Larry Silverstein

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article

Larry Silverstein
Born(1931-05-30) May 30, 1931 (age 82)
Brooklyn, New York City, New York, U.S.
NationalityAmerican
EthnicityJewish
Alma materNew York University (NYU)
OccupationOwner of Silverstein Properties
 
Jump to: navigation, search
Larry Silverstein
Born(1931-05-30) May 30, 1931 (age 82)
Brooklyn, New York City, New York, U.S.
NationalityAmerican
EthnicityJewish
Alma materNew York University (NYU)
OccupationOwner of Silverstein Properties

Larry A. Silverstein (born May 30, 1931) is an American businessman.[1]

Silverstein was born in Brooklyn, and became involved in real estate, together with his father, establishing Silverstein Properties. Silverstein separated from his business partner, Bernard Mendik, in 1977, and bought a number of large office buildings in Midtown and Lower Manhattan in the late 1970s. In 1980, Silverstein won a bid from the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey to construct 7 World Trade Center, to the north of the World Trade Center site. Silverstein was interested in acquiring the entire World Trade Center complex, and put in a bid when the Port Authority put it up for lease in 2000. Silverstein won the bid when a deal between the initial winner and the Port Authority fell through, and he signed the lease on July 24, 2001.

Soon after the September 11 attacks, Silverstein declared his intent to rebuild, though he and his insurers became embroiled in a multi-year dispute over whether the attacks had constituted one event or two under the terms of the insurance policy, which provided for a maximum of $3.55 billion coverage per event.[2] A settlement was reached in 2007, with insurers agreeing to pay out $4.55 billion,[3] which was not as much as Silverstein had sought. Silverstein also ran into multiple disputes with other parties in the rebuilding effort, including with the Port Authority. In an agreement reached in April 2006, Silverstein retained rights to build three office towers (150 Greenwich Street, 175 Greenwich Street, and 200 Greenwich Street), while One World Trade Center (previously referred to as the "Freedom Tower") would be owned by the Port Authority, as would Tower Five, which it would have the option of leasing to a different private developer and having redesigned as a residential building.[4]

Early life and education[edit]

Silverstein was born in Bedford-Stuyvesant, in Brooklyn in 1931 into a Jewish family.[5] Growing up, Silverstein enjoyed classical music and played the piano. He attended the High School of Music and Art in New York, and then New York University, graduating in 1952. During college, Silverstein worked at a summer camp, where he met his wife, Klara. The couple married in 1956, and had three children: Lisa, Roger and Sharon. His wife worked as a school teacher, supporting the family on her salary for the first few years of their marriage while Silverstein attended classes at Brooklyn Law School.[6]

Silverstein became involved in real estate, together with his father, Harry G. Silverstein, and then friend and brother-in-law, Bernard Mendik. In 1957, they established Silverstein Properties, as Harry G. Silverstein & Sons, and bought their first building, in Manhattan. Mendik and Silverstein continued the business after Harry's death in 1966. In 1977, Mendik divorced Annette Silverstein Mendik, with the business partnership also splitting up at that time.[7] Mendik also cited disagreements over real estate strategies, with Mendik wanting to buy buildings while Silverstein wanted to build.[8]

Career[edit]

After splitting with Mendik, both remained involved in the real-estate industry, but in separate firms. By 1978, Silverstein owned five buildings on Fifth Avenue, as well as 44 Wall Street, and a shopping center in Stamford, Connecticut. In 1980, he renovated the building at 11 West 42nd Street, and acquired the lease for the Equitable Building at 120 Broadway.[7] In 1983, Silverstein sold the building at 711 Fifth Avenue to Coca-Cola for $57.6 million (equals $136.4 million in 2013), having bought the building in 1977 for $11.5 million ($44.8 million in 2013).[9]

Also in 1980, Silverstein bought the building at 120 Wall Street, which was constructed in 1930.[10] In 1991, Silverstein set aside 20 floors of 120 Wall Street to be leased by non-profit organizations, as an Association Center, with tax incentives for the tenants and bonds for Silverstein to undertake building renovations.[11][12] By 1994, Silverstein had signed up 14 nonprofit tenants for 120 Wall Street,[13] and the building was nearly at capacity by 1997, with 38 nonprofit tenants including the National Urban League and the Illuminating Engineering Society of North America.[14]

In 1980, Larry Silverstein won a bid to lease and develop the last undeveloped parcel from the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey, to build the 47-story building 7 World Trade Center.

