From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - View original article

  (Redirected from Crowd funding)
Jump to: navigation, search

Crowdfunding is the practice of funding a project or venture by raising monetary contributions from a large number of people, typically via the internet.[1] One early-stage equity expert described it as “the practice of raising funds from two or more people over the internet towards a common Service, Project, Product, Investment, Cause, and Experience or SPPICE.”[2]

The crowdfunding model is fueled by three types of actors: the project initiator who proposes the idea and/or project to be funded; individuals or groups who support the idea; and a moderating organization (the "platform") that brings the parties together to launch the idea.[3]

In 2013, the crowdfunding industry grew to be over $5.1 billion worldwide.[4]


According to, the earliest recorded use of the word "crowdfunding" was by Michael Sullivan in fundavlog[5] in August 2006.[6]

A possible early precursor of the crowdfunding business model could be the concept of collective fundraising or praenumeration, a subscription business model, which was used in the 17th century to finance publications planned but not yet printed.[7]

Crowdfunding gained traction in the United States after the launch of ArtistShare, the first online platform for crowdfunding, in 2003.[8][9][10] Following ArtistShare, more crowdfunding sites started to appear on the web such as ChipIn (2005), EquityNet (2005),[11] Pledgie (2006), Sellaband (2006), IndieGoGo (2008), GiveForward (2008), FundRazr (2009), Kickstarter (2009), RocketHub (2009), Fundly (2009), GoFundMe (2010), Microventures (2010) and Fundageek (2011).[10][12]

Crowdfunding websites helped companies and individuals worldwide raise US$89 million from members of the public in 2010, US$1.47 billion in 2011 and US$2.66 billion in 2012—US$1.6 billion of the 2012 amount was raised in North America.[13] In 2012 more than one million individual campaigns were established globally[14] and the industry was projected to grow to US$5.1 billion in 2013.[14]

A May 2014 report, released by the United Kingdom-based The Crowdfunding Centre and titled "The State of the Crowdfunding Nation", presented data showing that during the month of March 2014, more than US$60,000 dollars were raised on an hourly basis via global crowdfunding initiatives. Also during this time period, 442 crowdfunding campaigns were launched globally on a daily basis.[15]

Types of crowdfunding[edit]

The Crowdfunding Centre's May 2014 report identified the existence of two primary types of crowdfunding:

  1. Reward-based crowdfunding: entrepreneurs pre-sell a product or service to launch a business concept without incurring debt or sacrificing equity/shares.
  2. Equity-based crowdfunding: the backer receives unlisted shares of a company, usually in its early stages, in exchange for the money pledged. The company's success is determined by how successfully it can demonstrate its viability.[15]

Reward-based crowdfunding[edit]

Reward-based crowdfunding has been used for a wide range of purposes, including motion picture promotion,[16] free software development, inventions development, scientific research,[17] and civic projects.[18]

For a joint study between Toronto, Canada's York University and Universite Lille Nord de France, in Lille, France, published on June 2, 2014, two types of reward-based crowdfunding were identified: "'Keep-it-All' (KIA) where the entrepreneurial firm sets a fundraising goal and keeps the entire amount raised regardless of whether or not they meet their goal, and 'All-or-Nothing' (AON) where the entrepreneurial firm sets a fundraising goal and keeps nothing unless the goal is achieved."[19] The study's researchers analyzed 22,875 crowdfunding campaigns, with targets of between US$5,000 and US$200,000, and concluded: "Overall, [all-or-nothing] fundraising campaigns involved substantially larger capital goals, and were much more likely to be successful at achieving their goals." In its review of the study outcomes, the publication explained that potential investors are more inclined to support "all-or-nothing strategy" initiatives, whereby a substandard product will not be released if the funding goal is not achieved. The review concluded that "AON" campaign typically provide more detailed information on the campaign.[20]

Equity-based crowdfunding[edit]

Equity-based crowdfunding is the collective effort of individuals to support efforts initiated by other people or organizations through the provision of finance in the form of equity.[21][22] In the United States, legislation that is mentioned in the 2012 JOBS Act will allow for a wider pool of small investors with fewer restrictions following the implementation of the act.[22]

Credit-based crowdfunding[edit]

In the U.S., credit-based crowdfunding from non-banks became more prominent as a form of crowdfunding in 2012, with the launch of the Lending Club, a which had advanced more than US$500 million in loans via its website by April 2012. Prospective borrowers of the Lending Club first submit their requirements, and are then matched with pools of investors who are willing to accept the credit terms. Platforms such as the Lending Club gained popularity, as banks increased interest rates or reduced their level of lending activity. Another credit-based platform,, was established in 2006 and had funded nearly US$325 million in personal loans by April 2012.[23]

Role of the crowd[edit]

The inputs of the individuals in the crowd trigger the crowdfunding process and influence the ultimate value of the offerings or outcomes of the process. Each individual acts as an agent of the offering, selecting and promoting the projects in which they believe. They will sometimes play a donor role oriented towards providing help on social projects. In some cases they will become shareholders and contribute to the development and growth of the offering. Each individual disseminates information about projects they support in their online communities, generating further support (promoters).

Motivation for consumer participation stems from the feeling of being at least partly responsible for the success of others’ initiatives (desire for patronage), striving to be a part of a communal social initiative (desire for social participation), and seeking a payoff from monetary contributions (desire for investment).[3]

An individual who takes part in crowdfunding initiatives tends to reveal several distinct traits: innovative orientation, which stimulates the desire to try new modes of interacting with firms and other consumers; social identification with the content, cause or project selected for funding, which sparks the desire to be a part of the initiative; (monetary) exploitation, which motivates the individual to participate by expecting a payoff.[3][22]

Crowdfunding platforms[edit]

As of 2012, there were over 450 crowdfunding platforms.[24] Project creators need to do their own due diligence in order to understand which platform is the best to use depending on the type of project that they want to launch.[22] There are fundamental differences in the services provided by many crowdfunding platforms.[3]

For instance, CrowdCube and Seedrs are both Internet platforms which enable small companies to issue shares over the Internet and receive small investments from registered users in return. While CrowdCube is meant for users to invest small amounts and acquire shares directly in start-up companies, Seedrs on the other hand pools the funds to invest in new businesses, as a nominated agent.[25]

