Me Go, she instead worked with a smaller orchestra of no more than 48 players.[31] At the urgent request of the director and the producers, she tried other approaches, such as the use of a child's voice and what was described as a "big finale cue." In the end, they went for a simpler and more subtle approach. Stating that most of the score was written for piano, strings and harp, with solos for violin and cello, she called her score something of a "chamber piece". "If you use a solo instrument, it's like having a voice", she says.[31] "It highlights the emotion." But, she adds, "the violin is played with virtually no vibrato, because I didn't ever want it to sound sentimental". She notes that "for my own taste, I stay on the side of restraint, because I think it works better in film".[31] Her work on Never Let Me Go earned her a San Diego Film Critics Society Award for Best Score.[32]

Promotion and release[edit]

Romanek and Garfield at the screening of Never Let Me Go at the 2010 Toronto International Film Festival

In July 2010 Never Let Me Go was screened to film critics, who gave it generally positive reviews, with The Daily Telegraph calling the film's three leads "brilliant".[33] Never Let Me Go premièred at the 37th annual Telluride Film Festival, presented by the National Film Preserve. The festival began on 3 September 2010, running through Labor Day in a remote Colorado town.[34] The Hollywood Reporter observed that the audience "seemed to respond positively to the film's look at what makes us human and what defines a soul."[35] The film was also part of the 35th Toronto International Film Festival (TIFF) line-up during September 2010, and was screened along with 300 other films.[36] According to Deadline Hollywood, Never Let Me Go was originally expected to have its world premiere at the 2010 Venice Film Festival in September, but Fox replaced it with Black Swan. They favored the TIFF over Venice,[37] but eventually settled on the Telluride Film Festival.

In the same month, the film was screened during the 2010 Fantastic Fest in Austin, Texas.[38] Never Let Me Go opened the 54th London Film Festival on 13 October 2010, the same day as its European release date.[39] Never Let Me Go was the second film based on an Ishiguro novel to open the festival, after Merchant IvoryIsmail Merchant's The Remains of the Day in 1993. Regarding the film's screening at the London Film Festival, Ishiguro said, "It is a fantastic privilege, I feel very lucky. To some extent it is a showcase for British talent and it's a tremendous honour".[40] Describing Never Let Me Go as "accomplished and imaginative", Sandra Helborn, the London Film Festival Artistic Director, added that "It combines impeccable film making, outstanding performances and a deeply moving story, and I couldn’t wish for a stronger or more appropriate opening night".[40] That same month it was also screened in competition at Japan's Tokyo International Film Festival.[41] Six screenings of the film were held in the Little Theatre at Western Michigan University between 17–19 December 2010.[42]

Never Let Me Go was scheduled for a limited release for select cities in the United States on 1 October 2010,[43] but the date was later moved up to 15 September.[44] The film was released in the United Kingdom on 11 February 2011, and in France on 9 February 2011.[45] As a forum of promotion for the film, Mulligan made guest appearances to introduce Never Let Me Go at movie theatre screenings, including at the Landmark Theatres and AMC Loews Lincoln Square.[46] Upon the film's release at the Telluride Film Festival, a writer for the Los Angeles Times called the film an "Oscar wild card". He believed its reviews were "likely to be split between those who consider the film a bleak masterpiece and others who find it straining so mightily for aesthetic perfection that it fails to provide a gripping narrative."[47] The Globe and Mail called Never Let Me Go one of 2010's "big noise" films.[48] In the United States, Never Let Me Go was released on DVD on 1 February 2011.[49] By 6 February, it had sold 44,911 units (amounting to $628,305 in consumer revenue) and was the 17th-best selling DVD for that week.[50] To date, the DVD sales revenue stands at $1,886,997.[50]

Box office[edit]

In its opening weekend in the United Kingdom, between 11–13 February 2011, it took ninth place at the box office. Playing on 265 screens, it took in an estimated UK£625,000 (US$1,001,483), which was seen as a disappointment to the British press.[51] In Never Let Me Go '​s next week, it had a 45% decrease in revenue, taking in about UK£338,404 (US$546,653).[52] Never Let Me Go has made a total of US$9,455,232 worldwide.