World Trade Center[edit]

During the 1990s, New York was suffering from the effects of the 1987 stock market crash, which led to high vacancy rates at the World Trade Center. George Pataki became Governor of New York in 1995 on a campaign of cutting costs, including privatizing the World Trade Center. A sale of the property was considered too complex, so it was decided by the Port Authority to open a 99-year lease to competitive bidding.[15]

In January 2001, Silverstein, via Silverstein Properties and Westfield America, made a $3.2 billion bid for the lease to the World Trade Center.[16] Silverstein was outbid by $30 million by Vornado Realty, with Boston Properties and Brookfield Properties also competing for the lease. However, Vornado withdrew and Silverstein's bid for the lease to the World Trade Center was accepted on July 24, 2001.[17] This was the first time in the building's 31-year history that the complex had changed management.

The lease agreement applied to One, Two, Four, and Five World Trade Center, and about 425,000 square feet (39,500 m2) of retail space. Silverstein put up $14 million of his own money to secure the deal.[18] The terms of the lease gave Silverstein, as leaseholder, the right and the obligation to rebuild the structures if destroyed.[19]

September 11 attacks[edit]

Silverstein has said on interviews that he usually spent his mornings in breakfast meetings at Windows on the World on top of the World Trade Center North Tower, and with new tenants in the building. However, the morning of September 11, 2001, his wife insisted that he attend a medical appointment with his dermatologist.[20]

All of the buildings at the World Trade Center, including buildings 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, and 7 were destroyed or damaged beyond repair on September 11, 2001. After a protracted dispute with insurers over the amount of coverage available for rebuilding World Trade Center buildings 1, 2, 4 and 5, a series of court decisions determined that a maximum of $4.55 billion was payable and settlements were reached with the insurers in 2007.[21]

Insurance dispute[edit]

The insurance policies for World Trade Center buildings 1 WTC, 2 WTC, 4 WTC and 5 WTC had a collective face amount of $3.55 billion. Following the September 11, 2001, attacks, Silverstein sought to collect double the face amount (~$7.1 billion) on the basis that the two separate airplane strikes into two separate buildings constituted two occurrences within the meaning of the policies. The insurance companies took the opposite view, and the matter went to court. Based on differences in the definition of "occurrence" (the insurance policy term governing the amount of insurance) and uncertainties over which definition of "occurrence" applied, the court split the insurers into two groups for jury trials on the question of which definition of "occurrence" applied and whether the insurance contracts were subject to the "one occurrence" interpretation or the "two occurrence" interpretation.

The first trial resulted in a verdict on April 29, 2004, that 10 of the insurers in this group were subject to the "one occurrence" interpretation, so their liability was limited to the face value of those policies, and 3 insurers were added to the second trial group.[22][23] The jury was unable to reach a verdict on one insurer, Swiss Reinsurance, at that time, but did so several days later on May 3, 2004, finding that this company was also subject to the "one occurrence" interpretation.[24] Silverstein appealed the Swiss Re decision, but lost that appeal on October 19, 2006.[25] The second trial resulted in a verdict on December 6, 2004, that 9 insurers were subject to the "two occurrences" interpretation and, therefore, liable for a maximum of double the face value of those particular policies ($2.2 billion).[26] The total potential payout, therefore, was capped at $4.577 billion for buildings 1, 2, 4, and 5.[27] An appraisal followed to determine the value of the insured loss.

In July 2006, Silverstein and the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey filed a lawsuit against some of its insurers, for refusing to waive requirements of the insurance contracts that Silverstein claimed were necessary to allow renegotiation of the original July 2001 World Trade Center leases. This litigation, was settled together with the federal lawsuits and appraisal, mentioned in the prior paragraph, in a series of settlements announced on May 23, 2007.[28][29][30][31] Silverstein's lease with the Port Authority, for the World Trade Center complex, requires him to continue paying $102 million annually in base rent.[32] He is applying insurance payments toward the redevelopment of the World Trade Center site.[27]

Rebuilding[edit]
New 7 World Trade Center (now 52 stories).

As leaseholder of buildings One, Two, Four and Five, Silverstein had the legal right to rebuild the buildings, including 1 World Trade Center at the World Trade Center site which would later be designated as building One, and while the site remains unoccupied, he continues to pay $10 million per month in rent to the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey.

