The Cowboys traded their first-round selection (No. 18 overall) to the San Francisco 49ers in exchange for the 49ers' first- (No. 31 overall) and third- (No. 74 overall) round selections. The Cowboys did not have a selection in the seventh round, as the team traded its seventh-round selection (No. 224 overall) to the Miami Dolphins in exchange for guardRyan Cook.
Coming off their loss to the Chargers, the Cowboys hosted the Denver Broncos at home for an interconference duel. The Cowboys grabbed a 14–0 lead in the first quarter, with a 2-yard touchdown pass from quarterback Tony Romo to wide receiver Dez Bryant, followed by running back DeMarco Murray rushing for a 4-yard touchdown. The latter score occurred after a fumble by Broncos' wide receiver Eric Decker. The Broncos later got on the scoreboard, with quarterback Peyton Manning connecting on a 4-yard shovel pass to tight end Julius Thomas for a touchdown. Early in the second quarter, a 43-yard field goal by placekicker Dan Bailey gave the Cowboys a 17–7 lead. The Broncos then reeled off 21 unanswered points, with Manning adding two more touchdown passes — a 2-yarder to Decker and a 9-yarder to Thomas, followed by Manning rushing for a 1-yard touchdown on a bootleg play. A 48-yard field goal by Bailey at the end of the first half narrowed the Broncos' lead to 28–20.
In the second half, the Broncos added to their lead midway through the third quarter, with Manning connecting on a 2-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Wes Welker. However, the Cowboys subsequently began chipping away at the Broncos' lead, with Romo connecting on an 82-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Terrance Williams. A 48-yard field goal by placekicker Matt Prater gave the Broncos a 38–27 lead, but the Cowboys further narrowed the Broncos' lead, with a 2-yard touchdown pass from Romo to Bryant (with an unsuccessful two-point conversion attempt). Following an intercepted Broncos' pass, the Cowboys subsequently re-claimed the lead early in the fourth quarter, with Romo throwing a 10-yard touchdown pass to tight end Jason Witten, coupled with a two-point pass from Romo to Williams. The Broncos tied the game at 41–41 on their next possession, with a 50-yard field goal by Prater. As the shootout continued, on the Cowboys' next possession, Romo connected on a 4-yard touchdown pass to wide receiver Cole Beasley to give the Cowboys a 48–41 lead with 7:19 remaining in the fourth quarter. Manning subsequently led the Broncos on a 9-play, 73-yard drive, which culminated with running back Knowshon Moreno rushing for a 1-yard touchdown to tie the game at 48–48 with 2:24 remaining in the fourth quarter. Two plays into the Cowboys' next possession, as the Cowboys were attempting a game-winning drive, Romo was intercepted by Broncos' linebacker Danny Trevathan at the Cowboys' 24-yard line just before the two-minute warning. On the fourth play of the Broncos' final possession, the Broncos were facing a 3rd-and-1 at the Cowboys' 2-yard line, after the Cowboys had exhausted two of their three team timeouts. Moreno earned a crucial first down after Manning implored him to go down before reaching the goal line instead of scoring a touchdown, which forced the Cowboys to burn their final timeout with 1:35 remaining in the fourth quarter. After three kneel-downs by Manning, Prater nailed the game-winning 28-yard field goal as time expired.
With the narrow loss, the Cowboys moved to 2–3, and dropped to second place in the division.
Week 6: vs. Washington Redskins
Week Six: Washington Redskins at Dallas Cowboys – Game summary
at AT&T Stadium, Arlington, Texas
Date: October 13
Game time: 8:20 p.m. CDT
Game weather: Played indoors (retractable roof closed)
Dan Bailey's 34 yard field goal with 4 seconds left in the game gives the Cowboys their sixth win of the season. With the win, the Giants' four game winning streak is snapped and the Cowboys regain the top spot of the NFC East, remaining undefeated in the division.
With the Packers coming off of their first win since the injury of Aaron Rodgers, the Cowboys lead 26–3 at halftime. In the second half of the game, the Packers managed a dramatic comeback that was helped by the mistake-prone Cowboys. The Packers scored the game-winning touchdown with almost a minute left in the game. Tony Romo tried to rally back and give the Cowboys a win, but threw a interception near the 50-yard line that sealed their fate. Controversy followed the game for the Cowboys giving up a 23 point halftime lead and the play-calling of the coaching staff.
Week 16: at Washington Redskins
Week Sixteen: Dallas Cowboys at Washington Redskins – Game summary
After coming off of the dismal loss to the Packers the week before, the Cowboys managed to hold the Redskins to only two field goals to lead 14–6 at halftime. In the third quarter, Kirk Cousins threw two touchdown passes to give the Redskins a 20–14 lead at the end of the 3rd. The Cowboys, in an attempt to not repeat the mistakes of the previous week, kicked a field goal to trail 17–20 early in the 4th. The Redskins extended their lead to 23–17 with a field goal. The Cowboys marched down the field to reach a 1st and goal from the 5. After two incomplete passes and a tackle for a loss of yards, the Cowboys faced 4th and goal from the 10. Tony Romo fired a pass to DeMarco Murray in the end zone to tie the game 23–23. With the extra point good, the Cowboys lead 24–23 with 30 seconds to go. The Redskins tried to kick at least a field goal to win the game, but failed to make it pass their own 30. With the win, the Cowboys kept their playoff hopes alive and faced a do-or-die game with the Eagles.
Week 17: vs. Philadelphia Eagles
Week Seventeen: Philadelphia Eagles at Dallas Cowboys – Game summary