Crowdfunding platforms serve as a "network orchestrators". They create the necessary organizational systems and conditions for resource integration among other players to take place.[3]

Relational mediators act as an intermediary between supply and demand (e.g., SellaBand, Kickstarter). They replace traditional intermediaries (such as traditional record companies, venture capitalists). These platforms link new artists, designers, project initiators with committed supporters who believe in the persons behind the projects strongly enough to provide monetary support.[citation needed]

Growth engines focus on the strong inclusion of investors. They dis-intermediate by eliminating the activity of a service provider previously involved in the network. The platforms that use crowdfunding to seek stakes from a community of high net worth, private investors and match them directly with project initiators.[citation needed]

Significant campaigns[edit]

Early Campaigns[edit]

In 1997 fans underwrote an entire U.S. tour for the British rock group Marillion, raising US$60,000 in donations by means of a fan-based Internet campaign.[26][27] The idea was conceived and managed by fans without any involvement from the band;[28] although Marillion has since used this method successfully as a way to fund the recording and marketing of its albums, like Anoraknophobia (2001), Marbles (2004), Happiness is the Road (2008), and Sounds That Can't Be Made (2012).[29]

In the film industry, independent writer/director Mark Tapio Kines designed a website in 1997 for his then-unfinished first feature film Foreign Correspondents. By early 1999, he had raised more than US$125,000 on the Internet from at least 25 fans, providing him with the funds to complete his film.[30]

Electric Eel Shock, a Japanese rock band in 2004 raised £10,000 from 100 fans (the Samurai 100) by offering them a lifetime membership on the band's guestlist.[31] Two years later, they became the fastest band to raise a US$50,000 budget on SellaBand.[32]

Franny Armstrong later created a donation system for her feature film The Age of Stupid.[33] Over five years, from June 2004 to June 2009 (release date), she raised £1,500,000.[34] In December 2004, French entrepreneurs and producers Benjamin Pommeraud and Guillaume Colboc, launched a public Internet donation campaign [35] to fund their short science fiction film, Demain la Veille (Waiting for Yesterday). Within a month, they managed to raise 17,000 online, allowing them to shoot their film.[citation needed]

Highest Grossing Campaigns[edit]

The highest reported funding by a crowdfunded project to date is Star Citizen, an online space trading and combat video game being developed by Chris Roberts and Cloud Imperium Games,[36] which—as of 10 March 2014—claimed to have raised USD$40,000,000, beating the previous record of $10,266,844 set by Pebble Watch.[37]

Another highly successful campaign was initiated by the Tile App company that raised US$2.6 million by July 2013 on the Selfstarter crowdfunding platform.[38] The startup was only looking for US$20,000 to add to the US$200,000 support it had received from Silicon Valley accelerator Tandem Capital. The Tile product is a small device that assists users to locate lost items and works in tandem with an app. The physical product can be attached to items such as keychains, bags and bikes. [39]

Kickstarter Campaigns[edit]

On April 17, 2014, the Guardian media outlet published a list of "20 of the most significant projects" launched on the Kickstarter platform prior to the date of publication:

For the past 35 years I have collected amazing specimens ... I then carefully break those specimens down into smaller pieces, embed them in acrylic ... Each mini museum is a handcrafted, individually numbered limited edition ... The majority of these specimens were acquired directly from contacting specialists recommended to me by museum curators, research scientists and university historians.[41]


Although musician Palmer raised over one million dollars through the Kickstarter crowdfunding process, she received criticism afterwards, some of which was published in prominent media outlets. Writing for the New Yorker, Joshua Clover initially focused upon issues specific to Palmer, but then broadened the scope of his examination to include financial conduct in the Internet era. ("you can’t spell Internet without intern.") According to Clover, Palmer initially invited local musicians to play on stage with her and her band at of the stops on her U.S. tour, but offered to “feed you beer, hug/high-five you up and down (pick your poison), give you merch, and thank you mightily,” instead of monetary compensation, as the money raised on Kickstarter was allocated to the production of the next studio album—in accordance with the campaign—as well as other financial commitments.[45] This decision was then overturned a week later, as Palmer explained on her blog:

my management team tweaked and reconfigured financials, pulling money from this and that other budget (mostly video) and moving it to the tour budget. all of the money we took out of those budgets is going to the crowd-sourced musicians fund. we are going to pay the volunteer musicians every night ... We're also retroactively sending a payment to the folks who've already played with us.[45]

Clover also made reference to the British political situation at the time, writing "that even newly minted haves, like Amanda Palmer, really need to treat have-nots, such as local musicians, a whole lot better." In a September 12, 2012 New York Times article, American Federation of Musicians President Raymond M. Hair Jr. explained, "If there's a need for the musician to be on the stage, then there ought to be compensation for it."[46] The following day, prominent sound engineer and musician Steve Albini was also vocal and, after initially referring to Palmer as an "idiot," apologized, writing that he had not met her or heard her music. Following his apology, in which he admits "it's my fault," Albini asserted: "It should be obvious also that having gotten over a million dollars from such an effort that it is just plain rude to ask for further indulgences from your audience, like playing in your backing band for free."[47]

Controversy arose in the crowdfunding sector in May 2014 when an adult entertainer was blocked by platform GiveForward. Following an allergy reaction, Eden Alexander required intensive medical treatment, but doctors, aware of her occupation, associated her health issue with drug use and didn't provide the necessary care to a sufficient extent; as a consequence, Alexander's condition worsened. Alexander then launched a GiveForward crowdfunding campaign to cover her medical bills, but the campaign was removed from the platform after a social media exchange, whereby a potential donor requested nude pictures as reciprocation and Alexander agreed to the offer—this was noticed within a brief time frame and WePay, the payment service used by GiveForward, deemed the negotiation a violation of WePay's terms of service (TOS), considering it the offer of "Adult or adult-related services ... Adult or adult-related content ... and Obscene or pornographic items.” Alexander restarted her crowdfunding campaign by using the services of[48] The campaign ended on June 13, 2014 with $10,550 raised.[49]