After the September 11 attacks, the United States Congress approved $8 billion in tax-exempt Liberty Bonds to fund development in the private sector at lower-than-market interest rates. $3.4 billion remained unallocated in March 2006 designated for Lower Manhattan, with about half of the funds under the control of Mayor Michael Bloomberg and the other half under the control of former Governor George Pataki.

In April 2006, after several months of negotiation aimed toward permitting reconstruction to commence, Silverstein yielded some of his rights back to the Port Authority, in order to facilitate rebuilding at the site. Those negotiations resulted in Silverstein ceding his rights to building One (and its pro-rata share of the above-noted Liberty Bond funds) to the Port Authority, and allocating a portion of the insurance proceeds to the rebuilding of building One in favor of the Port Authority. In return, the remaining pro-rata shares of the Liberty Bond funds were allocated to Silverstein Properties for purposes of rebuilding the remaining buildings, and government agencies are expected to be among the tenants in those buildings.

Ground was broken on the construction of 1 World Trade Center on April 27, 2006.[33] Lack of financing had prevented construction from commencing earlier. The proceeds of the insurance policies arising from the destruction of the previous buildings were insufficient to cover the cost of rebuilding all the insured buildings.

In March 2007 Silverstein appeared at a rally of construction workers and public officials outside of an insurance industry conference to highlight what he describes as the failures of insurers Allianz & Royal and Sun Alliance to pay $800 million in claims related to the attacks. Insurers cite an agreement to split payments between Mr. Silverstein and the Port Authority as a cause for concern.[34]

Other projects[edit]

While Silverstein is most famous for his involvement at the World Trade Center, his real estate holdings include many other buildings in New York City, including 1177 Avenue of the Americas, 529 Fifth Avenue, and 570 Seventh Avenue.[35]

Among his residential projects is an extensive complex that takes up the entire block between 42nd and 41st Street and between 11th and 12th Avenues in the Hell's Kitchen, Manhattan neighborhood. Projects on the block include 39 One River Place which opened in 2001. In May 2009 the twin-towered Silver Towers opened. At 60 stories it is the tallest rental building in New York.[36]

Other properties include 30 Park Place.[37] Silverstein was also involved as a developer of the Ronald Reagan Building in Washington, D.C..[38]

In November 2006, Silverstein agreed to buy the building at 99 Church Street from Moody's for $170 million.[39] Moody's moved its headquarters into 7 World Trade Center in 2007. 99 Church Street was promptly razed to make way for Silverstein's new project on the site. The 2008 plan proposed a 68 story, 912 foot tower, composed of condominiums and a Four Seasons Hotel on the lower 22 stories.[40] However, due to lack of financing, the project is not currently progressing past the foundation.[41]

In 1989 Silverstein proposed to members of the Israeli government that a free trade zone should be created within the Negev region of Israel. The project ultimately failed, however it enjoyed popular support amongst leading Israeli political figures.[9]

Philanthropy[edit]

Silverstein has been involved in his alma mater, as founder and chairman emeritus of New York University's Real Estate Institute, and as a trustee of the New York University Medical Center and Health System. Silverstein also has served as chairman of the United Jewish Appeal in New York, the Realty Foundation, trustee of the Museum of Jewish Heritage, and treasurer of the National Jewish Medical and Research Center in Denver. Silverstein is also a governor of The Real Estate Board of New York.[42]

References[edit]