Never Let Me Go was released to four movie theaters in its opening weekend in the United States, with an additional one hundred-sixty-three theatres added to its theatrical run later on.[23] The film became the number one-screening at these four theatres on its opening day,[46] and grossed slightly over US$44,500 from those select screenings.[23] In its opening weekend, the film made over US$111,700, averaging US$30,250 per theatre, taking 42nd place at the box office.[23] In its succeeding week, revenues for Never Let Me Go saw an 117% increase, making about US$241,000, with an average of nearly US$9,500 per theatre. It was the 28th top grossing film at the box office for that week.[23] By its third week of release, the film suffered a revenue decrease to around US$188,000, despite being screened at more theatres than the previous week.[23] After one month of release, it pulled in US$350,000, increasing nearly 90 percent from its previous weekend.[23]

According to a news piece published by the Los Angeles Times on 21 October, by Never Let Me Go '​s fifth week of release it had been labeled an "undeniable disappointment" commercially. The publication noted that when its release widened to over 200 theatres the previous weekend its per-theatre average was so low that its distributor decided to cut its screens in the succeeding weeks.[53] Based on answers from film experts and executives for Fox Searchlight, there were five factors to why the film commercially disappointed: its timing, airing too early in the year when lighter summer fare is still popular; a novel that is particularly difficult to adapt; mixed reviews from critics; its depressing tone; and its lack of appeal to male viewers.[53] In the following weeks Never Let Me Go began to gross under US$100,000 per weekend, going on to earn US$2.5 million in the US by the second week of December.[23]

Critical response[edit]

Never Let Me Go has received generally positive reviews from critics, with the cast's performances being praised. The critical consensus on review site Rotten Tomatoes states that "With Never Let Me Go, Mark Romanek has delivered a graceful adaptation that captures the spirit of the Ishiguro novel -- which will be precisely the problem for some viewers." It holds a 71% rating based on 164 reviews. The film's overall result has been viewed as a disappointment by some reviewers when compared to the novel. A Daily Mail reporter declared the film to be "the most haunting film about love and death I've ever seen",[54] and film critic David Gritten of The Daily Telegraph saluted the film, applauding the production and the performances of its supporting cast.[40] Saul Austerlitz, a correspondent to the Boston Globe, felt that the film struck a "mournful note" and believed that certain images in the film, such as a tree in an empty field, "possess a haunting power directly lifted from the best of Romanek's video work", while respecting the themes in Ishiguro's novel.[55]

The Hollywood Reporter writer Jay A. Fernandez said that Never Let Me Go was an engaging film, but he thought that its overall impact was not as emotionally devastating as the book.[35] Cleveland Magazine '​s Clint O'Connor strongly approved the acting performance of Garfield,[56] and Eric Kohn from indieWIRE praised the script and the photography of Kimmel and Garland.[57]

In a short review, Chris Knight of the National Post wrote that the film was able to capture the wistfulness and the unpredictable tone of Ishiguro's novel, but added that it "spills the beans much sooner".[58] Mark Jenkins of NPR called Never Let Me Go a "remarkably successful adaptation" of Ishiguro's book, but acknowledged that Romanek and Garland "do make a few missteps", which were mostly the result of the limitations of turning the novel's contents into a film.[59] Entertainment Weekly film critic Owen Gleiberman described the film as feeling like a "period piece" and rated it a C+.[60] Reuters '​s Stephen Farber called the film a disappointment, because although it was "expertly acted, impeccably photographed, intelligently written" and "even intermittently touching", Never Let Me Go is "too parched and ponderous to connect with a large audience".[17] He said the film should have laid out more completely the logic of its parallel universe, such as the cloning process. He found its theme of the dangers of medical experimentation "rather tired".[17]

Slant magazine writer Ed Gonzalez gave the film a two out of four star rating, saying that in Never Let Me Go the characters' actions do not feel "appropriately warped" while the interactions between the teachers and students is not "at all rife with the what-are-they-thinking-about-us mystery of the book".[61] Andrew O'Hehir of Salon.com wrote that Romanek "does so many difficult things beautifully in this movie". He thought the film carried a reminder that life is short regardless of how long it lasts rather than a "lecture about the horrors of human history".[62] Tom Preston from The Guardian described Mulligan and Garfield's acting as solid, while commenting that Knightley's emotional performances are occasionally jarring. He further wrote that although Never Let Me Go finely demonstrated subtlety, its screenplay could have been written with less compression in some parts.[63] Writing in Newsweek, Louisa Thomas praised the film for its beauty and its performances but declared that "there's something just missing here."[64]