A previous sex industry-related incident affected Andre Shakti, a Bay Area, San Francisco, U.S. sex worker who raised funds on, a platform that promotes itself as an avenue to "Raise Money for Anything.", to attend the 2014 Feminist Porn Awards in Toronto, Canada. Shakti raised US$545 in early 2014, a total that was in excess of her target, and attempted to purchase her plane ticket, but was hindered, like Alexander, by WePay. WePay operates a credit card processor and prevented Shakti from redeeming the funds she had raised; instead, Shakti was informed that she had violated WePay's Terms of Service and her funds could therefore not be processed. Shakti's contributors were refunded, while Kristina Dolgin, director of the Bay Area Chapter of the Sex Worker Outreach Project, in an open letter to Fundly on March 11, 2014, wrote: "Fundly cannot claim to be accessible to all while contracting with a credit card processing company that explicitly is not. This practice is opaque, unfair, and harmful to our disparaged community."[50]

Following the Alexander incident of May 2014, WePay CEO Bill Clerico wrote an explanation of their TOS in relation to adult services to the TechCrunch media outlet:

WePay faces tremendous scrutiny from its partners & card networks around the enforcement of policy, especially when it comes to adult content. We must enforce these policies or we face hefty fines or the risk of shutdown for the many hundreds of thousands of merchants on our service. We’re incredibly sorry that these policies added to the difficulties that Eden is facing. We offered to help her setup a new campaign that complied with our policies, but I believe that her friends chose to work with another company instead. We continue to stand by to help if Eden would like to work with us further, and we are reviewing both our Terms of Service & account shutdown process to see how we can avoid situations like this in the future.[49]

Clerico further stated that such practice is "is a relatively common requirement in the industry" and assured the TechCrunch writer that WePay agreed to cease Alexander's campaign "because we are contractually required to."[49]

Crowdfunding applications[edit]

Crowdfunding is being experimented with as a funding mechanism for creative work such as blogging and journalism,[51] music, independent film,[52][53] and for funding startup companies.[54][55][56][57] Community music labels are usually for-profit organizations where "fans assume the traditional financier role of a record label for artists they believe in by funding the recording process".[58]

Since pioneering crowdfunding in the film industry, Spanner Films has published a "how to" guide.[59] A Financialist article published in mid-September 2013 stated that "the niche for crowdfunding exists in financing films with budgets in the [US]$1 to $10 million range" and crowdfunding campaigns are "much more likely to be successful if they tap into a significant pre-existing fan base and fulfill an existing gap in the market."[60] Innovative new platforms, such as RocketHub, have emerged that combine traditional funding for creative work with branded crowdsourcing—helping artists and entrepreneurs unite with brands "without the need for a middle man."[61]

Philanthropy and civic projects[edit]

A variety of crowdfunding platforms have emerged to allow ordinary web users to support specific philanthropic projects without the need for large amounts of money.[18]

Global Giving allows individuals to browse through a selection of small projects proposed by nonprofit organizations worldwide, donating funds to projects of their choice. Microcredit crowdfunding platforms such as Kiva (organization) and Wokai facilitate crowdfunding of loans managed by microcredit organizations in developing countries.

The US-based nonprofit Zidisha offers a new twist on these themes, applying a direct person-to-person lending model to microcredit lending for low-income small business owners in developing countries. Zidisha borrowers who pass a background check may post microloan applications directly on the Zidisha website, specifying proposed credit terms and interest rates. Individual web users in the US and Europe can lend as little as one US dollar, and Zidisha's crowdfunding platform allows lenders and borrowers to engage in direct dialogue. Repaid principal and interest is returned to the lenders, who may withdraw the cash or use it to fund new loans.[62], founded in 2000, allows public school teachers in the United States to request materials for their classrooms. Individuals can lend money to teacher-proposed projects, and the organization fulfills and delivers supplies to schools. There are also a number of own-branded university crowdfunding websites, which enable students and staff to create projects and receive funding from alumni of the university or the general public.

Several dedicated civic crowdfunding platforms have emerged in the US and the UK, some of which have led to the first direct involvement of governments in crowdfunding.

Real estate crowdfunding[edit]

Real estate crowdfunding is the online pooling of capital from investors to fund mortgages secured by real estate, such as "fix and flip" redevelopment of distressed or abandoned properties, and equity for commercial and residential projects, acquisition of pools of distressed mortgages, home buyer down payments and similar real estate related outlets. Investment, via specialised online platforms, is generally completed under Title II of the JOBS Act and is limited to accredited investors. The platforms offer low minimum investments, often $100 – $10,000.[63][64]

Intellectual property exposure[edit]

One of the challenges of posting new ideas on crowdfunding sites is there may be little or no intellectual property (IP) protection provided by the sites themselves. Once an idea is posted, it can be copied. As Slava Rubin, founder of IndieGoGo said: “We get asked that all the time, ‘How do you protect me from someone stealing my idea?’ We’re not liable for any of that stuff.”[65] Inventor advocates, such as Simon Brown, founder of the UK-based United Innovation Association, counsel that ideas can be protected on crowdfunding sites through early filing of patent applications, use of copyright and trademark protection as well as a new form of idea protection supported by the World Intellectual Property Organization called Creative Barcode.[66]

Patent disputes[edit]

On September 30, 2011, the crowdfunding site Kickstarter filed a request for declaratory judgment against Fan Funded who owns U.S. patent US 7885887 , "Methods and apparatuses for financing and marketing a creative work". Brian Camelio, founder of ArtistShare, is the inventor on the patent. Kickstarter says it believes it is under threat of a patent infringement lawsuit. Kickstarter has asked that the patent be invalidated, or, at the very least, that the court find that Kickstarter is not liable for infringement.[67][68]

In February 2012, Fan Funded responded to Kickstarter's complaint notably claiming that patent infringement litigation was never threatened, that "ArtistShare merely approached KickStarter about licensing their platform, including patent rights", and that "rather than responding to ArtistShare's request for a counter-proposal, Kickstarter filed this lawsuit."[69]

Benefits and risks[edit]

Benefits for the creator[edit]

Crowdfunding campaigns provide producers with a number of benefits, beyond the strict financial gains.[70] The following are non financial benefits of crowdfunding.

Proponents of the crowdfunding approach argue that it allows good ideas which do not fit the pattern required by conventional financiers to break through and attract cash through the wisdom of the crowd. If it does achieve "traction" in this way, not only can the enterprise secure seed funding to begin its project, but it may also secure evidence of backing from potential customers and benefit from word of mouth promotion in order to reach the fundraising goal.[22] Another potential positive effect is the propensity of groups to "produce an accurate aggregate prediction" about market outcomes as identified by author James Surowiecki in his book The wisdom of crowds, thereby placing financial backing behind ventures likely to succeed.