  1. ^ "Larry A. Silverstein". Bloomberg Businessweek. Retrieved April 23, 2013. 
  2. ^ http://www.forbes.com/2003/07/23/cx_da_0723topnews.html
  3. ^ Brown, Eliot (2009-03-10). "Refi in FiHi! Silverstein, Port Talk WTC Dates, Funds". The New York Observer. Retrieved 2009-03-11
  4. ^ Gelinas, Nicole (Autumn 2006). "Freeing us from Freedom Tower". City Journal. 
  5. ^ Schuerman, Matthew (2005-12-18). "Larry Silverstein". New York Observer. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  6. ^ "One On 1: Developer Larry Silverstein". NY1. 2006-07-31. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  7. ^ a b "Silverstein Properties, Inc. - Company History". Fundinguniverse.com. 
  8. ^ Salmans, Sandra (1985-01-28). "Putting Together City's Biggest Apartment Deal". New York Times. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  9. ^ a b Leibovich-Dar, Sara. "Up In Smoke". Haaretz. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  10. ^ "Silverstein Buys 120 Wall St.". The New York Times. 1980-09-28. 
  11. ^ Dunlap, David W. (1991-10-27). "Commercial Property: Nonprofit Tenants; Wall Street Tower as a Site for a Service Association". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  12. ^ "120 Wall Gets Profitable; Tenants Exiting". New York Observer. 2007-03-20. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  13. ^ Dunlap, David W. (1994-08-07). "Shift by Nonprofits Leaves Space Behind". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  14. ^ Rothstein, Mervyn (1997-09-03). "Nonprofits' Wall St. Home Filling Up". The New York Times. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  15. ^ Goldberger, Paul (2004). Up From Ground Zero. New York: Random House. p. 28. ISBN 1-4000-6017-6. 
  16. ^ "Silverstein Group Seals $3.2 Billion Deal For New York's World Trade Center". Wall Street Journal. April 26, 2001.
  17. ^ "Governor Pataki, Acting Governor Difrancesco Laud Historic Port Authority Agreement To Privatize World Trade Center" (Press release). Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. 2001-07-24. 
  18. ^ Frankel, Alison (2002-09-03). "Double Indemnity: Was the WTC disaster one incident or two?". The American Lawyer. 
  19. ^ Goldberger, Paul (2002-05-20). Groundwork: How the future of Ground Zero is being resolved. The New York York. [dead link]
  20. ^ "Larry Silverstein: Silverstein Properties". New York Observer. Retrieved April 2, 2013. 
  21. ^ Litigation Settled, Bloomberg, May 23, 2007
  22. ^ Hamblett, Mark (2004-04-30). "Jurors Deal World Trade Center Leaseholder Major Setback". New York Law Journal / Law.com. 
  23. ^ Starkman, Dean (2004-04-30). "Jury's Decision Leaves Rebuilding of World Trade Center in Turmoil". Wall Street Journal. p. A1. 
  24. ^ Parekh, Rupal (2006-10-18). "Appeals court rules for Swiss Re in WTC dispute". Business Insurance. 
  25. ^ Hamblett, Mark (2006-10-19). "Circuit Resolves Distribution Of 9/11 Insurance Proceeds". New York Law Journal. 
  26. ^ Starkman, Dean (2004-12-07). "Jury Rules for Silverstein on Trade Center Insurance". Wall Street Journal. p. A11. 
  27. ^ a b Murray, Barbra (March 2007). "WTC Developer to Get Additional $12.5M Payment from Insurer TIG". Commercial Property News. 
  28. ^ Levitt, David M. (2007-05-23). "Litigation Settled". Bloomberg. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  29. ^ Westfeldt, Amy (2007-05-23). "$2B Settlement Ends Trade Center Litigation". USA Today / Associated Press. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  30. ^ "Circuit Resolves Distribution Of 9/11 Insurance Proceeds". The New York Law Journal. 2006-10-19. 
  31. ^ Jenkins, Jr., Holman (2002-03-06). "The Importance of Being Larry". Wall Street Journal. p. A17. 
  32. ^ "2001 Annual Report" (PDF). PANY. April 23, 2002. 
  33. ^ Westfeldt, Amy (2006-04-28). "Construction Begins at Ground Zero". Washington Post / Associated Press. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  34. ^ "Silverstein Lashes Out Against WTC Insurers". New York Sun. 2007-03-13. 
  35. ^ "Portfolio". Silverstein Properties. Retrieved May 21, 2013.
  36. ^ Silverstein Properties launches Manhattan's tallest rental - New York Daily News - May 1, 2009
  37. ^ "Properties". Silverstein Properties. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 
  38. ^ Moore, Elizabeth (2006-10-10). "Silverstein's shopping on Long Island". Newsday (New York). 
  39. ^ Hess, Diane (November 21, 2006). "Moody's to sell headquarters to Silverstein". New York Business. 
  40. ^ "Silverstein Partners with Four Seasons for New Downtown Development", World Trade Center - wtc.com, Silverstein Properties, Inc., January 29, 2008
  41. ^ Cuozzo, Steve, "‘Silver’ Lining for 99 Church Street", World Trade Center - wtc.com, Silverstein Properties, Inc., March 31, 2009 (from the New York Post)
  42. ^ "Speakers - Larry Silverstein". Global Conference 2007. Retrieved 2008-11-11. 

External links[edit]