Marshall Fine of The Huffington Post noted that like the novel, the film is difficult to embrace. He said that the film does work on a "suspense level", due to Romanek's creating a "quiet, leisurely pace that would not be out of place in a yoga class". He stated that he "no doubt was aiming for an eerie, Children of the Damned vibe, except that it's the children who are damned". The writer concluded that Never Let Me Go '​s final result is a "staid, lifeless tale that never talks about what it's about, or at least not enough to provoke deep thoughts on the subject."[65] Film critic Rex Roberts of Film Journal International thought that the film was moderately surprising given Romanek and Garland's previous work, saying that they "show real affinity for the subtle shades of resignation and quiet desperation that characterize Isighuro's [sic] prose and, as would be expected, accentuate the unsettling eeriness that pervades Never Let Me Go." Roberts felt that Mulligan and Knightley were unconvincing in their roles due to the age differences.[21]

The Canadian Press '​s Christy Lemire stated that the film was a "gorgeous, provocative look at humanity" and observed that like its characters, the film "demands much of its audiences emotionally". She concluded that Never Let Me Go is worth the investment.[66] The Los Angeles Times film critic Kenneth Turan thought that the film was "passionate about deliberation and restraint" and believed that the latter may not appeal to all audiences.[67] Scott Bowles, writing for USA Today, gave the film a negative review, declaring "never was a movie so bleak and empty". He claimed that Never Let Me Go did not "embrace the book's unrelentingly dark tones", but rather wallowed in them. He commented that not even the cast's performance, particularly Garfield's, were enough to redeem the film.[68] New York Times journalist Manohla Dargis said that the film presented "the aspect of a tasteful shocker" because its "cruelty is done so prettily and with such caution that the sting remains light".[69]

Top ten lists[edit]

The film has appeared on the following critics' top ten lists for the best films of 2010:

CriticPublicationRank
Adam KempenaarFilmspotting[70]1st
David PolandMovie City News[71]1st
Tim MillerCape Cod Times[72]2nd
Laron ChapmanThe Oklahoma Daily[73]2nd
Michael AtkinsonThe Village Voice[74]3rd
Richard CorlissTime magazine[75]3rd
Rex ReedThe New York Observer3rd
Julie CrawfordThe Vancouver Courier[76]4th
David GermainAssociated Press[77]5th
Christy LemireAssociated Press[77]7th
Calvin WilsonSt. Louis Post-Dispatch[78]7th
Joe NeumaierNew York Daily News[79]8th
Steven ReaThe Philadelphia Inquirer[80]N/A

Accolades[edit]

AwardDate of ceremonyCategoryRecipientsResult
Alliance of Women Film Journalists[81]10 January 2011Most Beautiful FilmNever Let Me GoNominated
British Independent Film Awards[82]5 December 2010Best British Independent FilmNever Let Me GoNominated
Best DirectorMark RomanekNominated
Best ScreenplayAlex GarlandNominated
Best ActressCarey MulliganWon
Best Supporting ActorAndrew GarfieldNominated
Best Supporting ActressKeira KnightleyNominated
Central Ohio Film Critics Association Awards[83]6 January 2011Best ScoreRachel PortmanNominated
Detroit Film Critics Society[84]16 December 2010Best ActressCarey MulliganNominated
Breakthrough Performance
(Also for The Social Network)
Andrew GarfieldNominated
Evening Standard British Film Awards[85]7 February 2011Best Actor
(Also for The Social Network)
Andrew GarfieldWon
Best ScreenplayAlex GarlandNominated
Hollywood Film Festival[86]25 October 2010Hollywood Film Festival for Best Breakthrough Performance
(Also for The Social Network)
Andrew GarfieldWon
Independent Spirit Awards[87]26 February 2011Best CinematographyAdam KimmelNominated
Indiana Film Critics Association Awards[88]12 December 2010Best FilmNever Let Me GoNominated
London Film Critics' Circle[89]10 February 2011British Actor of the YearAndrew GarfieldNominated
Palm Springs International Film Festival[90]8 January 2011Breakthrough Performance Award
(Also for Wall Street: Money Never Sleeps)
Carey MulliganWon
Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards[91]28 December 2010Top Ten Films and Best PictureNever Let Me GoNominated
Best Actress in a Leading RoleCarey MulliganNominated
Best Screenplay, Adapted from Another MediumNever Let Me GoNominated
Breakthrough Behind the CameraMark RomanekNominated
Overlooked FilmNever Let Me GoWon
Saturn Awards[92]23 June 2011Best Science Fiction FilmNever Let Me GoNominated
Best ActressCarey MulliganNominated
Best Supporting ActorAndrew GarfieldWon
Best Supporting ActressKeira KnightleyNominated
Best WritingAlex GarlandNominated
San Diego Film Critics Society[32]14 December 2010Best ActressCarey MulliganNominated
Best ScoreRachel PortmanWon
Women in Film and Television Awards[93]3 December 2010Best Performance
(Also for An Education)
Carey MulliganWon