Proponents also identify a potential outcome of crowdfunding as an exponential increase in available venture capital. One report claims that If every American family gave one percent of their investable assets to crowdfunding, $300 billion (a 10X increase) would come into venture capital.[71] Proponents also cite that a benefit for companies receiving crowdfunding support is that they retain control of their operations, as voting rights are not conveyed along with ownership when crowdfunding.

As part of his response to the Amanda Palmer Kickstarter controversy, Albini expressed his supportive views of crowdfunding for musicians, explaining: "I've said many times that I think they're part of the new way bands and their audience interact and they can be a fantastic resource, enabling bands to do things essentially in cooperation with their audience." Albini described the concept of crowdfunding as "pretty amazing."[47]

Risks and barriers for the creator[edit]

Crowdfunding also comes with a number of potential risks or barriers.[72]

For crowdfunding of equity stock purchases, there is some research in social psychology that indicates that, like in all investments, people don't always do their due diligence to determine if it's a sound investment before investing, which leads to making investment decisions based on emotion rather than financial logic.[73]

Crowdfunding draws a crowd: investors and other interested observers who follow the progress, or lack of progress, of a project. Sometimes it proves easier to raise the money for a project than to make the project a success. Managing communications with a large number of possibly disappointed investors and supporters can be a substantial, and potentially diverting, task.[74]

Equity crowdfunding[edit]

Investment crowdfunding can breach various securities laws, because soliciting investments from the general public is often illegal, unless the opportunity has been filed with an appropriate securities regulatory authority, such as the Securities and Exchange Commission in the U.S., the Ontario Securities Commission in Ontario, Canada, the Autorité des marchés financiers in France and Quebec, Canada, or the Financial Conduct Authority in the U.K. These regulators have different ways of determining what is and what is not a security but a general rule one can rely on (at least in the U.S.) is the Howey Test. The Howey Test says that a transaction constitutes an investment contract (therefore a security) if there is (1) an exchange of money (2) with an expectation of profits arising (3) from a common enterprise (4) which depends solely on the efforts of a promoter or third party. Any crowdfunding arrangement in which investors are asked to contribute money in exchange for potential profits based on the work of others would be considered a security. As such, the applicable investment contract would have to be registered with a regulatory agency, unless it qualified for one of several exemptions (e.g., Regulation A or Rule 506 of Regulation D of the Securities Act of 1933, or the California Limited Offering Exemption – Rule 1001 (also known as S.E.C. Rule 1001)). The penalties for a securities violation can vary greatly and depend on the amount of profit obtained by the "promoter," the damage done to the investors, and whether a violation is a first time offense. According to Section 5 of the Securities Act, it is illegal to sell any security unless such a sale is accompanied or preceded by a prospectus that meets the requirements of the Securities Act.[75]

Selling investments via crowdfunding has been called crowdfund investing,[76] crowdinvesting,[77] or even simply crowdfunding, as in "legalize crowdfunding".[78] Some have called for standardization of the terminology in a way that distinguishes the practice from other forms of crowdfunding.[79] Investment crowdfunding can be debt-based or equity-based, or can follow other models, including profit-sharing and hybrid models.

Debt crowdfunding allows a group of lenders to lend funds to individuals or businesses in return for interest payment on top of capital repayments. Also known as Peer to peer lending or Peer to business lending. Borrowers must demonstrate creditworthiness and the capability to repay the debt, making it unsuitable for NINA or startups. [80]

Equity crowdfunding (also known as "hyperfunding")[81] is a mechanism that enables broad groups of investors to fund startup companies and small businesses in return for equity. Investors give money to a business and receive ownership of a small piece of that business. If the business succeeds, then its value goes up, as well as the value of a share in that business—the converse is also true. Coverage of equity crowdfunding indicates that its potential is greatest with startup businesses that are seeking smaller investments to achieve establishment, while follow-on funding (required for rapid growth) may come from other sources.[82]


Crowdfunding as a discrete activity is not prohibited in Australia when raising funds with donations. The provisions of the Corporations Act need to be considered if raising funds with either debt or equity.[83]


Local crowdfunding sites have been active in Belgium since 2011, and the legislation was adapted to cover them in April 2014. This made it possible to raise up to 300k€ per projects via crowdfunding as long as crowd investors' individual investments remained below €1000. Since this law adaptation was limited, regional governments have confirmed that further improvements of the legislation would remain a priority to address before 2019, and this was officially confirmed by the Flemish government in a published act.[84]

New Zealand[edit]

New Zealand enacted the legal framework for equity crowdfunding in 2013 [85] and multiple platforms are expected to go live in 2014. The regulations allow each New Zealand company to raise up to $2 million in any 12 months from the New Zealand public through a licensed equity crowdfunding platform without the usual offer document prescribed under securities law.


Canada's first equity crowdfunding portal is Optimize Capital Markets which launched in Ontario on September 2009.[86] In June 2013, the Ontario Securities Commission announced that it was allowing an Ontario-only portal for accredited investors.[87] The province of Saskatchewan made equity crowdfunding legal in December 2013.[88]


Crowdfunding remains unregulated in Ireland. The law with regard to crowdfunding, and in particular equity based crowdfunding is complex. Issues to be resolved and regulations to be reviewed include :

However, there are a number of websites that offer various types of crowdfunding services :


Italy has several well-functioning reward-based crowdfunding websites since 2011 (e.g., In July 2013 Italy became the first country in Europe to implement a complete regulation on equity-crowdfunding, which establishes a national registry for crowdfunding operators.[89] The first platform for equity crowdfunding went online on December 12, 2013.


