Hydrogen vehicle

From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article

Jump to: navigation, search
Honda FCX Clarity, a hydrogen fuel cell demonstration vehicle introduced in 2008

A hydrogen vehicle is a vehicle that uses hydrogen as its onboard fuel for motive power. Hydrogen vehicles include hydrogen fueled space rockets, as well as automobiles and other transportation vehicles. The power plants of such vehicles convert the chemical energy of hydrogen to mechanical energy either by burning hydrogen in an internal combustion engine, or by reacting hydrogen with oxygen in a fuel cell to run electric motors. Widespread use of hydrogen for fueling transportation is a key element of a proposed hydrogen economy.[1]

Hydrogen fuel does not occur naturally on Earth and thus is not an energy source; rather it is an energy carrier. It is most frequently made from methane or other fossil fuels, but it can be produced using sources (such as wind, solar, or nuclear) that are intermittent, too diffuse or too cumbersome to directly propel vehicles. Integrated wind-to-hydrogen (power to gas) plants, using electrolysis of water, are exploring technologies to deliver costs low enough, and quantities great enough, to compete with traditional energy sources.[2]

Many companies are working to develop technologies that might efficiently exploit the potential of hydrogen energy for use in motor vehicles. As of November 2013 there are demonstration fleets of hydrogen fuel cell vehicles undergoing field testing including the Chevrolet Equinox Fuel Cell, Honda FCX Clarity, Hyundai ix35 Fuel Cell and Mercedes-Benz B-Class F-Cell.[3] The attraction of using hydrogen as an energy currency is that, if hydrogen is prepared without using fossil fuel inputs, vehicle propulsion would not contribute to carbon dioxide emissions. The drawbacks of hydrogen use are high capital cost, low energy content per unit volume, production and compression of hydrogen, and the large investment in infrastructure that would be required to fuel vehicles.[3][4]


Buses, trains, PHB bicycles, canal boats, cargo bikes, golf carts, motorcycles, wheelchairs, ships, airplanes, submarines, and rockets can already run on hydrogen, in various forms. NASA used hydrogen to launch Space Shuttles into space. A working toy model car runs on solar power, using a regenerative fuel cell to store energy in the form of hydrogen and oxygen gas. It can then convert the fuel back into water to release the solar energy.[5]

The current land speed record for a hydrogen-powered vehicle is 286.476 mph (461.038 km/h) set by Ohio State University's Buckeye Bullet 2, which achieved a "flying-mile" speed of 280.007 mph (450.628 km/h) at the Bonneville Salt Flats in August 2008. For production-style vehicles, the current record for a hydrogen-powered vehicle is 333.38 km/h (207.2 mph) set by a prototype Ford Fusion Hydrogen 999 Fuel Cell Race Car at Bonneville Salt Flats in Wendover, Utah in August 2007. It was accompanied by a large compressed oxygen tank to increase power.[6]


Many automobile companies are currently researching the feasibility of commercially producing hydrogen cars, and some have introduced demonstration models in limited numbers (see list of fuel cell vehicles).[7] At the 2012 World Hydrogen Energy Conference, Daimler AG, Honda, Hyundai and Toyota all confirmed plans to produce hydrogen fuel cell vehicles for sale by 2015.[8] General Motors said it had not abandoned fuel-cell technology and still plans to introduce hydrogen vehicles like the GM HydroGen4 to retail customers by 2015. Charles Freese, GM’s executive director of global powertrain engineering, stated that the company believes that both fuel-cell vehicles and battery electric vehicles are needed for reduction of greenhouse gases and reliance on oil.[9]

The Toyota FCV concept, unveiled at the 2013 Tokyo Motor Show, is a practical concept of the fuel cell vehicle Toyota plans to launch around 2015.[10]

In December 2012 Toyota announced its plans to limit its all-electric car development and instead concentrate on the development and launch of a fuel cell vehicle by 2015.[11] In October 2013 Toyota announced it had reduced the cost of the fuel cell system in its next hydrogen-powered car by almost US$1 million and expects to introduce a hydrogen mid-size sedan at a price of less than US$100,000 by 2015.[12] The practical concept of the fuel cell vehicle Toyota plans to launch around 2015, the Toyota FCV concept, was unveiled at the November 2013 Tokyo Motor Show. The fuel cell car will have a range of just over 300 mi (480 km), and it will take about three minutes to refill its twin hydrogen tanks. California, mainly the Los Angeles area, was chosen as the first roll-out market due to its largest concentration of hydrogen fuel stations.[10]

The Chevrolet Sequel is a purpose-built hydrogen fuel cell-powered concept SUV vehicle developed by General Motors

In 2009, Nissan started testing a new FC vehicle in Japan.[13] Daimler has introduced its B-class demonstration FC vehicle.[8] In 2011, Hyundai introduced its Blue2 ("Blue Square") fuel cell electric vehicle (FCEV), and stated that it plans to have FCEVs available for sale by 2014.[14] Honda stated in 2009 that it could start mass-producing vehicles based on its FCX Clarity concept car by the year 2020[15] and in 2009 stated that it saw hydrogen fuel cells as "a better long term bet than batteries and plug-in vehicles".[16] In December 2010, however, it introduced the Honda Fit EV, an all-electric car version of the gasoline-powered Fit, using elements of its hydrogen engine design, stating that the "industry trend seems to be focused on the battery electric vehicle".[17]

In 2012, Lux Research, Inc. issued a report that stated: "The dream of a hydrogen economy ... is no nearer." It concluded that "Capital cost, not hydrogen supply, will limit adoption to a mere 5.9 GW" by 2030, providing "a nearly insurmountable barrier to adoption, except in niche applications". Lux's analysis concluded that by 2030, the PEM stationary market will reach $1 billion, while the vehicle market, including forklifts, will reach a total of $2 billion.[18]


Fuel cell buses (as opposed to hydrogen fueled buses) are being trialed by several manufacturers in different locations. The Fuel Cell Bus Club is a global fuel cell bus testing collaboration.