See also[edit]

References[edit]

  1. ^ Rachel Portman Scoring Never Let Me Go, Mark Romanek Photographs Ben Stiller /Film. Retrieved 28 February 2010.
  2. ^ a b c d e f g h Leins, Jeff (8 October 2010). "Director Mark Romanek Talks ‘Never Let Me Go’". News In Film. Retrieved 2 November 2010. 
  3. ^ a b c Marshall, Rick (15 September 2010). "Andrew Garfield Calls 'Never Let Me Go' Adaptation A 'Call To Arms'". MTV. Viacom. Retrieved 29 September 2010. 
  4. ^ a b c "A Chilling Turn for Keira Knightley in New Film". CBS News. CBS Interactive Inc. 29 September 2010. Retrieved 29 September 2010. 
  5. ^ a b McGrath, Charles (8 September 2010). "Filmmakers Tread Gently on Author's Dystopia". The New Season Film. Retrieved 14 July 2011. 
  6. ^ a b Brad Brevet (14 April 2009). "Mark Romanek's 'Never Let Me Go' Gains Four New Names as Filming Begins in the UK". RopeofSilicon.com. Retrieved 8 July 2009. 
  7. ^ a b Rachel Abramowitz 'Never Let Me Go' comes to the screen—and Carey Mulligan learns to drive Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 30 July 2010.
  8. ^ Cybergosh (18 December 2008). "Mark Romanek Will Never Let It Go". Movie Blog. Retrieved 11 May 2009. 
  9. ^ Zeitchik, Steve (2 December 2010). "Audiences have embraced 'Mao's Last Dancer'". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 22 May 2011. 
  10. ^ a b c d e Macdonald, Moira (2 October 2010). "Novelist Kazuo Ishiguro on the film adaptation of 'Never Let Me Go'". The Seattle Times. The Seattle Times Company. Retrieved 16 October 2010. 
  11. ^ a b c d e Homaday, Ann (24 September 2010). "After her breakout year, Carey Mulligan still garnering praise for acting". Washington Post (The Washington Post Company). 
  12. ^ Rich, Katey (13 September 2010). "TIFF Interview: Carey Mulligan Breaks Hearts And Grows Up In Never Let Me Go". Cinema Blend (Cinema Blend LLC). 
  13. ^ a b c d Cassandra Szklarski (11 September 2010). "Carey Mulligan couldn't bear anyone else starring in 'Never Let Me Go'". Winnipeg Free Press. The Canadian Press. 
  14. ^ a b McCollum, Charlie (29 September 2010). "Andrew Garfield: Actor on the verge of stardom". San Jose Mercury News. MediaNews Group. Retrieved 29 September 2010. 
  15. ^ Jaafar, Ali; Siegel, Tatiana (1 March 2009). "Keira Knightley set for 'Never'". Variety (Reed Business Information). Retrieved 11 May 2009. 
  16. ^ Ward, Victoria (5 December 2010). "Keira Knightley "nearly retired at 22"". The Daily Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group Limited. Retrieved 24 June 2011. 
  17. ^ a b c Farber, Stephen (6 September 2010). ""Never Let Me Go" a let-down". Reuters. Retrieved 6 September 2010. 
  18. ^ Campbell, Christopher (14 September 2010). "In Praise of Carey Mulligan, Isobel Meikle-Small and the Young-to-Old Casting of "Never Let Me Go"". indieWIRE. SnagFilms. Retrieved 1 October 2010. 
  19. ^ Medina, Jeremy (15 April 2009). "Sally Hawkins lands role in 'Never Let Me Go': Is she destined for big things?". Entertainment Weekly. Time Warner Inc. Retrieved 29 September 2010. 
  20. ^ Baine, Wallace (30 September 2010). "Never Let Me Go' a story of beautiful sadness". California Chronicle (MediaNews Group). 
  21. ^ a b Roberts, Rex (9 September 2010). "Film Review: Never Let Me Go". Film Journal International. Retrieved 14 September 2010. 
  22. ^ Brevet, Brad (14 April 2009). "Mark Romanek's 'Never Let Me Go' Gains Four New Names as Filming Begins in the UK". Screen Daily (EMAP Media). Retrieved 11 May 2009. 