Israel has yet to enact legal framework for equity crowdfunding. Therefore, any equity crowdfunding activity is currently regulated under the Israeli Securities Law which permits the offering of securities to 35 non accredited individuals and an unlimited amount of accredited investors as defined in Israel Securities Law. The Israeli Securities Authority has proposed a new regulatory framework for equity crowdfunding in Israel, which has not been adopted yet. Some of the main terms are:

There is an equity crowdfunding platform called iAngels


An Equity Crowdfunding portal was launched in Finland in May 2012 by Invesdor.[90] The legal issues around donation-based crowdfunding have been under debate in Finland as its legislation[91] around this is different from most countries. However the legislation about Equity and Rewards-based Crowdfunding is more similar to the rest of Europe, and the legal situation is clear.[92] Invesdor has also started operating in Sweden[93] and has additionally opened its service to Danish and Estonian companies.[94] The Sweden-based FundedByMe also launched their Equity Crowdfunding portal in Finland in January 2013.[95]


After two smaller projects in 2010, 2011 can be considered the first successful year for crowdfunding in Germany. The largest crowdfunding project was launched by the company Brainpool in December 2011. For the movie of the successful TV series Stromberg, the company wanted to collect one million euros by March 2012,[96] and the total amount was reached within one week.[97] Since then, various national, but also regional, platforms were founded, such as Crowd Berlin, Nordstarter for Hamburg and Dresden Durchstarter.

Additional specialized niche sites, mainly for games[98] and musicians,[99] are entering the market. At the end of 2013, a new crowdfunding platform was launched called Dreamojo,[100] which lets you collect money from anyone, for anything. Dreamojo also helps you collect money through social networks.


Crowdfunding currently falls under the Collective Investment Scheme which is regulated by the Monetary Authority of Singapore. Despite being an Asian financial center, crowdfunding platforms are illegal in Singapore.[101] There is no provision in the legislation specially for crowdfunding.

Sweden and Norway[edit]

Crowdfunding portals have also launched in Scandinavia supporting both local language crowdfunding and English language crowdfunding. The oldest active crowdfunding platform in Sweden today is crowdculture launched in 2010. The system works with a unique hybrid mechanism where crowdfunding works as abase to crowdsource public investment decisions.[102] The donation-based CrowdFunding portal FundedByMe has been active in Sweden and Norway since 2011,[103] and Swedish crowdfunding activity is evolving in parallel to Crowdfunding in the USA with Equity-Based CrowdFunding becoming active in Sweden late in 2012.[104] Invesdor also started operating in Sweden in February 2013.[93]


Turkey's crowdfunding platforms are Fonlabeni, Fongogo and Biayda.[105]

United Arab Emirates[edit]

The first crowdfunding site in the United Arab Emirates (UAE) is Aflamnah, the Dubai-based platform launched in July 2012. Aimed at extensively supporting Arab-produced film projects, its operational model is based on a hybrid form of Kickstarter and Indiegogo.[106]

The first equity crowdfunding portal for real estate in the UAE, the GCC, and the rest of the Middle East and North Africa (or MENA) region, was launched by Abu Dhabi-based Humming Crowd Realty in May 2014. The concept, which is built on Western real estate crowdfunding fundamentals, introduces global investors to property-investment opportunities that are compliant with Islamic financing principles and Sharia standards.[107][108]

United Kingdom[edit]

On 1 April 2014, the regulation of the consumer credit market transferred from the Office of Fair Trading (OFT) to the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA). This includes responsibility for regulating loan-based crowdfunding. The FCA has published a policy statement regarding crowd funding in March 2014.[109]

Abundance Generation was the first debt crowdfunding platform in the United Kingdom (UK) to be regulated by the Financial Services Authority (now the Financial Conduct Authority). It was approved in July 2011 and was launched to the public in 2012.[110] Abundance Generation provides democratic finance to UK-based renewable energy developers.[111]

On 6 July 2012, Seedrs Limited was launched as the first equity crowdfunding platform to receive regulatory approval from the Financial Services Authority.[112] In August 2012, Richard Branson announced his support for crowdfunding, crowdinvesting and crowdlending platform in the Telegraph newspaper.[113] In February 2013, the CrowdCube equity crowdfunding platform, which was launched in 2011, was authorised by the FSA.[114]

United States[edit]

Federal Legislation[edit]

Thanks in part to the Crowdfunding exemption movement, the JOBS Act was signed into law by President Obama on April 5, 2012. The U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission has been given approximately 270 days to set forth specific rules and guidelines that enact this legislation, while also ensuring the protection of investors.[115] Some rules have already been proposed by the SEC.[116][117]

The bill went through a number of amendments and on April 5, 2012 President Barack Obama signed the JOBS Act into law.[118] The legislation mandates that funding portals must register with the SEC as well as an applicable self-regulatory organization to operate.[119]

The JOBS Act places limits on the value of securities issuer may offer and individuals can invest through crowdfunding intermediaries. An issuer may sell up to $1,000,000 of its securities per 12 months, and, depending upon their net worth and income, investors will be permitted to invest up to $100,000 in crowdfunding issues per 12 months.[120] An independent financial statement review by a CPA firm is required for raises $100,000–500,000 and an independent financial statement audit by a CPA firm is required for raises over $500,000.[121]

On October 23, 2013, the SEC unanimously approved the progress of the crowdfunding bill and SEC commissioners explained that the commission's goals are to ease online fundraising for small companies and fraud protection for investors. As of the date of approval, the proposal is open for public comment for a 90-day period that is followed by another SEC vote to enable the enactment of the proposal.[122] In parallel to the SEC regulations, the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is creating additional rules related to member firms engaged in crowdfunding.[119]

State legislation[edit]

Some people see the federal crowdfunding legislation as unworkable, and several U.S. states have recently enacted or are considering their own crowdfunding exemption laws, to facilitate intrastate investment offerings that are already exempt from federal (SEC) regulation.[123] These include the Invest Kansas Exemption,[124] effective August 2011, and the Invest Georgia Exemption, effective December 2012, has $1m/$10k caps.[125] Late in 2013, both Michigan [126] and Wisconsin [127] joined Kansas and Georgia. As of April 2013, the states of Washington[128] and North Carolina[129] are considering their own crowdfunding exemptions.[130] In July 2012, the Wisconsin Department of Financial Institutions issued an advisory, about legislation proposed, intended to allow crowdfunding to raise up to $1 million from non-accredited Wisconsin investors without audited financial statements, or up to $2 million if the issuer has audited financial statements.[131]

Crowdfunding services[edit]

The JOBS Act enables equity based crowdfunding when it is conducted by a licensed broker-dealer or via a Funding Portal registered with the SEC.[132] Many Crowdfunding services have launched to fill this role, and the space is evolving rapidly. Early portal Profounder closed before SEC guidelines were released,[133] and equity portal Earlyshares acquired charity portal Helpersunite.[134] The first portal operating in the U.S. and geared towards small businesses was founded in 2010 by Alejandro Cremades and Tanya Prive and is operating under the name of Rock The Post.[135]

Crowdfunding insurance[edit]

The draft SEC rules calls for portals to purchase a fidelity bond of at least $100,000. As stated by the SEC is that a "fidelity bond .. aims to protect its holder against certain types of losses, including but not limited to those caused by malfeasance of the holder's officers and employees, and the effect of such losses on the holder's capital".[136] A fidelity bond generallly covers a corporate policyholder from first party losses arising from the theft of money, securities or other tangible property so if the portal's employees steal the funds belonging to the crowdfunding company, the bond can be useful. However, if there is a claim against the portal for negligence in providing its services as a portal, the more proper insurance policy to apply to this loss is a professional liability insurance.