Hydrogen was first stored in roof mounted tanks, although models are now incorporating onboard tanks. Some double deck models use between floor tanks.


Pearl Hydrogen Power Sources of Shanghai, China, unveiled a hydrogen bicycle at the 9th China International Exhibition on Gas Technology, Equipment and Applications in 2007.

Motorcycles and scooters[edit]

ENV develops electric motorcycles powered by a hydrogen fuel cell, including the Crosscage and Biplane. Other manufacturers as Vectrix are working on hydrogen scooters.[19] Finally, hydrogen fuel cell-electric hybrid scooters are being made such as the Suzuki Burgman Fuel cell scooter.[20] and the FHybrid.[21] The Burgman received "whole vehicle type" approval in the EU.[22] The Taiwanese company APFCT conducted a live street test with 80 fuel cell scooters for Taiwans Bureau of Energy.[23]

Quads and tractors[edit]

Autostudi S.r.l's H-Due[24] is a hydrogen-powered quad, capable of transporting 1-3 passengers. A concept for a hydrogen powered tractor has been proposed.[25]


The Boeing Fuel Cell Demonstrator powered by a hydrogen fuel cell

Companies such as Boeing, Lange Aviation, and the German Aerospace Center pursue hydrogen as fuel for manned and unmanned airplanes. In February 2008 Boeing tested a manned flight of a small aircraft powered by a hydrogen fuel cell. Unmanned hydrogen planes have also been tested.[26] For large passenger airplanes however, The Times reported that "Boeing said that hydrogen fuel cells were unlikely to power the engines of large passenger jet airplanes but could be used as backup or auxiliary power units onboard."[27]

In July 2010 Boeing unveiled its hydrogen powered Phantom Eye UAV, powered by two Ford internal combustion engines that have been converted to run on hydrogen.[28]

In Britain, the Reaction Engines A2 has been proposed to use the thermodynamic properties of liquid hydrogen to achieve very high speed, long distance (antipodal) flight by burning it in a precooled jet engine.

Fork trucks[edit]

A HICE forklift or HICE lift truck is a hydrogen fueled, internal combustion engine-powered industrial forklift truck used for lifting and transporting materials. The first production HICE forklift truck based on the Linde X39 Diesel was presented at an exposition in Hannover on May 27, 2008. It used a 2.0 litre, 43 kW diesel internal combustion engine converted to use hydrogen as a fuel with the use of a compressor and direct injection.[29][30]

A fuel cell forklift (also called a fuel cell lift truck or a fuel cell forklift) is a fuel cell powered industrial forklift truck. In 2013 there were over 4,000 fuel cell forklifts used in material handling in the US.[31] Only 500 of these received funding from DOE in 2012.[32][33] As of 2013, fuel cell fleets are being operated by several number of companies, including Sysco Foods, FedEx Freight, GENCO (at Wegmans, Coca-Cola, Kimberly Clark, and Whole Foods), and H-E-B Grocers.[34] A total of 30 fuel cell forklifts with Hylift were demonstrated in Europe and extended it with HyLIFT-EUROPE to 200 units.[35] With other projects in France[36][37] and Austria.[38] Pike Research stated in 2011 that fuel-cell-powered forklifts will be the largest driver of hydrogen fuel demand by 2020.[39]

PEM fuel-cell-powered forklifts provide significant benefits over both petroleum forklifts as they produce no local emissions, and as compared with electric vehicles, the forklifts can work for a full 8-hour shift on a single tank of hydrogen, can be refueled in 3 minutes and have a lifetime of 8–10 years. Fuel-cell-powered forklifts are often used in refrigerated warehouses as their performance is not degraded by lower temperatures.[40] Most fuel cells used for material handling purposes are powered by PEM fuel cells, although some DMFC forklifts are coming onto the market. In design the FC units are often made as drop-in replacements.[41][42]


Many large rockets use liquid hydrogen as fuel, with liquid oxygen as an oxidizer. The main advantage of hydrogen rocket fuel is the high effective exhaust velocity compared to kerosene/LOX or UDMH/NTO engines. According to the Tsiolkovsky rocket equation, a rocket with higher exhaust velocity needs less propellant mass to achieve a given change of speed. Before combustion, the hydrogen runs through cooling pipes around the exhaust nozzle to protect the nozzle from damage by the hot exhaust gases.[43]

The disadvantages of LH2/LOX engines are the low density and low temperature of liquid hydrogen, which means bigger and insulated and thus heavier fuel tanks are needed. This increases the rocket's structural mass and decreases its efficiency somewhat. Another disadvantage is the poor storability of LH2/LOX-powered rockets: Due to the constant hydrogen boil-off, the rocket can only be fueled shortly before launch, which makes cryogenic engines unsuitable for ICBMs and other rocket applications with the need for short launch preparations.

Liquid hydrogen and oxygen were also used in the Space Shuttle to run the fuel cells that power the electrical systems.[44] The byproduct of the fuel cell is water, which is used for drinking and other applications that require water in space.

Internal combustion vehicle[edit]

Hydrogen internal combustion engine cars are different from hydrogen fuel cell cars. The hydrogen internal combustion car is a slightly modified version of the traditional gasoline internal combustion engine car. These hydrogen engines burn fuel in the same manner that gasoline engines do.