  23. ^ a b c d e f g h "Never Let Me Go". Box Office Mojo (Amazon.com). 
  24. ^ Macnab, Geoffrey (14 May 2009). "The UK private film funds". Screen Daily (EMAP Media). 
  25. ^ a b c "University of St Andrews: Photo of the Week". 16 June 2009. 
  26. ^ Hill, Chris (8 May 2008). "Keira Knightley back in Norfolk for filming". EDP 24. Retrieved 11 May 2009. 
  27. ^ A-list actress in Weston Restaurant The Weston Mercury.
  28. ^ a b Rachel Abramowitz (12 October 2009). "'Never Let Me Go' comes to the screen – and Carey Mulligan learns to drive". The Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). Retrieved 9 October 2009. 
  29. ^ "Director struggled to make Knightley look plain". The Toronto Sun. 16 August 2010. Retrieved 29 September 2010. 
  30. ^ a b Cwelich, Lorraine (15 September 2010). "Carey Mulligan on Her New Movie ‘Never Let Me Go’". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 29 September 2010. 
  31. ^ a b c d Burlingame, Jon (15 December 2010). "Portman took simple approach to 'Never'". Variety. Retrieved 15 December 2010. 
  32. ^ a b "2010 Awards". San Diego Film Critics Society. Retrieved 2 January 2011. 
  33. ^ London River: why we filmed in Finsbury Park The Daily Telegraph. Retrieved 13 July 2010.
  34. ^ Hammond, Pete (2 September 2010). "Telluride Film Festival Kicking Off: First Stop Of Hollywood Awards Season". Deadline Hollywood Daily. Mail.com Media Corporation. Retrieved 2 September 2010. 
  35. ^ a b Fernandez, Jay A. (4 September 2010). "TELLURIDE: Carey Mulligan, Kazuo Ishiguro at 'Never Let Me Go' world première". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved 6 September 2010. 
  36. ^ Peter Howell Howell Ten Great Gets for TIFF The Star. Retrieved 28 July 2010.
  37. ^ Adler, Tim (31 August 2010). "Venice Fest "No Longer Special" Say Critics". Deadline Hollywood. Mail.com Media Corporation. Retrieved 2 September 2010. 
  38. ^ Graham, Bill (28 September 2010). "Impressions from Fantastic Fest – Part 1". Collider.com. Retrieved 2 October 2010. 
  39. ^ "Carey Mulligan drama to open London Film Festival". BBC News (BBC Online). 6 August 2010. Retrieved 14 September 2010. 
  40. ^ a b c Brown, Mark (6 August 2010). "Kazuo Ishiguro's Never Let Me Go to premiere at London Film Festival". The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Retrieved 2 September 2010. 
  41. ^ "The 23rd TIFF, "Never Let Me Go" for Competition!". Tokyo International Film Festival. 29 September 2010. Retrieved 2 November 2010. 
  42. ^ "'Never Let Me Go' comes to Little Theatre". Western Michigan University. 11 December 2010. Retrieved 11 December 2010. 
  43. ^ Chen, David (25 May 2010). "Mark Romanek Announces Release Date for Never Let Me Go". /Film. Archived from the original on 6 August 2010. Retrieved 6 August 2010. 
  44. ^ Dodson, Thomas (30 June 2010). "Never Let Me Go Moves Up 2 Weeks to September 15th!". Inside Searchlight. Fox Searchlight Pictures. Archived from the original on 6 August 2010. Retrieved 6 August 2010. 
  45. ^ "Never Let Me Go". Rotten Tomatoes. Flixster, Inc. Retrieved 2 September 2010. 
  46. ^ a b Wieselman, Jarett (16 September 2010). "Get Carey-d away with 'Never Let Me Go'". New York Post. Retrieved 18 September 2010. 
  47. ^ "'Never Let Me Go' is an Oscar wild card". Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). 7 September 2010. Retrieved 7 September 2010. 