See also[edit]


  1. ^ "Oxford Dictionary Definition of Crowdfunding". Retrieved July 23, 2014. ; The Merriam Webster Dictionary defines Crowdfunding as "the practice of soliciting financial contributions from a large number of people especially from the online community" "Merriam Webster Dictionary Definition of Crowdfunding". Retrieved July 23, 2014. 
  2. ^ Drake, David. "CROWDFUNDING: IT’S NO LONGER A BUZZWORD". Retrieved 16 June 2014. 
  3. ^ a b c d e "Crowdfunding: Transforming Customers Into Investors Through Innovative Service Platforms". Retrieved February 7, 2013. 
  4. ^
  5. ^ "fundavlog". 
  6. ^ "Crowdfundings earliest citation". 
  7. ^ "The Statue of Liberty and America's crowdfunding pioneer". BBC Online. April 24, 2013. Retrieved 28 April 2013. 
  8. ^ "A Brief History Of Crowdfunding". 
  9. ^ "". ; The New York Times refers to ArtistShare as a "pioneering crowd-financing platform"Chinen, Nate (May 8, 2013). "New York Times". The New York Times. 
  10. ^ a b "Can You Spare a Quarter? Crowdfunding Sites Turn Fans into Patrons of the Arts". Wharton. Dec 8, 2010. 
  11. ^ New service helps local entrepreneurs raise capital November 12, 2013 Missouri S&T Andrew Careaga
  12. ^ MALIKA ZOUHALI-WORRALL. "Comparison of Crowdfunding Websites". 
  13. ^ Global Crowdfunding Volumes Rise 81% In 2012, 04/08/2013, The Huffington Post, Retrieved at 7 September 2013
  14. ^ a b Top 10 Crowdfunding Sites For Fundraising, May 8, 2013, Chance Barnett, Forbes
  15. ^ a b Catherine Clifford (19 May 2014). "Crowdfunding Generates More Than $60,000 an Hour (Infographic)". Entrepreneur. Entrepreneur Media, Inc. Retrieved 25 May 2014. 
  16. ^ "Crowd funding: An emerging trend in Bollywood". The Times Of India. Retrieved August 12, 2012. 
  17. ^ "Crowdfunding as the future of science funding? | The Science Exchange Blog". May 27, 2012. Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  18. ^ a b "Crowdfunding and Civic Society in Europe: A Profitable Partnership?". Open Citizenship Journal. Retrieved April 29, 2013. 
  19. ^ Douglas J. Cumming, Gaël Leboeuf and Armin Schwienbacher. "Crowdfunding Models: Keep-it-All vs. All-or-Nothing" (Abstract). Social Science Research Network. Social Science Electronic Publishing, Inc. Retrieved 21 June 2014. 
  20. ^ Kimberly Weisul (19 June 2014). "In Crowdfunding, All-or-Nothing Campaigns Are More Successful". Monsueto Ventures. Retrieved 21 June 2014. 
  21. ^ Ordanini, A.; Miceli, L.; Pizzetti, M.; Parasuraman, A. (2011). "Crowd-funding: Transforming customers into investors through innovative service platforms". Journal of Service Management 22 (4): 443. doi:10.1108/09564231111155079.  (also available as Scribd document)
  22. ^ a b c d e Prive, Tanya (November 27, 2012). "What IS Crowdfunding And How Does IT Benefit The Economy". Forbes. Retrieved November 27, 2012. 
  23. ^ "Crowdfunding: John Mack backs non-bank with board role ", Euromoney, April 12, 2012.
  24. ^ "Top 10 Crowdfunding Platforms". 2012. Retrieved February 9, 2013. 
  25. ^ Roy, Ritobaan (2012-09-03). "Crowdfunding: Sideshow or Headline Act? – CFO Insight". Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  26. ^ Golemis, Dean (September 23, 1997). "British Band's U.s. Tour Is Computer-generated". Chicago Tribune. 
  27. ^ Masters, Tim (2011-11-05). "BBC News – Marillion 'understood where the internet was going early on'". Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  28. ^ "BBC article, May 11, 2001". BBC News. May 11, 2001. 
  29. ^ Jon Collins (Dec 1, 2012). Marillion: Separated Out ... Redux. Foruli Limited. ASIN 1905792409. ISBN 9781905792405. 
  30. ^ Andrew Rodgers (June 11, 1999). "Filmmaker Uses Web To Help Finance, Cast Movie". Chicago Tribune. Retrieved January 7, 2013. 
  31. ^ " "Wanna Go VIP? Electric Eel Shock'll show you the way...", Dec 2nd, 2004". 
  32. ^ "itsallhappening, June 24th, 2008". 
  33. ^ Kate Bulkley (November 24, 2012). "funding models for film making | Sheffield Doc/Fest 2010 |". London: Guardian. Retrieved December 13, 2012. 
  34. ^ "Crowd-Funding FAQ". Spanner Films. July 13, 2009. Retrieved December 13, 2012. 
  35. ^ Christina Warren (January 17, 2011). "A Guide to Kickstarter & Crowd Funding [INFOGRAPHIC]". Retrieved December 13, 2012. 
  36. ^ Brian Crecente (24 August 2013). "Star Citizen delivers hangars, the beginning of its universe, to backers". Polygon. Vox Media, Inc. Retrieved 5 November 2013. 
  37. ^ Chris Roberts. "Letter from the Chairman: $40 Million". Roberts Space Industries. Retrieved 2014-03-11. 
  38. ^ Natasha Lomas (24 July 2013). "Tile Grabs $2.6M Via Selfstarter For Its Lost Property-Finding Bluetooth Tags Plus App". TechCrunch. AOL Inc. Retrieved 14 June 2014. 
  39. ^ Sarah Perez (13 June 2013). "Tile, The Lost-Item Tracker With Millions In Crowdfunding, Was Worth The Wait". TechCrunch. AOL Inc. Retrieved 14 June 2014. 
  40. ^ "Amanda Palmer Raises $1.2 Million On Kickstarter, And The Crowd Goes Wild". June 1, 2012. Retrieved May 3, 2014. 
  41. ^ Hans Fex (29 April 2014). "Mini Museum by Hans Fex". Mini Museum on Kickstarter. Kickstarter, Inc. Retrieved 29 April 2014. 
  42. ^ Rob Thomas (29 April 2014). "The Veronica Mars Movie Project by Rob Thomas". The Veronica Mars Movie Project on Kickstarter. Kickstarter, Inc. Retrieved 29 April 2014. 
  43. ^ "THE 10-YEAR HOODIE". Flint and Tinder. Flint and Tinder. 29 April 2014. Retrieved 29 April 2014. 