Francois Isaac de Rivaz designed in 1807 the first hydrogen-fueled internal combustion engine.[45] Paul Dieges patented in 1970 a modification to internal combustion engines which allowed a gasoline-powered engine to run on hydrogen US 3844262 .

Mazda has developed Wankel engines burning hydrogen. The advantage of using ICE (internal combustion engine) like Wankel and piston engines is the cost of retooling for production is much lower. Existing-technology ICE can still be applied for solving those problems where fuel cells are not a viable solution insofar, for example in cold-weather applications.

HICE forklift trucks have been demonstrated[46] based on converted diesel internal combustion engines with direct injection.[30]

Fuel cell[edit]

Fuel cell cost[edit]

Hydrogen fuel cells are relatively expensive to produce. As of October 2009, Fortune magazine estimated the cost of producing the Honda Clarity at $300,000 per car.[47] Many designs require rare substances such as platinum as a catalyst.[48] In 2010, a new nickel-tin nanometal catalyst was tested to lower the cost of fuel cells.[49]

The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) estimated in 2002 that the cost of a fuel cell for an automobile (assuming high-volume manufacturing) was approximately $275/kW, which translated into each vehicle costing more than 1 million dollars[citation needed]. However, by 2010, DOE estimated the cost had fallen 80% and that automobile fuel cells might be manufactured for $51/kW, assuming high-volume manufacturing cost savings.[50] The projected cost, assuming a manufacturing volume of 500,000 units/year, using 2012 technology, was estimated by the DOE to be $47/kW for an 80 kW PEM fuel cell. Assuming a manufacturing volume of 10,000 units/year, however, the cost was projected to be $84/kW using 2012 technlogy.[51]

Freezing conditions[edit]

Temperatures below freezing are a concern with fuel cells operations. Operational fuel cells have an internal vaporous water environment that could solidify if the fuel cell and contents are not kept above 0° Celsius (32°F). Most fuel cell designs are not as yet robust enough to survive in below-freezing environments. Frozen solid, especially before start up, they would not be able to begin working. Once running though, heat is a byproduct of the fuel cell process, which would keep the fuel cell at an adequate operational temperature to function correctly. This makes startup of the fuel cell a concern in cold weather operation. Places such as Alaska where temperatures can reach −40 °C (−40 °F) at startup would not be able to use early model fuel cells. Ballard announced in 2006 that it had hit the U.S. DoE's 2010 target for cold weather starting which was 50% power achieved in 30 seconds at -20 °C.[52] Fuel cells have startup and long term reliability problems.[53]

Service life[edit]

The service life of fuel cells is comparable to that of other vehicles.[54] PEM service life is 7,300 hours under cycling conditions.[55] Research is ongoing to extend service life further.


Hydrogen does not come as a pre-existing source of energy like fossil fuels, but is first produced and then stored as a carrier, much like a battery. A suggested benefit of large-scale deployment of hydrogen vehicles is that it could lead to decreased emissions of greenhouse gases and ozone precursors.[56]

According to the United States Department of Energy, "compared to ICE vehicles using gasoline ... fuel cell vehicles using hydrogen produced from natural gas reduce greenhouse gas emissions by 60%."[57] While methods of hydrogen production that do not use fossil fuel would be more sustainable,[58] currently renewable energy represents only a small percentage of energy generated, and power produced from renewable sources can be used in electric vehicles and for non-vehicle applications.[59]

The challenges facing the use of hydrogen in vehicles include production, storage, transport and distribution. Because of all these challenges, the well-to-wheel efficiency for hydrogen is less than 25%.[60][61][62]


The molecular hydrogen needed as an on-board fuel for hydrogen vehicles can be obtained through many thermochemical methods utilizing natural gas, coal (by a process known as coal gasification), liquefied petroleum gas, biomass (biomass gasification), by a process called thermolysis, or as a microbial waste product called biohydrogen or Biological hydrogen production. 95% of hydrogen is produced using natural gas,[63] and 85% of hydrogen produced is used to remove sulfur from gasoline. Hydrogen can also be produced from water by electrolysis or by chemical reduction using chemical hydrides or aluminum.[64] Current technologies for manufacturing hydrogen use energy in various forms, totaling between 25 and 50 percent of the higher heating value of the hydrogen fuel, used to produce, compress or liquefy, and transmit the hydrogen by pipeline or truck.[65]

Environmental consequences of the production of hydrogen from fossil energy resources include the emission of greenhouse gases, a consequence that would also result from the on-board reforming of methanol into hydrogen.[60] Studies comparing the environmental consequences of hydrogen production and use in fuel-cell vehicles to the refining of petroleum and combustion in conventional automobile engines find a net reduction of ozone and greenhouse gases in favor of hydrogen.[56] Hydrogen production using renewable energy resources would not create such emissions or, in the case of biomass, would create near-zero net emissions assuming new biomass is grown in place of that converted to hydrogen. However the same land could be used to create Biodiesel, usable with (at most) minor alterations to existing well developed and relatively efficient diesel engines. In either case, the scale of renewable energy production today is small and would need to be greatly expanded to be used in producing hydrogen for a significant part of transportation needs.[66] As of December 2008, less than 3 percent of U.S. electricity was produced from renewable sources, not including dams.[67] In a few countries, renewable sources are being used more widely to produce energy and hydrogen. For example, Iceland is using geothermal power to produce hydrogen,[68] and Denmark is using wind.[69]