  48. ^ Lacey, Liam (11 September 2010). "Who will be this year's Slumdog Millionaire?". Globe and Mail. Retrieved 11 September 2010. 
  49. ^ "And the Oscar goes to...". Vancouver Sun (Postmedia Network Inc). 3 December 2010. 
  50. ^ a b "Never Let Me Go – DVD Sales". The-Numbers. Nash Information Services, LLC. Retrieved 18 February 2011. 
  51. ^ Gant, Charles (15 February 2011). "Gnomeo and Juliet come up roses, but Never Let Me Go has butterfingers". The Guardian. Guardian News and Media Limited. Retrieved 15 February 2011. 
  52. ^ "United Kingdom Box Office February 18–20, 2011". Box Office Mojo. Amazon.com. Retrieved 24 February 2011. 
  53. ^ a b Zeitchik, Steven (21 October 2010). "Why didn't audiences spark to 'Never Let Me Go'?". Los Angeles Times. Tribune Company. Retrieved 24 October 2010. 
  54. ^ "Why Maggie Gyllenhaal is giving out good vibrations". Daily Mail. Retrieved 2 July 2010. 
  55. ^ Austerlitz, Saul (5 September 2010). "Getting from MTV to the big screen (Page 2)". Boston Globe (New York Times Company). Retrieved 6 September 2010. 
  56. ^ O'Connor, Clint (11 September 2010). "'Never Let Me Go': full out weeper with Carey Mulligan and Andrew Garfield at TIFF". Cleveland Magazine. Cleveland Magazine Inc. Retrieved 12 September 2010. 
  57. ^ Kohn, Eric (10 September 2010). "Toronto Review: One Sad Note: "Never Let Me Go"". indieWIRE. Snag Film. Archived from the original on 18 September 2010. Retrieved 12 September 2010. 
  58. ^ Knight, Chris (11 September 2010). "TIFF Mini Reviews: ‘Black Swan’ and ‘Never Let Me Go’". National Post. National Post Inc. Retrieved 11 September 2010. 
  59. ^ Jenkins, Mark (14 September 2010). "In A Dystopian Britain, Teens Grope Toward A Future". NPR. Retrieved 14 September 2010. 
  60. ^ Owen Gleiberman (15 September 2010). "Never Let Me Go (2010)". Entertainment Weekly. Time Warner Inc. Retrieved 15 September 2010. 
  61. ^ Gonzalez, Ed (12 September 2010). "Never Let Me G". Slant. Retrieved 12 September 2010. 
  62. ^ O'Hehir, Andrew (10 September 2010). "Toronto: The devastating, dystopian "Never Let Me Go"". Salon.com. Salon Media Group. Retrieved 11 September 2010. 
  63. ^ Preston, Tom (10 September 2010). "Never Let Me Go: subtle and subversive". The Guardian (London: Guardian News and Media Limited). Retrieved 12 September 2010. 
  64. ^ Thomas (11 September 2010). "Ishiguro wants his fiction to be unfilmable. 'Never Let Me Go' comes close to granting his wish.". Newsweek. Washington Post Company. Retrieved 12 September 2010. 
  65. ^ Fine, Marshall (13 September 2010). "HuffPost Review: Never Let Me Go". Huffington Post. HuffingtonPost.com, Inc. Retrieved 13 September 2010. 
  66. ^ Lemire, Christy (14 September 2010). "Movie review: The sci-fi drama 'Never Let Me Go' a gorgeous, provocative look at humanity". The Canadian Press. 
  67. ^ Turan, Kenneth (15 September 2010). "Movie review: 'Never Let Me Go'". Los Angeles Times (Tribune Company). Retrieved 14 September 2010. 
  68. ^ Bowles, Scott (14 September 2010). "'Never Let Me Go': Never was a movie so bleak and empty". USA Today (Gannett Co. Inc.). Retrieved 14 September 2010. 
  69. ^ Dargis, Monohla. "Growing Up in a Hush, With the Ultimate Identity Crisis". New York Times (New York Times Company). 
  70. ^ Kempenaar, Adam (14 January 2011). "#331: Top 10 Films of 2010". Filmspotting. Telegraph Road Publishing. Retrieved 17 February 2011. 