  44. ^ Stuart Dredge (17 April 2014). "Kickstarter's biggest hits - why crowdfunding now sets the trends". The Guardian. Retrieved 29 April 2014. 
  45. ^ a b Amy Phillips (19 September 2012). "Amanda Palmer Starts Paying Musicians". Pitchfork. Pitchfork Media. Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  46. ^ Daniel J. Wakin (12 September 2012). "Rockers Playing for Beer: Fair Play?". The New York Times. Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  47. ^ a b Steve Albini (13 September 2012). "Re: amanda "$1.2m" palmer wants you to play with her for fre" (Forum post). Electrical Audio. Electrical Audio. Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  48. ^ |url= missing title (help). Retrieved 25 August 2014. 
  49. ^ a b c Josh Constine (18 May 2014). "WePay Withholds Funds From Sick Woman Due To Offer Of Porn For Donations". TechCrunch. AOL, Inc. Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  50. ^ Siouxsie Q (2 April 2014). "Kicked Out: Crowdsourcing Shows Its Bias". SF Weekly. Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  51. ^ "Crowdfunding journalism". idio. May 19, 2009. Retrieved May 15, 2009. 
  52. ^ Helen Pidd (April 14, 2009). "Teenagers' credit note approach to fund £1m film of Clovis Dardentor". London: Guardian. Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  53. ^ Dell, Kristina (September 4, 2008). "TIME article on crowdfunding the 'Age of Stupid'". Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  54. ^ TechCrunch "Sponsume lets projects get off the ground with Groupon-style group funding model"
  55. ^ "TechCrunch 'Grow VC launches, aiming to become the Kiva for tech startups'". February 15, 2010. Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  56. ^ Prentice, Claire (May 12, 2010). "'Cash-strapped entrepreneurs get creative'". BBC News. Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  57. ^ Crowdfunding Rules Could Create Mini-Disclosure Regime WSJ/CFO Journal, October 24, 2013 Emily Chasan
  58. ^ Kappel, Tim, "Ex Ante Crowdfunding and the Recording Industry: A Model for the U.S.?" in Loyola of Los Angeles Entertainment Law Review, Vol.29, Issue 3, p.376
  59. ^ "How to crowd fund your film". Spanner Films. Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  60. ^ Jens Erik Gould (12 September 2013). "In Hollywood, Crowdfunding Isn’t Just for No-Names". The Financialist. Credit Suisse. Retrieved 13 September 2013. 
  61. ^ Bell, Melissa. "Crowd-sourcing a brand", The Washington Post, March 12, 2011, accessed September 3, 2011.
  62. ^ "Is Microfinance for You?", SecondAct, April 17, 2012.
  63. ^ O'Connell, Jonathan (9 June 2013) "Fundrise faces off with skeptical financial services industry over crowd-funded real estate". Washington Post. Retrieved 26 June 2014.
  64. ^ Simon, Ruth and Brown, Eliot(11 June 2014). "Real-Estate Sector Moves Crowdfunding Beyond the Trinkets". Wall Street Journal. Retrieved 26 June 2014 (subscription required).
  65. ^ Mike Drummond, “Making it Rain: Seeking Seed Money from the Crowd”, Inventors Digest, August 2011
  66. ^ Simon Brown. "Simon Brown, "Follow the Crowd", Intellectual Property Magazine, July 2011". Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  67. ^ Sarah Jacobsson Purewal, Kickstarter Faces Patent Suit Over Funding Idea, PCWorld, October 5, 2011. Consulted on October 6, 2011.
  68. ^ Eriq Gardner, KickStarter Seeks To Protect Fan-Funding Model From Patent Threat, The Hollywood Reporter, October 4, 2011. Consulted on October 15, 2011.
  69. ^ Eriq Gardner (February 16, 2012). "Hollywood Docket: Comedy Club Documentary Lawsuit; Michael Jordan vs. 1st Amendment". The Hollywood Reporter. Retrieved March 23, 2012. 
  70. ^ "Crowdfunding in a Canadian Context". Canada Media Fund. Retrieved 12 February 2013. 
  71. ^ "Gigaom: What crowdfunding means for the VC business". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  72. ^ a b "Oxford Dictionary Definition of Crowdfunding". Retrieved July 23, 2014. 
  73. ^ Isenberg, Daniel (April 23, 2012). "The Road to Crowdfunding Hell – Daniel Isenberg – Harvard Business Review". Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  74. ^ Jenna Wortham (September 17, 2012). "Success of Crowdfunding Puts Pressure on Entrepreneurs". The New York Times. Retrieved September 18, 2012. 
  75. ^ Cohen, Corcoran & Landis. "Securities Act of 1933". Securities Act of 1933. U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission. Retrieved 5 March 2014. 
  76. ^ "Crowdfund Investing For Dummies – Sherwood Neiss, Jason W. Best, Zak Cassady-Dorion". Wiley. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  77. ^ Koren, Gijsbert. "First crowdinvesting platform with ROI » | Smarter money | weblog about crowdfunding & crowdsourcing". Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  78. ^ Mattise, Nathan (2012-03-22). "Senate passes legislation to legalize crowdfunding". Ars Technica. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  79. ^ Sang Lee (2013-04-22). "Stop Calling It Crowdfunding". Crowdfund Insider. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  80. ^ Art Patnaude (27 March 2013). "'Crowdfunding' Takes Hold in the U.K". The Wall Street Journal. 