Compressed hydrogen storage mark

Hydrogen has a very low volumetric energy density at ambient conditions, equal to about one-third that of methane. Even when the fuel is stored as liquid hydrogen in a cryogenic tank or in a compressed hydrogen storage tank, the volumetric energy density (megajoules per liter) is small relative to that of gasoline.[48] Hydrogen has a three times higher specific energy by mass compared to gasoline (143 MJ/kg versus 46.9 MJ/kg). Some research has been done into using special crystalline materials to store hydrogen at greater densities and at lower pressures. A recent study by Dutch researcher Robin Gremaud has shown that metal hydride hydrogen tanks are actually 40 to 60-percent lighter than an equivalent energy battery pack on an electric vehicle permitting greater range for H2 cars.[70] In 2011, scientists at Los Alamos National Laboratory and University of Alabama, working with the U.S. Department of Energy, found a new single-stage method for recharging ammonia borane, a hydrogen storage compound.[71][72]


Hydrogen car fueling
Hydrogen fueling

The hydrogen infrastructure consists mainly of industrial hydrogen pipeline transport and hydrogen-equipped filling stations like those found on a hydrogen highway. Hydrogen stations which are not situated near a hydrogen pipeline can obtain supply via hydrogen tanks, compressed hydrogen tube trailers, liquid hydrogen tank trucks or dedicated onsite production.

Hydrogen use would require the alteration of industry and transport on a scale never seen before in history. For example, according to GM, 70% of the U.S. population lives near a hydrogen-generating facility but has little access to hydrogen, despite its wide availability for commercial use.[73] The distribution of hydrogen fuel for vehicles throughout the U.S. would require new hydrogen stations that would cost, by some estimates approximately 20 billion dollars[74] and 4.6 billion in the EU.[75] Other estimates place the cost as high as half trillion dollars in the United States alone.[76]

The California Hydrogen Highway is an initiative to build a series of hydrogen refueling stations along California state highways. As of June 2012, 23 stations were in operation,[77] mostly in and around Los Angeles, with a few in the Bay area.[78][79] South Carolina also has a hydrogen freeway project, and the first two hydrogen fueling stations opened in 2009 in Aiken and Columbia, South Carolina. The University of South Carolina, a founding member of the South Carolina Hydrogen & Fuel Cell Alliance, received 12.5 million dollars from the Department of Energy for its Future Fuels Program.[80]

Codes and standards[edit]

Hydrogen codes and standards, as well as codes and technical standards for hydrogen safety and the storage of hydrogen, have been identified as an institutional barrier to deploying hydrogen technologies and developing a hydrogen economy. To enable the commercialization of hydrogen in consumer products, new codes and standards must be developed and adopted by federal, state and local governments.[81]

Official support[edit]

In January 2003, George W. Bush announced an initiative to promote hydrogen powered vehicles.[82]


Critics claim the time frame for overcoming the technical and economic challenges to implementing wide-scale use of hydrogen cars is likely to last for at least several decades, and hydrogen vehicles may never become broadly available.[59][83] They claim that the focus on the use of the hydrogen car is a dangerous detour from more readily available solutions to reducing the use of fossil fuels in vehicles.[84] In May 2008, Wired News reported that "experts say it will be 40 years or more before hydrogen has any meaningful impact on gasoline consumption or global warming, and we can't afford to wait that long. In the meantime, fuel cells are diverting resources from more immediate solutions."[85]

K. G. Duleep commented that "a strong case exists for continuing fuel-efficiency improvements from conventional technology at relatively low cost."[86] Critiques of hydrogen vehicles are presented in the 2006 documentary, Who Killed the Electric Car?. According to former U.S. Department of Energy official Joseph Romm, "A hydrogen car is one of the least efficient, most expensive ways to reduce greenhouse gases." Asked when hydrogen cars will be broadly available, Romm replied: "Not in our lifetime, and very possibly never."[86] The Los Angeles Times wrote, in February 2009, "Hydrogen fuel-cell technology won't work in cars. ... Any way you look at it, hydrogen is a lousy way to move cars."[87]

The Wall Street Journal reported in 2008 that "Top executives from General Motors Corp. and Toyota Motor Corp. Tuesday expressed doubts about the viability of hydrogen fuel cells for mass-market production in the near term and suggested their companies are now betting that electric cars will prove to be a better way to reduce fuel consumption and cut tailpipe emissions on a large scale."[88] The Economist magazine, in September 2008, quoted Robert Zubrin, the author of Energy Victory, as saying: "Hydrogen is 'just about the worst possible vehicle fuel'".[89] The magazine noted the withdrawal of California from earlier goals: "In March [2008] the California Air Resources Board, an agency of California's state government and a bellwether for state governments across America, changed its requirement for the number of zero-emission vehicles (ZEVs) to be built and sold in California between 2012 and 2014. The revised mandate allows manufacturers to comply with the rules by building more battery-electric cars instead of fuel-cell vehicles."[89] The magazine also noted that most hydrogen is produced through steam reformation, which creates at least as much emission of carbon per mile as some of today's gasoline cars. On the other hand, if the hydrogen could be produced using renewable energy, "it would surely be easier simply to use this energy to charge the batteries of all-electric or plug-in hybrid vehicles."[89]

The Washington Post asked in November 2009, "But why would you want to store energy in the form of hydrogen and then use that hydrogen to produce electricity for a motor, when electrical energy is already waiting to be sucked out of sockets all over America and stored in auto batteries"?.[63] A December 2009 study at UC Davis, published in the Journal of Power Sources, found that, over their lifetimes, hydrogen vehicles will emit more carbon than gasoline vehicles.[90] The Motley Fool stated in 2013 that "there are still cost-prohibitive obstacles [for hydrogen cars] relating to transportation, storage, and, most importantly, production."[91]