  71. ^ Poland, David (2 January 2011). "#331: Top 10 2010: Part Two – The 10". Movie City News. Retrieved 18 February 2011. 
  72. ^ Miller, Tim (7 January 2011). "'Dragon Tattoo' tops best-of movie list". Cape Cod Times. Dow Jones Local Media Group. Retrieved 8 January 2011. 
  73. ^ Chapman, Laron; Somers, Dusty (13 December 2010). "Top films of 2010". The Oklahoma Daily. OU Student Media. Retrieved 13 December 2010. 
  74. ^ Atkinson, Michael (2010). "Year-End Film Poll — 2010". The Village Voice. Village Voice Media. Retrieved 2 January 2011. 
  75. ^ Corliss, Richard (9 December 2010). "The Top 10 Everything of 2010". Time magazine (Time Warner Inc). Retrieved 9 December 2010. 
  76. ^ Courier, Julie (30 December 2010). "Meth-heads, Internet moguls, ballerinas top 2010". The Vancouver Courier. Postmedia Network Inc. Retrieved 31 December 2010. 
  77. ^ a b "AP Critics Germain, Lemire Pick Top Films of 2010". ABC News (American Broadcasting Company). 20 December 2010. 
  78. ^ Wilson, Calvin (26 December 2010). "'Fair Game,' 'The Fighter' lead list of top movies". St. Louis Post-Dispatch. Lee Enterprises. Retrieved 26 December 2010. 
  79. ^ Neumaier, Joe (27 December 2010). "'Blue Valentine' is best movie of 2010, 'How Do You Know' is worst: Joe Neumaier". New York Daily News. Mortimer Zuckerman. Retrieved 27 December 2010. 
  80. ^ Rea, Steven (26 December 2010). "Steven Rea: The best films of 2010". The Philadelphia Inquirer. Philadelphia Media Network. Retrieved 26 December 2010. [dead link]
  81. ^ "2010 EDA Awards Nominees". Alliance of Women Film Journalists. Retrieved 23 December 2010. 
  82. ^ "THE MOËT BRITISH INDEPENDENT FILM AWARDS ANNOUNCE NOMINATIONS AND JURY FOR 13th EDITION". British Independent Film Awards. Archived from the original on 4 November 2010. Retrieved 1 November 2010. 
  83. ^ Adams, Ryan (3 January 2011). "Central Ohio Film Critics Association Awards Nominees". Awards Daily. Retrieved 8 May 2011. 
  84. ^ "Detroit Film Critics Society ANNOUNCES THE BEST OF 2010 NOMINATIONS!". Detroit Film Critics Society. Retrieved 10 December 2010. 
  85. ^ Montgomery, Steve (10 February 2011). "LONDON EVENING STANDARD Award Winners: NEDS, Andrew Garfield, Kristin Scott Thomas". ALT Film Guide. Retrieved 8 May 2011. 
  86. ^ "Garfield, Bonham Carter and Rockwell lead Hollywood Awards". Hollywood Film Festival. Retrieved 5 November 2010. 
  87. ^ "Nominees". Independent Spirit Awards. 30 November 2010. Retrieved 30 November 2010. 
  88. ^ "Indiana Film Journalists Awards 2010: Christopher Nolan, Natalie Portman, James Franco". ALT Film Guide. Retrieved 12 December 2010. 
  89. ^ "The Nominees for the 31st Film Awards". London Film Critics' Circle. 15 January 2011. Retrieved 8 May 2011. 
  90. ^ "CAREY MULLIGAN TO RECEIVE THE BREAKTHROUGH PERFORMANCE AWARD AT 22nd ANNUAL PALM SPRINGS INTERNATIONAL FILM FESTIVAL AWARDS GALA". Palm Springs International Film Festival. Retrieved 20 October 2010. 
  91. ^ "Phoenix Film Critics Name THE KINGS SPEECH Best Film of 2010". Phoenix Film Critics Society Awards. 18 December 2010. Retrieved 2 January 2011. 
  92. ^ "'Inception' tops Saturn Awards noms". Variety. Reed Elsevier Inc. 23 February 2011. Retrieved 23 February 2011. 
  93. ^ Lodderhose, Dianne (2 December 2010). "Women in Film and Television Awards honor Brits". Variety. Reed Elsevier Inc. Retrieved 3 December 2010. 

External links[edit]