  81. ^ "Igniting That Startup Spark". Wharton Magazine. 2013-05-16. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  82. ^ Douglas, Danielle; Overly, Steven (May 23, 2012). "Washington Post: As-regulators-set-rules-for-equity-based-crowdfunding-investors-prepare-for-its-impact". The Washington Post. Retrieved July 25, 2012. 
  83. ^ "ASIC guidance on crowd funding". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  84. ^ "Regeerakkoord van de Vlaamse Regering 2014-2019". 
  85. ^ "Getting up with the play on crowd funding". 
  86. ^ "Matthew McGrath, CEO/Founder of Optimize Capital Markets, Joins NCFA / VEC Vancouver Equity Crowdfunding Event May 21, 2014" Retrieved 27 May 2014.
  87. ^ "OSC Approves Ontario-Only Crowdfunding Portal for Accredited Investors". Retrieved 3 July 2013.
  89. ^ "Consob disciplina con regolamento fenomeno 'equity crowdfunding' | Business | Reuters". 2009-02-09. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  90. ^ "Invesdor Launches Equity-Crowdfunding Platform That Skips The Paperwork". 
  91. ^ "Legal Challenges Related To Crowdfunding, Volume 1". 
  92. ^ "Legal Challenges Related To Crowdfunding: Volume 2". 
  93. ^ a b "Suomalainen joukkorahoituspalvelu Ruotsiin". 
  94. ^ "Great improvements to our crowdfunding service!". 
  95. ^ "FundedByMe To Launch Branch In Finland As Crowdfunding Heats Up In The Nordics". 
  96. ^ ""Stromberg revolutionizes movie funding", Financial Times Germany, 16 December 2011". Retrieved 2013-04-24. 
  97. ^ "Stromberg, one million € in one week". Retrieved 2013-04-24. 
  98. ^ "Crowdfunding for games". Retrieved April 24, 2013. 
  99. ^ "Crowdfunding for musicians". Retrieved April 24, 2013. 
  100. ^ "Social crowdfunding platform". Retrieved 23 December 2013. 
  101. ^
  102. ^ "Arctic Start-up: Stockholm Partners With CrowdCulture To Fund Culture". 
  103. ^ "Oslo Tecknopol: Crowdfunding comes to norway". 
  104. ^ "Site Makes Pennies to Big Ideas". 
  105. ^ "Ekibin Seçtikleri". Fonlabeni (in Turkish). Tüm hakları saklıdır. September 2013. Retrieved 23 September 2013. 
  106. ^ "Rothe, Nina E, "Aflamnah: Looking for crowdfunding in the Arab World", Huffington Post, 09 May 2013". Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  107. ^ "Real estate crowdfunding in the UAE, GCC, and MENA growth corridors". Learning Islamic financing principles and Sharia standards. Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  108. ^ "Teh, Robin, "Revisiting REITs in the UAE real-estate market", Gulf News, 30 September 2013". Retrieved 19 May 2014. 
  109. ^ "Policy Statement: The FCA’s regulatory approach to crowdfunding over the internet...". Financial Conduct Authority. Retrieved 24 June 2014. 
  110. ^ "Danny Fortsen, "Fivers make the windmill turn", Sunday Times, 22 April 2012". Retrieved 2013-01-02. 
  111. ^ "About Abundance". The Abundance Positive Cycle. Abundance NRG Ltd. Retrieved 5 March 2014. 
  112. ^ "James Hurley, "Regulated financing market for start-ups launched", Telegraph, 13 July 2012". London: July 13, 2012. Retrieved August 19, 2012. 
  113. ^ Hurley, James (August 14, 2012). "Richard Branson backs 'Bank to the Future’". London: The Telegraph. Retrieved 3 September 2013. 
  114. ^ "James Hurley, "FSA gives green light to 'crowdfunding", Telegraph, 4 February 2013". London: February 4, 2013. Retrieved 2013-02-04. 
  115. ^ "HR3606". Retrieved 25 July 2012. 
  116. ^ "Crowd SEC: Rules for advertising crowdfunding". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  117. ^ "Venturebeat: SEC uses JOBS Act to set up new roadblocks to crowdfunding". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  118. ^ Landler, Mark (5 April 2012). "Obama Signs Bill to Promote Start-Up Investments". New York Times. Retrieved 6 April 2012. 
  119. ^ a b "Crowd Fnding News: FINRA Seeks Public Input on Crowdfunding Regulation". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  120. ^ "EGS: Crowdfunding Alert". Retrieved 16 Oct 2012. 
  121. ^ Denlinger, Craig. "Crowdfunding Audits". Retrieved 5 April 2012. 
  122. ^ CHRISTINE LAGORIO-CHAFKIN (23 October 2013). "Historic Crowdfunding Rules Proposed--Finally". Inc. MANSUETO VENTURES. Retrieved 24 October 2013. 
  123. ^ "Crowdfunding state by state? – William Carleton, Counselor @ Law". 2013-03-08. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  124. ^ "Office of the Kansas Securities Commissioner, KS – Invest Kansas". 2013-06-21. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  125. ^
  126. ^ McGlade, Alan (December 31, 2013). "Michigan Governor Signs Intrastate Crowdfunding Exemption". Forbes. 
  127. ^
  128. ^ "House Bill 2023" (PDF). Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  129. ^ "Invest NC Exemption" (PDF). Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  130. ^ "State Crowdfunding Law". State Crowdfunding Law. Retrieved 2013-09-03. 
  131. ^ Murphy, Patrick; Melissa York, Godfrey & Kahn S.C. (December 21, 2013). "New Tools for Raising Capital at Community Bank Holding Companies: General Solicitation and Crowdfunding". The National Law Review. Retrieved December 30, 2013. 
  132. ^ "SEC: Crowdfunding Intermediaries". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  133. ^ "Profunder Shutting Down". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  134. ^ "Crowdsourcing Dot Org: EarlyShares acquires Helpersunite". Retrieved October 15, 2012. 
  135. ^ "Crowdfunding comes to small businesses". Business Insider. Retrieved June 15, 2012. 
  136. ^

Further reading[edit]

Studies and Papers