Volkswagen's Rudolf Krebs said in 2013 that "no matter how excellent you make the cars themselves, the laws of physics hinder their overall efficiency. The most efficient way to convert energy to mobility is electricity." He elaborated: "Hydrogen mobility only makes sense if you use green energy", but ... you need to convert it first into hydrogen "with low efficiencies" where "you lose about 40 percent of the initial energy". You then must compress the hydrogen and store it under high pressure in tanks, which uses more energy. "And then you have to convert the hydrogen back to electricity in a fuel cell with another efficiency loss". Krebs continued: "in the end, from your original 100 percent of electric energy, you end up with 30 to 40 percent."[92] In 2013, Volkswagen signed a $60 million to $100 million engineering services deal with Ballard for the development of fuel cells to move ahead faster with new power transportation technologies.[93] The Business Insider commented:

Pure hydrogen can be industrially derived, but it takes energy. If that energy does not come from renewable sources, then fuel-cell cars are not as clean as they seem. ... Another challenge is the lack of infrastructure. Gas stations need to invest in the ability to refuel hydrogen tanks before FCEVs become practical, and it's unlikely many will do that while there are so few customers on the road today. ... Compounding the lack of infrastructure is the high cost of the technology. Fuel cells are "still very, very expensive".[94]

Comparison with other types of alternative fuel vehicle[edit]

Hydrogen motor vehicles are one of a number of proposed alternatives to the modern fossil fuel powered vehicle infrastructure.[48]

Plug-in hybrids[edit]

Plug-in hybrid electric vehicles, or PHEVs, are hybrid vehicles that can be plugged into the electric grid and contain an electric motor and also an internal combustion engine. The PHEV concept augments standard hybrid electric vehicles with the ability to recharge their batteries from an external source, enabling increased use of the vehicle's electric motors while reducing their reliance on internal combustion engines. The infrastructure required to charge PHEVs is already in place,[95] and transmission of power from grid to car is about 93% efficient.[96] This, however, is not the only energy loss in transferring power from grid to wheels. AC/DC conversion must take place from the grids AC supply to the PHEV's DC. This is roughly 98% efficient.[97] The battery then must be charged. As of 2007, the Lithium iron phosphate battery was between 80-90% efficient in charging/discharging.[98] The battery needs to be cooled; the GM Volt's battery has 4 coolers and two radiators.[99] As of 2009, "the total well-to-wheels efficiency with which a hydrogen fuel cell vehicle might utilize renewable electricity is roughly 20% (although that number could rise to 25% or a little higher with the kind of multiple technology breakthroughs required to enable a hydrogen economy). The well-to-wheels efficiency of charging an onboard battery and then discharging it to run an electric motor in a PHEV or EV, however, is 80% (and could be higher in the future)—four times more efficient than current hydrogen fuel cell vehicle pathways."[62] A 2006 article in Scientific American argued that PHEVs, rather than hydrogen vehicles, would become standard in the automobile industry.[100][101] A December 2009 study at UC Davis found that, over their lifetimes, PHEVs will emit less carbon than current vehicles, while hydrogen cars will emit more carbon than gasoline vehicles.[90]

Natural gas[edit]

ICE-based CNG, HCNG or LNG vehicles (Natural gas vehicles or NGVs) use methane (Natural gas or Biogas) directly as a fuel source. Natural gas has a higher energy density than hydrogen gas. NGVs using biogas are nearly carbon neutral.[102] Unlike hydrogen vehicles, CNG vehicles have been available for many years, and there is sufficient infrastructure to provide both commercial and home refueling stations. Worldwide, there were 14.8 million natural gas vehicles by the end of 2011.[103]

All-electric vehicles[edit]

A 2008 Technology Review article stated, "Electric cars—and plug-in hybrid cars—have an enormous advantage over hydrogen fuel-cell vehicles in utilizing low-carbon electricity. That is because of the inherent inefficiency of the entire hydrogen fueling process, from generating the hydrogen with that electricity to transporting this diffuse gas long distances, getting the hydrogen in the car, and then running it through a fuel cell—all for the purpose of converting the hydrogen back into electricity to drive the same exact electric motor you'll find in an electric car."[104] Thermodynamically, each additional step in the conversion process decreases the overall efficiency of the process.[105][106]

A 2013 comparison of hydrogen and battery electric vehicles agreed with the 25% figure from Ulf Bossel in 2006 and stated that the cost of an electric vehicle battery "is rapidly coming down, and the gap will widen further", while there is little "existing infrastructure to transport, store and deliver hydrogen to vehicles and would cost billions of dollars to put into place, everyone's household power sockets are "electric vehicle refueling" station and the "cost of electricity (depending on the source) is at least 75% cheaper than hydrogen."[107] In 2013 the National Academy of Sciences[108] and DOE stated that even under optimistic conditions by 2030 the price for the battery is not expected to go below $17,000 ($200–$250/kWh) on 300 miles of range.[109] In 2013 Matthew Mench, from the University of Tennessee stated ""If we are sitting around waiting for a battery breakthrough that will give us four times the range than we have now, we are going to be waiting for a long time".[110] Navigant Research, (formerly Pike research), on the other hand, forecasts that “lithium-ion costs, which are tipping the scales at about $500 per kilowatt hour now, could fall to $300 by 2015 and to $180 by 2020.”[111] In 2013 Takeshi Uchiyamada, a designer of the Toyota Prius stated: "Because of its shortcomings – driving range, cost and recharging time – the electric vehicle is not a viable replacement for most conventional cars".[112]

Many electric car designs offer limited driving range causing range anxiety. For example, the 2013 Nissan Leaf has a range of 75 mi (121 km),[113] the 2014 Mercedes-Benz B-Class Electric Drive has an estimated range of 115 mi (185 km)[114] and the Tesla Model S has a range of up to 265 mi (426 km).[115] However, most commutes are 30–40 miles (48–64 km) miles per day round trip.[citation needed]

In 2013, The New York Times stated that there are only 10 publicly accessible hydrogen filling stations in the U.S., eight of which are in Southern California, and that BEVs' cost-per-mile expense in 2013 is one-third as much as hydrogen cars, when comparing electricity from the grid and hydrogen at a filling station. The Times commented: "By the time Toyota sells its first fuel-cell sedan, there will be about a half-million plug-in vehicles on the road in the United States – and tens of thousands of E.V. charging stations."[3] In 2013 John Swanton of the California Air Resources Board, who sees them as complementary technologies, stated that EVs have the jump on fuel-cell autos, which "are like electric vehicles were 10 years ago. EVs are for real consumers, no strings attached. With EVs you have a lot of infrastructure in place.[116] The Business Insider, in 2013 commented that if the energy to produce hydrogen "does not come from renewable sources, then fuel-cell cars are not as clean as they seem. ... Gas stations need to invest in the ability to refuel hydrogen tanks before FCEVs become practical, and it's unlikely many will do that while there are so few customers on the road today. ... Compounding the lack of infrastructure is the high cost of the technology. Fuel cells are "still very, very expensive", even compared to battery-powered EVs.[94]

See also[edit]


  1. ^ A portfolio of power-trains for Europe: a fact-based analysis
  2. ^ "Wind-to-Hydrogen Project". Hydrogen and Fuel Cells Research. Golden, CO: National Renewable Energy Laboratory, U.S. Department of Energy. September 2009. Retrieved 7 January 2010. 
  3. ^ a b c Berman, Bradley (2013-11-22). "Fuel Cells at Center Stage". The New York Times. Retrieved 2013-11-26. 
  4. ^ Davies, Alex (2013-11-22). "Honda Is Working On Hydrogen Technology That Will Generate Power Inside Your Car". The Business Insider. Retrieved 2013-11-26. 
  5. ^ Thames & Kosmos kit, Other educational materials, and many more demonstration car kits.
  6. ^ "New Hydrogen-Powered Land Speed Record from Ford". Motorsportsjournal.com. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  7. ^ Whoriskey, Peter. "The Hydrogen Car Gets Its Fuel Back", Washington Post, October 17, 2009
  8. ^ a b "Hydrogen fuel cells to hit showrooms by 2013", Collision Repair Magazine, 7 June 2012
  9. ^ Alan Ohnsman. "GM to Maintain Hydrogen Push as Plug-In Volt Readied for Sale". BusinessWeek, March 17, 2010
  10. ^ a b Richard Truett (2013-11-21). "Fuel cell nearing leap from lab to highway". Automotive News. Retrieved 2013-12-01. 
  11. ^ Associated Press (2012-09-24). "Toyota beefs up green vehicles, plans electric car for this year, fuel cell vehicle by 2015". Toledo Blade. Retrieved 2013-12-01. 
  12. ^ Kubota, Yoko (2013-10-10). "Toyota says slashes fuel cell costs by nearly $1 million for new hydrogen car". Reuters. Retrieved 2013-12-01. 
  13. ^ "Nissan Starts Vehicle Testing of New Fuel-cell Technology". Japanesesportcars.com. 2009-02-25. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  14. ^ "Hyundai Debuts All New" Hyundai Australia, July 2011
  15. ^ Bloomberg News (24 August 2009). "Hydrogen-powered vehicles on horizon". Washington Times. Retrieved 5 September 2009. 
  16. ^ Abuelsamid, Sam. "Honda pulls out of Frankfurt to save costs, starts testing FCX in Germany", AutoBloggreen, April 2, 2009
  17. ^ Ohnsman, Alan. "Honda Says Hydrogen Auto Fuel Cell Know-How Helped Speed Battery-Car Plan". Bloomberg.com, December 16, 2010
  18. ^ Brian Warshay, Brian. "The Great Compression: the Future of the Hydrogen Economy", Lux Research, Inc. January 2013
  19. ^ "Hydrogen scooter by vectrix". Jalopnik.com. 2007-07-13. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  20. ^ "Suzuki Burgman fuel-cell scooter". Hydrogencarsnow.com. 2009-10-27. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  21. ^ "Fhybrid fuel cell-electric hybrid scooter". Io.tudelft.nl. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  22. ^ Burgman_Fuel-Cell_Scooter
  23. ^ APFCT won Taiwan BOE project contract for 80 FC scooters fleet demonstration
  24. ^ "Autostudi S.r.l. H-Due". Ecofriend.org. 2008-04-15. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  25. ^ New Holland Wins Gold for Energy Independent Farm Concept or Hydrogen-powered tractor in an Energy Independent Farm
  26. ^ "Ion tiger hydrogen UAV". Sciencedaily.com. 2009-10-15. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  27. ^ David Robertson (3 April 2008). "Boeing tests first hydrogen powered plane". London: The Times. 
  28. ^ "oeing's 'Phantom Eye' Ford Fusion powered stratocraft". The Register. 2010-07-13. Retrieved 2010-07-143. 
  29. ^ "Hydrogen engines get a lift". Accessmylibrary.com. 2008-10-01. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  30. ^ a b HyICE
  31. ^ Press release: "Fuel Cell Forklifts Gain Ground", fuelcells.org, July 9, 2013
  32. ^ Fuel cell technologies program overview
  33. ^ Economic Impact of Fuel Cell Deployment in Forklifts and for Backup Power under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act
  34. ^ "Fact Sheet: Materials Handling and Fuel Cells"
  35. ^ Hylift
  36. ^ First hydrogen station for fuel cell forklift trucks in France, for IKEA
  37. ^ HyPulsion
  38. ^ HyGear delivers hydrogen system for fuel cell based forklift trucks
  39. ^ "Hydrogen Fueling Stations Could Reach 5,200 by 2020". Environmental Leader: Environmental & Energy Management News, 20 July 2011, accessed 2 August 2011
  40. ^ Full Fuel-Cycle Comparison of Forklift Propulsion Systems
  41. ^ Fuel cell technology
  42. ^ Fuel cell forklift
  43. ^ "Rocket propulsion". Braeunig.us. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  44. ^ "Fuel cell use in the Space Shuttle". NASA. Retrieved 2012-02-17. 
  45. ^ 1807 Francois Isaac de Rivaz - internal combustion engine
  46. ^ Linde X39
  47. ^ Copeland, Michael V. "The hydrogen car fights back", Fortune magazine, October 14, 2009
  48. ^ a b c Eberle, Ulrich; Mueller, Bernd; von Helmolt, Rittmar (2012-07-15). "Fuel cell electric vehicles and hydrogen infrastructure: status 2012". Royal Society of Chemistry. Retrieved 2013-01-08. 
  49. ^ "COE researchers engineer low-cost catalyst for hydrogen production". Engr.wisc.edu. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  50. ^ "Accomplishments and Progress". Fuel Cell Technology Program, U.S. Dept. of Energy, June 24, 2011
  51. ^ "DOE Fuel Cell Technologies Program Record", U.S. Dept. of Energy, September 14, 2012
  52. ^ From the Ballard website
  53. ^ United States Department of Energy, http://www1.eere.energy.gov/hydrogenandfuelcells/
  54. ^ "EERE Service life 5000 hours" (PDF). Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  55. ^ "Fuel Cell School Buses: Report to Congress" (PDF). Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  56. ^ a b Schultz, M.G., Thomas Diehl, Guy P. Brasseur, and Werner Zittel. "Air Pollution and Climate-Forcing Impacts of a Global Hydrogen Economy", Science, October 24, 2003 302: 624-627
  57. ^ "FCT Hydrogen Production: Natural Gas Reforming". .eere.energy.gov. 15 December 2008. Retrieved 19 October 2009. 
  58. ^ F. Kreith, "Fallacies of a Hydrogen Economy: A Critical Analysis of Hydrogen Production and Utilization" in Journal of Energy Resources Technology (2004), 126: 249–257.
  59. ^ a b "From TechnologyReview.com "Hell and Hydrogen", March 2007". Technologyreview.com. Retrieved 2011-01-31. 
  60. ^ a b Bossel, Ulf. "Does a Hydrogen Economy Make Sense?" Proceedings of the IEEE, Vol. 94, No. 10, October 2006
  61. ^ Heetebrij, Jan. "A vision on a sustainable electric society supported by Electric Vehicles", Olino Renewable Energy, June 5, 2009
  62. ^ a b Romm, Joseph. "Climate and hydrogen car advocate gets almost everything wrong about plug-in cars", The Energy Collective, October 6, 2009
  63. ^ a b Suplee, Curt. "Don't bet on a hydrogen car anytime soon". Washington Post, November 17, 2009
  64. ^ L. Soler, J. Macanás, M. Muñoz, J. Casado. Journal of Power Sources 169 (2007) 144-149
  65. ^ F. Kreith (2004). "Fallacies of a Hydrogen Economy: A Critical Analysis of Hydrogen Production and Utilization". Journal of Energy Resources Technology 126: 249–257.
  66. ^ "US Energy Information Administration, "World Primary Energy Production by Source, 1970–2004"". Eia.doe.gov. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  67. ^ Galbraith, Kate and Matthew L. Wald. "Energy Goals a Moving Target for States", The New York Times, December 4, 2008
  68. ^ Iceland's hydrogen buses zip toward oil-free economy. Retrieved 17-July-2007.
  69. ^ First Danish Hydrogen Energy Plant Is Operational. Retrieved 17-July-2007.
  70. ^ "Light Weight Hydrogen 'Tank' Could Fuel Hydrogen Economy". Sciencedaily.com. 2008-11-05. Retrieved 2010-12-12. 
  71. ^ ”Hydrazine fuels hydrogen power hopes.” ChemistryWorld.com, March 2011.
  72. ^ The Drive Toward Hydrogen Vehicles Just Got Shorter. ChemNews.com, March 2011.
  73. ^ Henry, Jim (October 29, 2007). "GM's Fuel-Cell Hedge". BusinessWeek. Retrieved 9 May 2008. 
  74. ^ Gardner, Michael (November 22, 2004). "Is 'hydrogen highway' the answer?". San Diego Union-Tribune. Retrieved 9 May 2008. 
  75. ^ Stanley, Dean. "Shell Takes Flexible Approach to Fueling the Future". hydrogenforecast.com. Archived from the original on January 21, 2008. Retrieved 9 May 2008. 
  76. ^ Romm, Joseph (2004). The Hype about Hydrogen, Fact and Fiction in the Race to Save the Climate. New York: Island Press. ISBN 1-55963-703-X.  (ISBN 1-55963-703-X), Chapter 5
  77. ^ Ingram, Antony. "RIP Hydrogen Highway? California Takes Back Grant Dollars", Green Car Reports, June 5, 2012
  78. ^ "California Fuel Cell Partnership". 
  79. ^ "Filling the Tank with Hydrogen". Berkely Transportation Letter. University of California at Berkeley. Winter 2011. Retrieved January 21, 2011. 
  80. ^ "Cluster Successes in South Carolina" (PDF). Retrieved 2011-01-31. 
  81. ^ "DOE codes and standards". Hydrogen.energy.gov. Retrieved 2011-01-31. 
  82. ^ http://www1.eere.energy.gov/hydrogenandfuelcells/pdfs/benefits.pdf
  83. ^ Meyers, Jeremy P. "Getting Back Into Gear: Fuel Cell Development After the Hype". The Electrochemical Society Interface, Winter 2008, pp. 36–39, accessed August 7, 2011
  84. ^ White, Charlie. "Hydrogen fuel cell vehicles are a fraud" Dvice TV, July 31, 2008
  85. ^ Squatriglia, Chuck. "Hydrogen Cars Won't Make a Difference for 40 Years", Wired, May 12, 2008
  86. ^ a b Boyd, Robert S. (May 15, 2007). "Hydrogen cars may be a long time coming". McClatchy Newspapers. Retrieved 9 May 2008. 
  87. ^ Neil, Dan (February 13, 2009). "Honda FCX Clarity: Beauty for beauty's sake". Los Angeles Times. Retrieved 11 March 2009. 
  88. ^ GM, Edward Taylor and Mike Spector. "Toyota Doubtful on Fuel Cells' Mass Use", The Wall Street Journal, March 5, 2008
  89. ^ a b c Wrigglesworth, Phil. "The car of the perpetual future"' September 4, 2008, retrieved on September 15, 2008
  90. ^ a b "Hydrogen Cars' Lifecycle Emits More Carbon Than Gas Cars, Study Says", Digital Trends, January 1, 2010
  91. ^ Chatsko, Maxx. "1 Giant Obstacle Keeping Hydrogen Fuel Out of Your Gas Tank", The Motley Fool, November 23, 2013
  92. ^ Blanco, Sebastian. "VW's Krebs talks hydrogen, says 'most efficient way to convert energy to mobility is electricity'", AutoblogGreen, November 20, 2013
  93. ^ Ballard signs deal with Volkswagen for fuel cell project
  94. ^ a b Davies, Alex. "Honda Is Working On Hydrogen Technology That Will Generate Power Inside Your Car", The Business Insider, November 22, 2013
  95. ^ "US government news release". Pnl.gov. 2006-12-11. Retrieved 2011-01-31. 
  96. ^ "Domestic Energy use in the UK". Powerwatch. Retrieved 2011-01-31. 
  97. ^ "CR4 - Blog Entry: Transformer Efficiency Standards Proposed". Google.co.uk. 6 November 2006. Retrieved 19 September 2009. 
  98. ^ http://www.pluginhighway.ca/PHEV2007/proceedings/PluginHwy_PHEV2007_PaperReviewed_Valoen.pdf
  99. ^ Stewart, Ben (4 April 2008). "Chevy Volt Plug-in Car Batteries Ready for 2010 - GM Technical Center". Popular Mechanics. Retrieved 19 September 2009. 
  100. ^ Romm, Joseph and Prof. Andrew A. Frank. "Hybrid Vehicles Gain Traction", Scientific American (April 2006)
  101. ^ "Plug-in Hybrid Advocacy Group". Pluginpartners.org. Retrieved 2011-01-31. 
  102. ^ "Car Fueled With Biogas From Cow Manure: WWU Students Convert Methane Into Natural Gas"
  103. ^ "Worldwide NGV Statistics". NGV Journal. Retrieved 2012-04-24. 
  104. ^ "The Last Car You Would Ever Buy – Literally: Why we shouldn't get excited by the latest hydrogen cars", Technology Review, June 18, 2008
  105. ^ "Efficiency of Hydrogen PEFC, Diesel-SOFC-Hybrid and Battery Electric Vehicles" (PDF). 15 July 2003. Retrieved January 7, 2009. 
  106. ^ "Information from". cta.ornl.gov. Retrieved 2011-01-31.  See also the cost comparison tables here: Buchmann, Isidor. "Batteries against fossil fuel", accessed March 15, 2011. Excerpted from Buchman, Isidor. Batteries in a Portable World – A Handbook on Rechargeable Batteries for Non-Engineers (3rd edition), 2011, Cadex Electronics Inc. ISBN 0-9682118-2-8
  107. ^ Dansie, Mark. "Hydrogen vs Electric", revolution-green.com, July 4, 2013
  108. ^ Transitions to alternative vehicles and fuels
  109. ^ Toyota’s Hydrogen vs. Tesla’s Batteries: Which Car Will Win?
  110. ^ L.A. Auto Show: Will fuel cells make battery electric cars obsolete?
  111. ^ King, Danny. “Li-ion battery prices still headed way, way down, to $180/kWh by 2020”, ‘’AutoblogGreen’’, November 8, 2013
  112. ^ Insight: Electric cars head toward another dead end
  113. ^ "2013 Nissan Leaf Gets Fuel Economy, Range Improvement, Says EPA", Edmunds.com, May 3, 2013
  114. ^ Jablansky, Jeffrey. "First ride: 2014 Mercedes-Benz B-Class Electric Drive will beat Nissan Leaf in range, boasts Tesla-built battery", New York Daily News, October 29, 2013
  115. ^ Welsh, Jonathan. "Is Tesla Model S the Cure for 'Range Anxiety?'", Wall Street Journal, November 24, 2013
  116. ^ Scauzillo, Steve. "L.A. Auto Show drives new green-car market", The Trentonian, November 23, 2013

External links[edit]